Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Roo-Fan Timmo

Falcon/Slave One Scale

19 posts in this topic

 Can anyone tell me how the Falcon and Slave One measure up against the X-Wing/TIE Fighters for scale? Are they roughly the same scale (big) or are they shrunk down (like the old WoTC miniatures)? 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Falcon and Slave I are the same scale (1/270th) as the current ships.  FFG has consistently stated how critical keeping the ships in scale is for ranges/movement, etc.  Which is why I doubt we'll ever see anything much bigger in the game (and I'm glad of that)!

Jim

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Emrico said:

Falcon and Slave I are the same scale (1/270th) as the current ships.  FFG has consistently stated how critical keeping the ships in scale is for ranges/movement, etc.  Which is why I doubt we'll ever see anything much bigger in the game (and I'm glad of that)!

Jim

Didn't they call the Falcon and Slave I "medium" size ships somewhere? I thought they did.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ShadowJak said:

Emrico said:

 

Falcon and Slave I are the same scale (1/270th) as the current ships.  FFG has consistently stated how critical keeping the ships in scale is for ranges/movement, etc.  Which is why I doubt we'll ever see anything much bigger in the game (and I'm glad of that)!

Jim

 

 

Didn't they call the Falcon and Slave I "medium" size ships somewhere? I thought they did.

I think maybe that was in one video press release or something.  But even if they come out with something twice as big as the Falcon for a "large" ship, I still wouldn't consider that to be that huge when compared to other ships in the Star Wars Universe (Star Destroyers, etc).  That's kind of what I meant about not seeing many that are much bigger.  I doubt we'll ever see true capital ships in this game (and that's a good thing, IMO).  Save those for a fleet style game in a different scale!

Jim

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Emrico said:

ShadowJak said:

 

Emrico said:

 

Falcon and Slave I are the same scale (1/270th) as the current ships.  FFG has consistently stated how critical keeping the ships in scale is for ranges/movement, etc.  Which is why I doubt we'll ever see anything much bigger in the game (and I'm glad of that)!

Jim

 

 

Didn't they call the Falcon and Slave I "medium" size ships somewhere? I thought they did.

 

 

I think maybe that was in one video press release or something.  But even if they come out with something twice as big as the Falcon for a "large" ship, I still wouldn't consider that to be that huge when compared to other ships in the Star Wars Universe (Star Destroyers, etc).  That's kind of what I meant about not seeing many that are much bigger.  I doubt we'll ever see true capital ships in this game (and that's a good thing, IMO).  Save those for a fleet style game in a different scale!

Jim

I would like to see some small frigates. Another post has one someone scratch built and it look great flying in formation with TIEs.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Emrico said:

Falcon and Slave I are the same scale (1/270th) as the current ships.  FFG has consistently stated how critical keeping the ships in scale is for ranges/movement, etc.  Which is why I doubt we'll ever see anything much bigger in the game (and I'm glad of that)!

Jim

Capitol ships are like Star Wars' Pandora's Box as far as gaming is concerned, and I am satisfied that Fantasy Flight has no interest in even peeking inside of it.  I believe many of us have witnessed what a disappointment of imbalance that could be.  I wouldn't mind another attempt at a Capitol Ship game, but I'd rather it be separate from this. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ShadowJak said:

Emrico said:

 

Falcon and Slave I are the same scale (1/270th) as the current ships.  FFG has consistently stated how critical keeping the ships in scale is for ranges/movement, etc.  Which is why I doubt we'll ever see anything much bigger in the game (and I'm glad of that)!

Jim

 

 

Didn't they call the Falcon and Slave I "medium" size ships somewhere? I thought they did.

 

Yes, I'm absolutely sure they did.  All the early news about the new size of ships referred to them as 'medium' also.  I've dug through everything I can find from FFG though and can't find the reference.  I suspect they realized calling them 'medium' hinted at a larger class of ships and perhaps retroactively modified some news releases.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 At 1:270 scale, the Millennium Falcon should be 3.89 inches long (or 9.89 cm).  That is pretty big.

