Darth Vader Officer

[RedDogReb 141]

I have a question about the wording and how this card works.

The card states:

"While a friendly ship at distance 1-5 is attacking a ship, it may discard 1 of its [officer icon] or [commander icon] cards (other than Darth Vader) to reroll any number of dice in its attack pool"

I read this as meaning the officer that is discarded has to be on the ship that is firing.

However, one of my friends says that the officer being discarded can be on any ship.

For example:

ISD flagship, with DV officer

Arquitens with SFO

Gozanti with SFO

If arquitens shots, it could discard its SFO.

If the ISD shoot's, can it discard the Gozanti's SFO, or if it wanted to reroll it would have to discard the commander?

Thannks.

[Bertie Wooster 1,857]

You are correct. In that example, the only way the ISD can benefit would be to discard its commander. Which is why people almost never put Darth Vader (officer) on an ISD (unless they're flying triple Cymoons or something like that). Just stick him on a Gozanti!

[Drasnighta 26,832]

1 hour ago, RedDogReb said:

However, one of my friends says that the officer being discarded can be on any ship.

The question to ask is, "How does that work with the wording 'One of its'...?"

 

ABsolutely, the ship firing is discarding an officer on board itself, and then rerolling...  Vader's long distance Force TeleChoke (as seen on ESB) re-motivates the Crew.

[R4Pi3R 101]

7 hours ago, Drasnighta said:

ABsolutely, the ship firing is discarding an officer on board itself, and then rerolling...  Vader's long distance Force TeleChoke (as seen on ESB) re-motivates the Crew.

The most motivated one will be the guy who just got promoted, due to a sudden opening in the position of his superior officer o_o xD