Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Lumberjack Nick

Lucasfilm Limiting Hasbro. What does it mean for FFG

86 posts in this topic

Disney has been very public about it's distaste for the EU and the overall direction that LucasFilm allowed it's property to be developed.  It is frankly hard to explore new and exciting stories if you have to constantly check every single detail against hundreds of books and comics.  Readdressing the EU is one of the smartest moves Disney could have made.  Disney has also been very diligent about removing references to the EU in their merchandise, take this for instance.  We know that is an E-Wing but Lego has branded it a prequel "Stealth Fighter."  That is a brilliant side step.  Also, look at the other stuff FFG has been doing with their stint with the Star Wars IP; they completely changed the RPG and made it all about the Rebellion.  WotC was all over the place when they had the RPG.  

 

Why do we get the E-Wing, Headhunter, Defender and Phantom?  The Defender/Phantom make a bit of sense, they were both in classic LucasArt games and we already know that Disney doesn't mind referencing games the classic games as seen with the HWK.  The E-Wing and Headhunter are much more puzzling to me.  Maybe they were in production prior to the EU crackdown earlier this year, or maybe Disney just doesn't mind what they throw into this game to keep it going until EP. 7 comes out and we have a whole slew of new ships.  It's anyones guess.

pgarfunkle likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The e-wing can be ugly, but it can also look pretty good like here:  http://swc.fs2downloads.com/media/screenshots/Fighters-Rebel/E-Wing/ewing15.jpg

 

But from any angle, the defender is ugly...

http://static2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20061223184054/starwars/images/0/07/Defender.jpg

 

Very menacing...</sarcasm>

 

 

 

 

If you see an E-Wing in the next movie it wont be "EU" anymore. 

 

Gosh I sure hope we don't see an E-Wing in the next movie unless it's in the distant background.   It is probably the ugliest ship ever.   

 

  Maybe if they have an advanced E-Wing or something with some extra fancy parts or something.   The E-Wing just doesn't look cool enough and if you can trust one thing from the Star Wars franchise - it's that they will try to make everything marketable.  That means Aliens, lightsabers, blasters, vehicles, ships, costumes, etc.   Anything they can make into a toy and sell they will try.  And the current E-Wing simply isn't visually impressive enough to be a cash cow.  

 

  I'd expect to see an update on the B-Wing to be honest.   That has a ton of possibilities.  

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Defender/Phantom make a bit of sense, they were both in classic LucasArt games and we already know that Disney doesn't mind referencing games the classic games as seen with the HWK.

The Z-95 had as much if not more 'screen time' then the Defender and Phantom.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Disney has been very public about it's distaste for the EU and the overall direction that LucasFilm allowed it's property to be developed.  It is frankly hard to explore new and exciting stories if you have to constantly check every single detail against hundreds of books and comics.  Readdressing the EU is one of the smartest moves Disney could have made.  Disney has also been very diligent about removing references to the EU in their merchandise, take this for instance.  We know that is an E-Wing but Lego has branded it a prequel "Stealth Fighter."  That is a brilliant side step.  Also, look at the other stuff FFG has been doing with their stint with the Star Wars IP; they completely changed the RPG and made it all about the Rebellion.  WotC was all over the place when they had the RPG.  

 

Why do we get the E-Wing, Headhunter, Defender and Phantom?  The Defender/Phantom make a bit of sense, they were both in classic LucasArt games and we already know that Disney doesn't mind referencing games the classic games as seen with the HWK.  The E-Wing and Headhunter are much more puzzling to me.  Maybe they were in production prior to the EU crackdown earlier this year, or maybe Disney just doesn't mind what they throw into this game to keep it going until EP. 7 comes out and we have a whole slew of new ships.  It's anyones guess.

 

I love the E-Wing... I want that Lego!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Bottom line is as long as Disney and Lucas are pulling in royalties from this game they are going to keep pushing out new ships. And as long as the new movies have t released we will continue to see eu just like wave 4 because Lucas film approves every ship release. Remember this was the reason why the large ships were waiting final approval.

