My Brother, My Enemy [Mafia]

[Matt3412 486]

1 hour ago, FortyInRed said:

 

Darn. There goes plan B.

I'm a town doctor (intentionally not revealing my "flavor" at this time though)

SO....        I believe you are a "Town Doctor" based on all your reactions and posting. I truly believe this because i think we were planning on calling out Mad on the exact same thing if he was wrong. 

 

I Am a "Town Doctor" as well. I suggest we protect each other tonight Forty. 

 

Now I ask town How is there 3  Doctors????? AND a Jailkeeper type role in the same game all on "towns" side 

 

I personally think Mad most likely is lying 

And i really think that the Jail-keeper role is in the game to balance out multiple doctors. 

 

Edited May 12 by Matt3412

[Madaghmire 7,274]

6 hours ago, FortyInRed said:

Are you sure your role is "town doctor"? Not the flavor, no. Just the role. I haven’t read past this point yet to know if telling you the flavor is esculpatory for me or giving away information.

[Madaghmire 7,274]

6 hours ago, PodRacer said:

##unvote

##vote @Madaghmire.

 

Not loving your counterclaim.

 

I have to counterclaim here. If I dont, then who the **** would believe me later if I needed to claim then? Once someone claims your role, you have to drop a counterclaim. At least IMO.

2 hours ago, PodRacer said:

Was just checking in to see if anything like a concensus had been reached.

I'd ask @Madaghmire who he perceived as a threat to @CaribbeanNinja when he protected him?

 

I just felt like he was a vocal town player, so he’s someone who I would have killed if I were scum. 

im not allowed to post more than doctor

Edited May 12 by Madaghmire

[FortyInRed 380]

8 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

 

I Am a "Town Doctor" as well. I suggest we protect each other tonight Forty. 

 

Now I ask town How is there 3  Doctors????? AND a Jailkeeper type role in the same game all on "towns" side

Because Jabba is up to something.

With 2 medics/doctors I say someone is lying. With 3 I call shenanigans on Jabba.

Remember back a few games ago (Bothans) when a whole bunch of us were "intel analysts" and we were convinced that people were lying because clearly we couldn't all have that role?

I wonder if something similar is going on here. 

 

Hmm.....

[Matt3412 486]

##unvote 

[The Jabbawookie 5,610]

Suddenly, a violent explosion rocks the base.  Klaxons blare.  Troopers in armor rush to the medbay, while troopers in fatigues rush to the barracks to suit up.

The bombing has scrapped the medical wing; the sole survivor on duty is Mads, but he's in critical condition and confined to his bunk.

 

@Madaghmire has been sent to the brig.  He was a Clone Medic (town doc.)

Day 2 continues.

All of you have my apologies.

Edited May 12 by The Jabbawookie

[GhostofNobodyInParticular 2,493]

27 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

SO....        I believe you are a "Town Doctor" based on all your reactions and posting. I truly believe this because i think we were planning on calling out Mad on the exact same thing if he was wrong. 

I Am a "Town Doctor" as well. I suggest we protect each other tonight Forty. 

Now I ask town How is there 3  Doctors????? AND a Jailkeeper type role in the same game all on "towns" side 

I personally think Mad most likely is lying 

And i really think that the Jail-keeper role is in the game to balance out multiple doctors. 

This is a rather delayed (counter)claim. Why'd you wait so long? I don't particularly advocate claiming, but as Mad pointed out, the longer the delay, the less believable it seems. However, as Forty said, with 3 docs I am willing to accept it.

 

@The Jabbawookie - was Mad's confinement a result of his edit?

[The Jabbawookie 5,610]

2 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

@The Jabbawookie - was Mad's confinement a result of his edit?

I'm unable to answer that, but any more outright modkilling is highly unlikely.

Edited May 12 by The Jabbawookie

[Matt3412 486]

Just now, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

This is a rather delayed (counter)claim. Why'd you wait so long? I don't particularly advocate claiming, but as Mad pointed out, the longer the delay, the less believable it seems. However, as Forty said, with 3 docs I am willing to accept it.

 

@The Jabbawookie - was Mad's confinement a result of his edit?

well i don't think many people have been in the position of having 2 other docs claim before them.

So i Figured i might as well try to figure out some information to at least attempt to call bullcrap on one off them  

[Bertie Wooster 1,857]

@GhostofNobodyInParticular Who are your top suspects?

[Matt3412 486]

@GhostofNobodyInParticular    here is my live thought process

Forty claims - i post the following

19 hours ago, Matt3412 said:

Idk if that would have been something I would have came out and said just yet...

But that is a very big statement we have to account for moving forward 

I think to myself okay lets see how this all plays out and if i can learn something to maybe turn the tide of my inevitable counter claim more in my favor. 

 

Literally the Next Post

16 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

That's very interesting.

Indeed it is.

I don't like doing this just yet, but unless we have multiple protective rolls, I don't have a choice. I think I have to counterclaim. I'm a town doctor, I protected Cninja last night.

@FortyInRed convince me there's two of us.

Now there is 2 People saying they are the Doc?!? and i know i am....

Yeah at that point i was really going to wait and see how they questioned each other. And in my opinion i believe there is 3 docs 

@FortyInRed i'm going to protect myself tonight i suggest you do the same in case we get forced to stay inside and cant get to each other. 

