Vehicle Damage Resilience Versus AP Incendiary Blast

[Kriegschatten 1]

With the new SSU tanks having the "damage resilient" skill, it occurred to me that I don't quite understand how that works with an AP incendiary blast (i.e. X/skull) attack.

 

Let's say that a Steel Rain hits a Lavrentiy Beria with a petard mortar shell.

Let's further assume that the Lavrentiy was at full health (i.e. 8 health points).

 

At first I figured that the tank would just roll one die to see if it was destroyed or not.

 

But then I took a closer look at the wording for the damage resilient skill on pg. 21, which says:

"…roll one die for each point of damage inflicted on this unit. For each result, ignore one point of damage."

 

Since the Lavrentiy went from 8 health to zero, it took 8 points of damage.  Thus, it sounds like the tank would actually get to roll 8 dice and only take damage for the failed rolls.

 

Hmm, now that I think about it, a third interpretation could be that damage resilience doesn't work against AP incendiary blast at all since no damage points are technically inflicted--the unit is simply eliminated.  (The actual rule for AP incendiary blast says "roll 'X' dice for each targeted miniature and eliminate the entire unit if at least one die result is crosshair" (pg. 24).

 

So, what do you chaps think?  Which is the result?:

1. Roll one die to see whether the tank is destroyed or not.
2. Roll one die for each health point lost to see if it is truly lost.
3. Roll no dice--tank is simply eliminated.

 

[fhaugh 0]

 Letter of of rules would say the third option.  I'm curious what the designers intended.

[Loophole Master 2]

I'm leaning towards option 3. Incendiary Blast doesn't deal damage, it just kills outright, so DR doesn't enter into it.

This certainly merits a request for an official answer, though.

[golem101 3]

Leaning towards option 3 too. Balance wise, I'd rather keep X/skull as an overkill effect.

[Kriegschatten 1]

I sent this question to the rules experts today, as well.  So, we'll see what they have to say.

[Lska2 0]

 Skull means you are dead-no saves today armor boys!

[Kriegschatten 1]

I received my response from FFG today, and they agree that Damage Resilient does not protect you from an AP Icendiary Blast.

 

So, no save, unit is eliminated.

 

[Loophole Master 2]

Zach's been giving some good answers lately. Good on him!

[sefou 0]

Well that's interresting.

I was a firm believer the damage resilient rule could be used even in those kind of situation.

I beleive the same answer is good with troops too. Like the axis hero, Lara being hit by a flame weapon. No matter her damage resilience rule, she's toasted.

[Major Mishap 33]

sefou said:

Well that's interresting.

I was a firm believer the damage resilient rule could be used even in those kind of situation.

I beleive the same answer is good with troops too. Like the axis hero, Lara being hit by a flame weapon. No matter her damage resilience rule, she's toasted.

The rule won't affect troops as an attack on them operates differently having a 1/+ attack on them and not a 1/'kill'.