Edited by Gungo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Disney has been very public about it's distaste for the EU and the overall direction that LucasFilm allowed it's property to be developed.  It is frankly hard to explore new and exciting stories if you have to constantly check every single detail against hundreds of books and comics.  Readdressing the EU is one of the smartest moves Disney could have made.  Disney has also been very diligent about removing references to the EU in their merchandise, take this for instance.  We know that is an E-Wing but Lego has branded it a prequel "Stealth Fighter."  That is a brilliant side step.  Also, look at the other stuff FFG has been doing with their stint with the Star Wars IP; they completely changed the RPG and made it all about the Rebellion.  WotC was all over the place when they had the RPG.  

 

Why do we get the E-Wing, Headhunter, Defender and Phantom?  The Defender/Phantom make a bit of sense, they were both in classic LucasArt games and we already know that Disney doesn't mind referencing games the classic games as seen with the HWK.  The E-Wing and Headhunter are much more puzzling to me.  Maybe they were in production prior to the EU crackdown earlier this year, or maybe Disney just doesn't mind what they throw into this game to keep it going until EP. 7 comes out and we have a whole slew of new ships.  It's anyones guess.

Erhm... That's not an E-wing. It some ship from the late clone war era. The E-wing is a ship that is first seen many years after that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Why do we get the E-Wing, Headhunter, Defender and Phantom?  The Defender/Phantom make a bit of sense, they were both in classic LucasArt games and we already know that Disney doesn't mind referencing games the classic games as seen with the HWK.  The E-Wing and Headhunter are much more puzzling to me.  Maybe they were in production prior to the EU crackdown earlier this year, or maybe Disney just doesn't mind what they throw into this game to keep it going until EP. 7 comes out and we have a whole slew of new ships.  It's anyones guess.

 

The Headhunter is as old as the Tie Defender, also from the old X-Wing/Tie Fighter games. It's also referenced in Clone Wars.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

The e-wing can be ugly, but it can also look pretty good like here:  http://swc.fs2downloads.com/media/screenshots/Fighters-Rebel/E-Wing/ewing15.jpg

 

But from any angle, the defender is ugly...

http://static2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20061223184054/starwars/images/0/07/Defender.jpg

 

Very menacing...</sarcasm>

 

Now I've stated in a previous thread that I thought the E-Wing was pretty damned ugly - BUT... maybe it's just FFG's rendition that doesn't appeal to me. Indeed there are quite a few images on the interweb that show it as a long, sleek looking fighter, and that appeals. The initial model pics, and indeed the pics on Wookiepedia make it look short and stubby. I think a stretched version would be much cooler - the EEEEE-Wing.

 

As for Disney putting the brakes on Hasbro. Is this a sign of things to come? Just how many ship designs does FFG have licence to use? And is FFG going to pop up in Disney's sights? 

I think the game will be safe in the meantime, as the toy market far outweighs the game market. X-Wing is luckily still a small fish in a big pond.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

 

If you see an E-Wing in the next movie it wont be "EU" anymore. 

 

Gosh I sure hope we don't see an E-Wing in the next movie unless it's in the distant background.   It is probably the ugliest ship ever.   

 

  Maybe if they have an advanced E-Wing or something with some extra fancy parts or something.   The E-Wing just doesn't look cool enough and if you can trust one thing from the Star Wars franchise - it's that they will try to make everything marketable.  That means Aliens, lightsabers, blasters, vehicles, ships, costumes, etc.   Anything they can make into a toy and sell they will try.  And the current E-Wing simply isn't visually impressive enough to be a cash cow.  

 

  I'd expect to see an update on the B-Wing to be honest.   That has a ton of possibilities.  

 

E-Wing is the ugliest? I take it you've never looked at a Y-Wing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Disney has been very public about it's distaste for the EU and the overall direction that LucasFilm allowed it's property to be developed.  It is frankly hard to explore new and exciting stories if you have to constantly check every single detail against hundreds of books and comics.  Readdressing the EU is one of the smartest moves Disney could have made.  Disney has also been very diligent about removing references to the EU in their merchandise, take this for instance.  We know that is an E-Wing but Lego has branded it a prequel "Stealth Fighter."  That is a brilliant side step.  Also, look at the other stuff FFG has been doing with their stint with the Star Wars IP; they completely changed the RPG and made it all about the Rebellion.  WotC was all over the place when they had the RPG.  

