About Melisandre Core.

[Uncle Joker 0]

 Melisandre     (4)   (3)      

[baratheon Character] 

Lady. Asshai.

Renown.

While Melisandre is standing, Asshai characters get +1 STR.

Power on opponents' characters does not count towards their total power. 

 

I have plenty power on my Lady Stoneheart, more than 15.

If I play Valar Morghlis, both Lady Stoneheart and Melisandre will go to die.

So will I win in the moment Melisandre leave play?

[Rogue30 60]

Uncle Joker said:

I have plenty power on my Lady Stoneheart, more than 15.

If I play Valar Morghlis, both Lady Stoneheart and Melisandre will go to die.

So will I win in the moment Melisandre leave play?

They both leave play at the same time (step 6), so if Mel's constant ability stops working, you also don't have power counters. So I think you would not win.

 

[Uncle Joker 0]

Rogue30 said:

Uncle Joker said:

I have plenty power on my Lady Stoneheart, more than 15.

 

If I play Valar Morghlis, both Lady Stoneheart and Melisandre will go to die.

So will I win in the moment Melisandre leave play?

They both leave play at the same time (step 6), so if Mel's constant ability stops working, you also don't have power counters. So I think you would not win.

 

 

Thank you.

[Skowza 9]

OK, weird question just because in any game I like to think of unusual situations and how they would be properly resolved... 

In the incredibly unlikely event that 2 players in a melee have both reached 15 or more power but cannot win the game due to things like Deep Freeze, Summer Tax, etc, how would the game end if the restricting attachment/character is removed from play and they were tied?  Just to illustrate the question I'll use core Melisandre for my example:
Players A and B both have 16 power including power on characters in play.  For simplicity we'll say they are both Baratheon and they each have out Robert with a dupe, 14 power on each house with 2 power on each Robert.
Player C has a core Melisandre in play, and at the beginning of the round, someone plays Valar.  Player C cannot save Melisandre so she is killed, but Players A and B discard their dupes of Robert... this leaves both of them tied for the win - would the game end in a tie, or would it continue until one player got 1 additional power?  Or would it be up to the TO?

[Rogue30 60]

Skowza said:

this leaves both of them tied for the win - would the game end in a tie, or would it continue until one player got 1 additional power?  Or would it be up to the TO?

The first player decides who wins.

[ktom 598]

Rogue30 said:

Skowza said:

 

this leaves both of them tied for the win - would the game end in a tie, or would it continue until one player got 1 additional power?  Or would it be up to the TO?

 

 

The first player decides who wins.

Check p.16 of the rulebook relating to Power and Victory to see this in print.