My Brother, My Enemy [Mafia]

[Bertie Wooster 1,857]

...am I the only Vanilla? 

[Matt3412 486]

5 minutes ago, Bertie Wooster said:

...am I the only Vanilla? 

No That would make you very unique ... 😂

[GhostofNobodyInParticular 2,493]

Wow. So, does that mean a third party, a busdriver, or both? Maybe a vigilante? Or does somebody have an ability that kills their visitor?

I am leaning third party, since that would explain the proliferation of protective roles.

[PodRacer 1,077]

1 hour ago, Matt3412 said:

Also pod said he is a roleblocker.... and if we think the docs are all town then it's not a long walk to think all the roleblockers are scum 

A very linear path to victory...

 

[PodRacer 1,077]

I think ovi may have blocked me last night, I was informed my action failed.

 

[FortyInRed 380]

38 minutes ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

Wow. So, does that mean a third party, a busdriver, or both? Maybe a vigilante? Or does somebody have an ability that kills their visitor?

I am leaning third party, since that would explain the proliferation of protective roles.

That's my guess too. With 3 town docs and 2 cryptics I'm thinking there may be some recruitment or 3rd faction

Just now, PodRacer said:

I think ovi may have blocked me last night, I was informed my action failed.

 

Did this result in him dying?

PS I protected @Matt3412. Did you protect me?

[Bertie Wooster 1,857]

I'm kinda wondering now if everyone is cryptic.

[Matt3412 486]

4 hours ago, FortyInRed said:

 

PS I protected @Matt3412. Did you protect me?

Yup haha, looks like you know what to do next lol 

[Matt3412 486]

24 minutes ago, Bertie Wooster said:

I'm kinda wondering now if everyone is cryptic.

Yeah it might just be one big red herring 

[Bertie Wooster 1,857]

Actually Mads wasn't cryptic. So maybe the docs are not cryptic but everyone else is. Roleblocker could be a town or scum role. Likewise Rolecop (but I personally think Battlefleet was a Mafia Rolecop, designed to hunt the docs and possibly even a third-party threat). 

I wonder if ovi/Battlefleet were both scum and there's a third-party out there? Or a third scum? 

[FortyInRed 380]

12 hours ago, Bertie Wooster said:

I'm kinda wondering now if everyone is cryptic.

 

11 hours ago, Matt3412 said:

Yeah it might just be one big red herring 

Bertie did your role description in your PM match what Jabba posted?

 

[Bertie Wooster 1,857]

19 minutes ago, FortyInRed said:

 

Bertie did your role description in your PM match what Jabba posted?

 

Basically it just said I'm vanilla town, typical town win condition, and the rest was flavor. There was no mention of "cryptic" in my PM because that's a hidden modifier. 

[CaribbeanNinja 6,207]

On 5/12/2020 at 8:34 AM, PodRacer said:

Gonna suggest top  scum RN looks like

Mad- for the unforced counter

Gnip - for the absence of NK

Ovi- 

Forty- unforced claim

 

 

Pod leaves ovi blank. Tell?

On 5/12/2020 at 9:13 AM, ovinomanc3r said:

Agree, however Forty’s move is really risky nailing auto loose. If he faked claim doc they would open the door for the true counter claim. Which points to both Ghost and Forty as scum. We would just have to check the claim thing to take both down.

to me it feels bad the game could be over by now, but who knows. That kind of things happen I guess.

Ovi pushes for GNIPs and Forty

On 5/12/2020 at 4:48 PM, ovinomanc3r said:

I’m gonna be clear: I’m totally out of place here

I had several ideas to share pointing to things that have been side but this escalated quickly to the point that I’m no sure anymore about anything.

A thrid doc could be a clever move to save a mate who screwed deeply but Mad has been cleared. So I lean toward trust the remaining docs.

Pod’s claim incriminates Ghost strongly however, the no kill reminded me the arsonist role. Given the number of docs it could pay off a way to kill that couldn’t be prevented. Or maybe is a recruitment game? The problem I find on this theory is that 3 docs look like useless rather than balanced.

man, I have a tendency on overthinking during late-game but so many claims just burnt my mind.

Mad is out, Forty looks town, Matt lurking seem suspicious but it is a weird spot to read two guys claiming what you are so I might buy the delay. Ghost seems a good lead if not the only but with so many docs not sure Pod’s claim means a ****. However, that doesn’t make Pod scum. If he is blocker it was an honest head up, if jailkeeper, well, then he was just Pod screwing things.

Ovi seems to be trying to thread the needle of agreeing with Pod, but not nuking him if/when GNIPs flips?

[CaribbeanNinja 6,207]

Also, @Battlefleet 01 Studiosdid you ever answer the question about what you found out about GNIPs?

[PodRacer 1,077]

1 hour ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

Pod leaves ovi blank. Tell?

Ovi pushes for GNIPs and Forty

Ovi seems to be trying to thread the needle of agreeing with Pod, but not nuking him if/when GNIPs flips?

I was actually just struggling to elaborate on what made him scummy beyond just the contents of his post that were the for all to see...

[Bertie Wooster 1,857]

@Madaghmire I believe you're still allowed to speak from the brig. You're the only confirmed town. Any thoughts? 

[Battlefleet 01 Studios 597]

2 hours ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

Also, @Battlefleet 01 Studiosdid you ever answer the question about what you found out about GNIPs?

He's cryptic vanilla.

[CaribbeanNinja 6,207]

On 5/13/2020 at 9:53 AM, Battlefleet 01 Studios said:

Well if people would like me to fly less under the radar in hopes of convincing them to unvote me I can say that I believe @GhostofNobodyInParticular is innocent and should be protected.

So if he turns up cryptic, how do you know he's innocent?

[PodRacer 1,077]

Pretty sure my reads are supposed to be 

Forty

Ninja

Matt

Gnip

 

But I don't think it's that straight forwards? 

[CaribbeanNinja 6,207]

1 minute ago, PodRacer said:

Pretty sure my reads are supposed to be 

Forty

Ninja

Matt

Gnip

 

But I don't think it's that straight forwards? 

Lol, Pod, you can't just put everybody else in it! 🙂

[PodRacer 1,077]

Forty I can buy as a town doc, but Matt and ninja willingness to off me yesterday muddies the pond coupled with BFS scan of gnip

[Matt3412 486]

5 hours ago, PodRacer said:

Forty I can buy as a town doc, but Matt and ninja willingness to off me yesterday muddies the pond coupled with BFS scan of gnip

Explain your case against me and ninja, I'm interested 

[PodRacer 1,077]

16 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

Explain your case against me and ninja, I'm interested 

Define case??

Gnip was roleblocked n1 but with 3 alleged docs and a rolecop check, it means very little.

You said you were suspicious of me, fair enough, but without much reason Ninja performs a 180 and tries to push me having previously townread my actions.

So maybe this is scum ninja taking advantage of your read, as an excuse, or vice versa maybe your just scum and accusing me to confuddle and overwhelm cninja?

[PodRacer 1,077]

Did you have a case on me? Or was it just purely the ' this is too much town power' angle?

[PodRacer 1,077]

Thoughts from the brig @Bertie Wooster @Madaghmire @Battlefleet 01 Studios?