Mafia Game VI (Day 7 - game ends)

[markdedrick 26]

1 hour ago, markferguson said:

Ok so we actually need to do something this time or we’re all going to end up dead.

let me start - Adam has been even quieter than the rest of us and while he has given a valid reason, we need a target and it’s the best lead we have

Agree 100% on the killing. Not sure on Adam (even though I voted for him last time). Hoping folks are more engaged this time around. 

[clontroper5 4,232]

Just to be clear, Adam = @Wenchiman correct?

 

He does seem Suspicious to me...

I would like more of an Answer from him, and if we are still considering lynching him perhaps he should Role claim at some point today...

[Rewen007 12]

11 minutes ago, clontroper5 said:

Just to be clear, Adam = @Wenchiman correct?

 

He does seem Suspicious to me...

I would like more of an Answer from him, and if we are still considering lynching him perhaps he should Role claim at some point today...

I second this proposal.   Always good to see how someone responds to a role claim challenge when they have been quiet..............

[Rewen007 12]

Having not played with a Desperado before - perhaps more experienced players can chime in here.

My read of the role is that @Paulcrawford didn't try to perform his day kill, but rather, was targeted by scum or non-town in a N1 attack?

Otherwise, we would have seen the results during D1 action if he had taken his desperate measure?

[markdedrick 26]

27 minutes ago, clontroper5 said:

Just to be clear, Adam = @Wenchiman correct?

 

He does seem Suspicious to me...

I would like more of an Answer from him, and if we are still considering lynching him perhaps he should Role claim at some point today...

Correct same person. Hopefully he’ll join us soon. 

[markdedrick 26]

15 minutes ago, Rewen007 said:

Having not played with a Desperado before - perhaps more experienced players can chime in here.

My read of the role is that @Paulcrawford didn't try to perform his day kill, but rather, was targeted by scum or non-town in a N1 attack?

Otherwise, we would have seen the results during D1 action if he had taken his desperate measure?

From my reading of the role he was probably waiting for more evidence before attacking. 

Based on last night’s actions I’d also suggest that we don’t have a serial killer, although an arsonist or a poisoner are still quite possible. 

[TheCallum 758]

I agree with all that’s been said.

##vote @Wenchiman

I will undo this vote if he becomes active.

[TheCallum 758]

Oh, I have seen his post now.

##unvote @Wenchiman

 

I can’t care any others who haven’t said anything.

A quick skim through suggests a lack of substance from @CaryHaneyDC.

Is he next policy lynch?

[Rewen007 12]

2 hours ago, TheCallum said:

I agree with all that’s been said.

##vote @Wenchiman

I will undo this vote if he becomes active.

I will also undo this vote, if he becomes more active, and if his response of role/function aren't scummy / unhelpful to the Rebel cause!

##vote lynch @Wenchiman

Edited January 6, 2019 by Rewen007
Adjusted my "if he becomes active" to more active based on the one statement yesterday by Wenchiman.

[Rewen007 12]

1 minute ago, TheCallum said:

Oh, I have seen his post now.

##unvote @Wenchiman

 

I can’t care any others who haven’t said anything.

A quick skim through suggests a lack of substance from @CaryHaneyDC.

Is he next policy lynch?

Yes, he's been very quiet, despite having chimed in yesterday.  To be fair, Cary's method is read a lot, analyze, and respond.  But presumably he'd have that time by now???  🤷‍♂️

[Rewen007 12]

1 hour ago, markdedrick said:

From my reading of the role he was probably waiting for more evidence before attacking. 

Based on last night’s actions I’d also suggest that we don’t have a serial killer, although an arsonist or a poisoner are still quite possible. 

Mark - agreed on all fronts.  Hard to pull the trigger as Desperado on day 1...unless there was a move to lynch him, evidence of mafia targeting.  Raises the question:  who would have motivation to take him out N1?

[markdedrick 26]

17 minutes ago, Rewen007 said:

Yes, he's been very quiet, despite having chimed in yesterday.  To be fair, Cary's method is read a lot, analyze, and respond.  But presumably he'd have that time by now???  🤷‍♂️

Yeah this is in line with my thinking. He’s suspicious, but given his history I’m willing to wait a bit before jumping on the lynch train. 

[markdedrick 26]

@Traingirl1 and @Madaghmire also seem rather quiet, even more so than Cary. Jessica much more so than in earlier games, so it would be good to hear from her. I don’t know the other player so can’t comment there other than to note lack of activity. 

[JessicaChase 2]

13 minutes ago, markdedrick said:

@Traingirl1 and @Madaghmire also seem rather quiet, even more so than Cary. Jessica much more so than in earlier games, so it would be good to hear from her. I don’t know the other player so can’t comment there other than to note lack of activity. 

I am finding this format much harder to track (I get notices on WA so that is easier for me to follow)

[clontroper5 4,232]

Just now, JessicaChase said:

I am finding this format much harder to track (I get notices on WA so that is easier for me to follow)

You can set the forum to send you notices if you want

[JessicaChase 2]

Just now, clontroper5 said:

You can set the forum to send you notices if you want

Thanks, I will give that a try

[markdedrick 26]

3 minutes ago, clontroper5 said:

You can set the forum to send you notices if you want

I did not know this. 

[Lord Preyer 556]

VOTES:

 @Paulcrawford

@CaryHaneyDC

@markdedrick

@JessicaChase

@Wenchiman: Rewen007 (L-6)

@Traingirl1

@Madaghmire

 @EbonHawk

 @clontroper5

@PodRacer

@Rewen007

 @Stefan

 @markferguson

  @TheCallum

  7 to Lynch

[markdedrick 26]

9 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:

VOTES:

 @Paulcrawford

@CaryHaneyDC

@markdedrick

@JessicaChase

@Wenchiman: Rewen007 (L-6)

@Traingirl1

@Madaghmire

 @EbonHawk

 @clontroper5

@PodRacer

@Rewen007

 @Stefan

 @markferguson

  @TheCallum

  7 to Lynch

How much time is left?

[Lord Preyer 556]

A little over 44hrs

[Rewen007 12]

1 hour ago, markdedrick said:

@Traingirl1 and @Madaghmire also seem rather quiet, even more so than Cary. Jessica much more so than in earlier games, so it would be good to hear from her. I don’t know the other player so can’t comment there other than to note lack of activity. 

@madaghmire has a very positive reputation and a lot of experience.  Seems odd to not be hearing more from them.

[markdedrick 26]

22 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:

A little over 44hrs

So not exactly time to panic then?

[PodRacer 1,077]

3 minutes ago, Rewen007 said:

@madaghmire has a very positive reputation and a lot of experience.  Seems odd to not be hearing more from them.

##vote madaghmire 

[Lord Preyer 556]

43hrs 12mins remaining.

VOTES:

 @Paulcrawford

@CaryHaneyDC

@markdedrick

@JessicaChase

@Wenchiman: Rewen007 (L-6)

@Traingirl1

@Madaghmire: Pod (L-6)

 @EbonHawk

 @clontroper5

@PodRacer

@Rewen007

 @Stefan

 @markferguson

  @TheCallum

  7 to Lynch

[clontroper5 4,232]

I'm still waiting for something from the quiet poeple... 

 

@EbonHawk you have been interestingly Quiet, everything ok?