[Matt3412 486]

##vote @PodRacer

I don't see how your role would be on the side of 3 Docs 

[The Jabbawookie 5,610]

22 hours ago, The Jabbawookie said:

Day 2 has begun, and will end in 48 hours at 8 PM GMT.

@GhostofNobodyInParticular: (L-4)

@Matt3412: (L-4)

@FortyInRed: (L-4)

@ovinomanc3r: (L-4)

@Battlefleet 01 Studios: FortyinRed,, Podracer, GNIPs (L-1)

@CaribbeanNinja: (L-4)

@PodRacer: Battlefleet 01 Studios, CaribbeanNinja (L-2)

 

@Bertie Wooster (Brig, Cryptic)

@Madaghmire (Brig, Town Doc)

1.5 hours remaining.

Edited May 13 by The Jabbawookie

[CaribbeanNinja 6,207]

2 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

##vote @PodRacer

I don't see how your role would be on the side of 3 Docs 

I get this, but it doesn't square with the fact that Pod came out right away to press GNIPs on his night actions.  This seems like a town play to me.

[Matt3412 486]

21 minutes ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

I get this, but it doesn't square with the fact that Pod came out right away to press GNIPs on his night actions.  This seems like a town play to me.

With His teammate potentially already behind bars you gotta take control of the situation. That's why I was  extra careful about fortys claim orginally as well 

[GhostofNobodyInParticular 2,493]

1 minute ago, Bertie Wooster said:

@GhostofNobodyInParticular Who are your top suspects?

I don't know. With Mad cleared, I am tempted to believe Forty and Matt. I honestly have a slight bit of suspicion of Pod, since his accusation of me led to the claims of 3 docs, and may have done a considerable amount of damage to town in the long run. I get that this coming from me may sound pretty cheap, but frankly it is the sort of bold move I can see him doing as scum. I don't really think he is scum, mind, but there is the suspicion. 

If we discount the idea of 3 docs, then Matt is obviously my prime suspect, since his claim is almost opportunistic (after all, it led to the acceptance of the 2 doc idea as a 3 doc idea). I am fairly neutral on Battlefleet. CNinja seems pretty town to me.

[CaribbeanNinja 6,207]

@ovinomanc3rwhat's your take on the situation?

[ovinomanc3r 4,436]

I’m gonna be clear: I’m totally out of place here

I had several ideas to share pointing to things that have been side but this escalated quickly to the point that I’m no sure anymore about anything.

A thrid doc could be a clever move to save a mate who screwed deeply but Mad has been cleared. So I lean toward trust the remaining docs.

Pod’s claim incriminates Ghost strongly however, the no kill reminded me the arsonist role. Given the number of docs it could pay off a way to kill that couldn’t be prevented. Or maybe is a recruitment game? The problem I find on this theory is that 3 docs look like useless rather than balanced.

man, I have a tendency on overthinking during late-game but so many claims just burnt my mind.

Mad is out, Forty looks town, Matt lurking seem suspicious but it is a weird spot to read two guys claiming what you are so I might buy the delay. Ghost seems a good lead if not the only but with so many docs not sure Pod’s claim means a ****. However, that doesn’t make Pod scum. If he is blocker it was an honest head up, if jailkeeper, well, then he was just Pod screwing things.

[ovinomanc3r 4,436]

If anything I think I would vote Battlefleet. There so much confusion and he is the only one with me that doesn’t seem involved at all which is I good place to be I guess? I’d rather vote him than me, lol. But it might be the dumbest reason to vote.

[PodRacer 1,077]

Specifically I am a roleblocked, I don't protect.

Still processing what IV just read, thoughts soon

[PodRacer 1,077]

1 hour ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

I don't know. With Mad cleared, I am tempted to believe Forty and Matt. I honestly have a slight bit of suspicion of Pod, since his accusation of me led to the claims of 3 docs, and may have done a considerable amount of damage to town in the long run. I get that this coming from me may sound pretty cheap, but frankly it is the sort of bold move I can see him doing as scum. I don't really think he is scum, mind, but there is the suspicion. 

If we discount the idea of 3 docs, then Matt is obviously my prime suspect, since his claim is almost opportunistic (after all, it led to the acceptance of the 2 doc idea as a 3 doc idea). I am fairly neutral on Battlefleet. CNinja seems pretty town to me.

I do agree today has gotten a little wild, but I don't think my reveal triggered the others, if I had been busy at day start, I feel like a similar chain of events could quite realistically have occured independent of my claim.

 

[PodRacer 1,077]

From a setup point of view three docs and a roleblocker would definitely suggest we have a strongman in the setup to avoid a perfect circle of protection for town.

A hard setup for scum otherwise.

 

Matt's claim comes late and can't be disproved in the absence of a rolecop/ tracker.

I am reminded of the three cop claim game of yesteryear for the vets.

 

[PodRacer 1,077]

Three docs could also point to multiple killing roles? Mafia and serial killer perhaps?

[PodRacer 1,077]

I will stick with my vote on gnip I guess, if he survives today I'm obliged to block him again presenting scum the opportunity to no kill, merely prolonging the inevitable.

Letting him live (if scum) means his partner can off me or another power role tonight also.

[FortyInRed 380]

28 minutes ago, PodRacer said:

I will stick with my vote on gnip I guess, if he survives today I'm obliged to block him again presenting scum the opportunity to no kill, merely prolonging the inevitable.

Letting him live (if scum) means his partner can off me or another power role tonight also.

Yeah I'm in the same boat.

##vote

@GhostofNobodyInParticular