 

Why do we get the E-Wing, Headhunter, Defender and Phantom?  The Defender/Phantom make a bit of sense, they were both in classic LucasArt games and we already know that Disney doesn't mind referencing games the classic games as seen with the HWK.  The E-Wing and Headhunter are much more puzzling to me.  Maybe they were in production prior to the EU crackdown earlier this year, or maybe Disney just doesn't mind what they throw into this game to keep it going until EP. 7 comes out and we have a whole slew of new ships.  It's anyones guess.

Erhm... That's not an E-wing. It some ship from the late clone war era. The E-wing is a ship that is first seen many years after that.

 

Thats an E-Wing alright, it was just rebranded as something else.  Doesn't matter when the "real" E-wing was introduced, this thing was just a way for Lego to get the kit out the door after the Disney EU crack down.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It seems like Disney is planning to retcon the EU, I doubt FFG will be able to continue to use EU ships after this wave. That leaves them with have to wait for Rebels/7,8,9 or going backwards into Clonewars, prequel era.

 

Honestly....I'm not too sad about a potential stop in going deeper into the EU. With the improvments to starfighters/tech we'd just see a constant powercreep that would invalidate all our lists and force us to buy more and more models just to play properly.

At this point, I'm neither dreading nor looking forward to seeing what Disney's meddeling will bring. We just don't have enough info yet.

Lumberjack Nick likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would be willing to bet that they have enough in development to keep it going until they have all new ships to deal with from Rebels and the new movies.

Edited by Audio Weasel

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Most people in this thread seem to understand, but I'd really like to elaborate on this topic for people who are unaware of the details of Star Wars' canon and Disney's changes in policy.

 

For a long time, Star Wars continuity has been divided into a series of tiers. In order, it's G-canon, T-canon, C-canon, and S-canon (there are two more tiers, but they're not canon). G-canon is George Lucas canon, and includes the six films. T-canon is Television canon, and includes the Clone Wars movie, show, and the planned live action show. C-canon is pretty much everything else, including games and comics (though if a game has multiple choices only one will be "truly" canon obviously). S-canon is Secondary canon, and includes older stuff that was written when there was less consistency. The term "Expanded Universe" refers to everything that is not G-canon.

 

What the order of the tiers means is that when two sources contradict each other, the higher one wins and is the most "official" version. In other words, if a video game says Luke Skywalker likes wearing red, but a television show says he likes wearing blue, then he "officially" likes wearing blue.

 

However, what's relevant to this thread, is that Dinsey has now formed the Lucasfilm Story Group to rethink this system. There will no longer be a hierarchy of canon. Things will either be fully canon or fully not. As far as I'm aware, there hasn't been any specifics yet. I'm sure we'll have things even down at S-canon made official, and things from T-canon abolished, but we're completely oblivious to any specifics. There will be no more "Expanded Universe," but that's only because the things that remain will now be on equal footing with the movies.

 

That's why the Hasbro thing is relevant. Not because Fantasy Flight Games has anything to do with Hasbro, but because it's more than likely that Lucasfilm's ruling on Hasbro will be applied to other companies that make Star Wars merchandise, as part of their initiative to simplify the canon. Obviously, Lucasfilm will want to focus merchandise on the upcoming films, but we know they're redefining canon, so there's no way that restrictions specifically on Expanded Universe merchandise is irrelevant to that decision.

 

What does that mean for the X-Wing Miniatures game? No one can say yet, but it will almost certainly mean something (even if we never find out). We know that in the past FFG was working closely with Lucasfilm, so it's possible that all of the Expanded Universe stuff in the Miniatures game so far has been approved, but it's equally possible from what we know that they just haven't started really cracking down yet. The only thing we can say for sure is that based on the Hasbro ruling, we'll at least get everything that FFG has announced so far.

Lumberjack Nick likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe it's time for a new term: IU (Included Universe) ?!?

 

:blink:

IU is a good idea, spread it around...