Slave One will be 3.13" / 7.96 cm tall, and almost as wide, not including mounting pegs!  If those are "medium", I'd love to see some "large" ships :-P

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 The falcon should actually be roughly 12.8cm long.  Going off the Star Wars websites length of 34.75m.  Slave 1 should be about 7.9 cm tall and just a little less wide.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ShadowJak said:

Emrico said:

Didn't they call the Falcon and Slave I "medium" size ships somewhere? I thought they did.

 

The pre-release wave 2 description describes them as Large Ships… which would suggest that this is as big as they are likely to get.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We have had this large vs. medium discussion here several times before. The only mention of "medium" ships from FFG (not just a forum poster) is in a casual comment made in passing during a video interview with a secondary game designer at a convention. In cotext, he seemed to be using the term loosely, not defining the term "medium" in the way "large" has been defined in written materials from FFG. The Falcon and Slave 1are the large ships.

The rules book mentions that "large" ships are coming, and then, according to the Falcon description on the website: "New rules expand the X-Wing galaxy to include large ships and modifications."

Although some people have made cool custom scenarios using paper models, printed playmats, or other repurposed models, it's just not realistic to think that FFG would publish models that take up half of a standard play field and can't move, in a game built on maneuvering around and dogfighting.

Maybe we can put this "medium ship" thing to rest, unless FFG actually announces something different. Then I would retract everything I just posted. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

magadizer said:

We have had this large vs. medium discussion here several times before. The only mention of "medium" ships from FFG (not just a forum poster) is in a casual comment made in passing during a video interview with a secondary game designer at a convention. In cotext, he seemed to be using the term loosely, not defining the term "medium" in the way "large" has been defined in written materials from FFG. The Falcon and Slave 1are the large ships.

The rules book mentions that "large" ships are coming, and then, according to the Falcon description on the website: "New rules expand the X-Wing galaxy to include large ships and modifications."

Although some people have made cool custom scenarios using paper models, printed playmats, or other repurposed models, it's just not realistic to think that FFG would publish models that take up half of a standard play field and can't move, in a game built on maneuvering around and dogfighting.

Maybe we can put this "medium ship" thing to rest, unless FFG actually announces something different. Then I would retract everything I just posted. :)

You just smashed everyone's hopes and dreams. Good job.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am happy with the fact that these ships will represent the large scale models for the game since it is meant to run on the idea of dogfighting and introducing larger scale ships would move it into the realms of wargaming akin to other companies.  That is not to say I wouldn't welcome FFG brining out a warship game based on Star Wars in the future since they make some great miniatures.

I would be interested to see where they go after this expansion set.  It's a given that the B-Wing and TIE Bomber will enter the battle, but if they intend to bring in more larger ships like the Falcon they may need to dig into the Expanded universe, unless they go into the clone wars which has more vessels to choose from I guess.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ThadiusCole said:

 

I am happy with the fact that these ships will represent the large scale models for the game since it is meant to run on the idea of dogfighting and introducing larger scale ships would move it into the realms of wargaming akin to other companies.  That is not to say I wouldn't welcome FFG brining out a warship game based on Star Wars in the future since they make some great miniatures.

 

 

I agree.  Also, the radically different sizes of capital vessels in Star Wars makes for a nightmare in proper scaling.  I also don't feel that the current combat and movement system would truly reflect how those types of craft are employed.  That being said, I wouldn't mind seeing a separate game with capital vessels, but I doubt that will ever happen(particularly after Starship Battles).  I think they made the perfect choice with giving us vehicular combat at this level and based it on an already proven and successful system.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

radiskull said:

 At 1:270 scale, the Millennium Falcon should be 3.89 inches long (or 9.89 cm).  That is pretty big.

Slave One will be 3.13" / 7.96 cm tall, and almost as wide, not including mounting pegs!  If those are "medium", I'd love to see some "large" ships :-P

 

No kidding , Makes one think what there version of large will be if they consider making large ships.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just pre- orderd my Slave1, I wish I knew the stats on it so I could create a 100pt list for it, I just hope it's not insanly expensive on point cost becase im going to be so tempted to deck it out in all its weapons that I possibly can.  I would love to have the slave 1 and two TIE advanced and whatever else I could fit in for a list. but I dont think ill know how list builds for the slave1 will work untill December.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0