Best Craftsmanship Ship Components: can anyone clarify this for me?

[Jan Solo 0]

I have a question about Best Craftsmanship ship components.

 

Suppose I have a normal quality component that uses 4 power and 4 space. I then decide I want it as a Good Craftsmanship component. I can either lower Power by 1 and the component is 3 power 4 space, or I can lower Space by 1 and the component is 4 Power and 3 Space.

What about Best Craftsmanship? Unlike Good Craftsmanship, in Best craftsmanship components it is not said that "Pick one or the other but not both", so are both Power and Space requirements lowered by 1, resulting in either 2 Power and 3 Space, or 3 Power and 2 Space?

 

So from the original 4 Power 4 Space I get either -2 Power -1 Space, or -1 power -2 Space? Is this the way this is supposed to be?

 

Cheers!

[van Riebeeck 41]

In my interpretation, a good quality component will use either 1 less Space or 1 less Power. A best quality item will use 1 less Space and 1 less Power. In both case, each component cannot use less then 1 Space or 1 Power, which makes it quite useless to install , by example, best quality augur arrays that only use power, excepting the influence of morale obviously.The bonus of a good and best quality item do not stack.  A Best Temple Shrine to the God Emperor would still demand the expenditure of 1 Space and 1 Power, but will boost morale directly by 1d5. But I am not certain how long that morale boost will last. In the case of a temples shrine, I might make it even permanent, as a shrine filled with Ancient Relics of the Angevin Crusade made to utter perfection and filled with the splendor of incomparable works of art will certainly be more inspiring.

                                             Friedrich van Riebeeck, Navigator Primus, Heart of the Void

[redhead22 0]

normal 4 space 4 power

good 4-3 or 3-4

best 3-3

and nothing can go under 1 if it is one you cant make it 0

[Kuririn67 0]

If I take Good Craftsmanship the RAWs are pretty clear - pick one. So its either Power Usage -1 or Space Usage -1.

But:

If I take Best Craftsmanship it states "pick any 2". Sodo I have only one option (in the case of a non-weapon component):

Power Usage -1 AND Space Usage -1
or am I able to pick from three possibilities:

- Power Usage -2
- OR Power Usage -1 AND Space Usage -1
- OR Space Usage -2
?

[Aldyramon 25]

I also think it is:

Good: -1Power OR -1Space

Best: -1Power AND -1Space

the 2 don't stack

 

The "Pick 2" is only for Weapons where you have more posibilities, like Damage etc.

[Kasatka 157]

Aldyramon said:

I also think it is:

Good: -1Power OR -1Space

Best: -1Power AND -1Space

the 2 don't stack

 

The "Pick 2" is only for Weapons where you have more posibilities, like Damage etc.

+1. That's how it works.

[HappyDaze 10,108]

Be aware that Good/Best macrobattery and lance components do NOT have the option of taking -1 Power according to the chart.

[player1569547 0]

Please forgive the thread necro, but which book is this in?  I just purchased Into the Storm as my first RT expansion book, and GC/BC ship Components was one of the big things I thought I could look forward to…  but I appear to have the wrong book o_O  I'm still going to love the book for my group, it fills a lot of holes my players have been wanting filled, but just so I know for next time, which book has the Craftsmanship modifiers for Components?

[Erathia 648]

gatherer818 said:

Please forgive the thread necro, but which book is this in?  I just purchased Into the Storm as my first RT expansion book, and GC/BC ship Components was one of the big things I thought I could look forward to…  but I appear to have the wrong book o_O  I'm still going to love the book for my group, it fills a lot of holes my players have been wanting filled, but just so I know for next time, which book has the Craftsmanship modifiers for Components?

Component Craftsmanship can be found in Battlefleet Koronus on page 18.

[player1569547 0]

Thanks a ton.  More ship customization seems like the biggest thing my group wants right now (besides more exp and more PF), so I'll probably get BK next time I get the chance.