First expansion

[player767602 0]

Hello All,

I'm going to buy an expansion for AH, any advice between Kingsport, Dunwich & Innsmouth ?

 

Thanks !

[Tibs 184]

www.boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/41787/the-complete-arkham-horror

www.boardgamegeek.com/geeklist/42411/arkham-horror-a-geeklist-game-review

I recommend getting the large expansions before the small ones because of their extra components. But don't get Kingsport first because it has no unstable locations. Don't get Innsmouth first for a number of reasons I won't go into here.

So that really leaves Dunwich, unless you're willing to get Kingsport and Innsmouth together (they complement each other well).

[oldthrashbarg 0]

Definitely Dunwich

[Guest Not In Sample]

Big Box: Dunwich>Innsmouth>Kingsport

Small Box: Lurker in the Threashold>King in Yellow>Black Goat of the Woods>Curse of the Dark Pharaoh

[Tibs 184]

kroen said:

Big Box: Dunwich>Innsmouth>Kingsport

Small Box: Lurker in the Threashold>King in Yellow>Black Goat of the Woods>Curse of the Dark Pharaoh

Since Lurker has not even been released yet, it is an unfair assessment to say that it would be the best one. That would be assuming that it will be the best because it is the most recently released, but then that would make Black Goat the best small box expansion released to date, and in my humble opinion it is the worst.

Lurker could wind up disappointing everybody. This announcement is all we have to go on so far.

[Avi_dreader 64]

 Whatever you do, get Dunwich first.

[Guest Not In Sample]

Tibs said:

 

kroen said:

 

Big Box: Dunwich>Innsmouth>Kingsport

Small Box: Lurker in the Threashold>King in Yellow>Black Goat of the Woods>Curse of the Dark Pharaoh

 

 

Since Lurker has not even been released yet, it is an unfair assessment to say that it would be the best one. That would be assuming that it will be the best because it is the most recently released, but then that would make Black Goat the best small box expansion released to date, and in my humble opinion it is the worst.

Lurker could wind up disappointing everybody. This announcement is all we have to go on so far.

 

 

Reason I think Lurker would be best is because it has a "core" mechanic, something wich no other small box exampnsion has.

Dunwich- Injury/Madness

Innsmouth- Personal Story

Kingsport- Epic Battle

Lurker- the new gates, also relatioinship cards too maybe

[Avi_dreader 64]

 I am excited about the new gates, but I'm somewhat suspicious of the relationship cards.  It feels like someone's trying to slip in Guardians through the back door.  If there will be negative relationships as well as positive relationships, I'll be pleased though.

[player767602 0]

Thanks to you All for the posts.

I'll go for Dunwich as recommended !!