A prime example would be Jedi Quinlan Vos, prior to his being mentioned in RotS he was just an EU character. Then he made an appearance in TCW, Hunt for Ziro episode I think. Now he is included but, how much of what he has effected in the SW universe is included?

Quinlan is part of the IU now... personally I would like to keep canon terms, characters and things, as references for the movies. General knowledge idea and concepts brought into canon from the EU would be easily marked as IU.

I am not saying we need to go through and re-classify everything, it would just seem to make better sense going forward.

Actually he started out as a background character in TPM.

aadh likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe it's time for a new term: IU (Included Universe) ?!?

 

:blink:

IU is a good idea, spread it around...

A prime example would be Jedi Quinlan Vos, prior to his being mentioned in RotS he was just an EU character. Then he made an appearance in TCW, Hunt for Ziro episode I think. Now he is included but, how much of what he has effected in the SW universe is included?

Quinlan is part of the IU now... personally I would like to keep canon terms, characters and things, as references for the movies. General knowledge idea and concepts brought into canon from the EU would be easily marked as IU.

I am not saying we need to go through and re-classify everything, it would just seem to make better sense going forward.

Actually he started out as a background character in TPM.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

The e-wing can be ugly, but it can also look pretty good like here:  http://swc.fs2downloads.com/media/screenshots/Fighters-Rebel/E-Wing/ewing15.jpg

 

But from any angle, the defender is ugly...

http://static2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20061223184054/starwars/images/0/07/Defender.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Completely disagree with you on both accounts.  Sorry but we will have to agree to disagree.  There are some design elements of the E-wing that I like (both the one illustrate here and the version FFG chose to produce) but any way you look at it, that is a **** stupid place to put that third Laser Cannon! :wacko:

 

Chris

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

If you see an E-Wing in the next movie it wont be "EU" anymore.

Gosh I sure hope we don't see an E-Wing in the next movie unless it's in the distant background. It is probably the ugliest ship ever.

Maybe if they have an advanced E-Wing or something with some extra fancy parts or something. The E-Wing just doesn't look cool enough and if you can trust one thing from the Star Wars franchise - it's that they will try to make everything marketable. That means Aliens, lightsabers, blasters, vehicles, ships, costumes, etc. Anything they can make into a toy and sell they will try. And the current E-Wing simply isn't visually impressive enough to be a cash cow.

I'd expect to see an update on the B-Wing to be honest. That has a ton of possibilities.

They recently released a Lego Ewing didn't they?

Oops it's already come up.....

Edited by Lumberjack Nick

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

There is a reason i made mine with the ion turret.Especially since the E Wing had issues with the guns. The one above the cockpit is both aesthetically daft and, tech design wise, ridiculous.

But that is just an opinion of course

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

With the announcemnt of new films, they obviously want to minimize EU material on the market in the future, because they'll be hammer smashing established time lines and events with whatever crazy they decide to come up with.

A teenage jedi coming of age movie?


That's what I'm expecting.

Edited by Arthur Volts
stegocent likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

well so far the hawk is the only rea eu ship we have as the others will most likely be in the newer movies so i thinks more of a limit to the eu is meant by this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

The EU didn't get demoted, it got elevated to the same level.  It's considered full canon, we just don't know what's not included in the full version yet.

 

No is is not.

 

They have stated that everything published from now on is canon.

(so star wras rebels will be canon, but Mara Jade is not)

 

It would never ever work to make the EU canon as much of it contradicts the movies.

 

What is canon is dictated by the Lucasfilm Story Group

 

They have implied in various press releases that they are going through the old EU material and discarding stupid ideas, like that giant green rabbit, and canonizing the good ones, like Talon Karrde.

aadh and Digitalkiller like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Completely disagree with you on both accounts.  Sorry but we will have to agree to disagree.  There are some design elements of the E-wing that I like (both the one illustrate here and the version FFG chose to produce) but any way you look at it, that is a **** stupid place to put that third Laser Cannon! :wacko:

Chris

 

 

I'm not sure why the third laser cannon is such a big deal. I would figure that's the perfect spot to put it: right in the centerline of the ship, but not in the way of all the avionics and sensors in the nose. The F/A-18 Hornet had its cannon in a similar spot.

stegocent likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0