What is the least effective upgrade?

[Shadow345 638]

One that costs too much for its effect or generally isn't worth taking.

 

I haven't seen anyone run Point Defense Reroute.

Edited August 22, 2018 by Shadow345

[OlaphOfTheNorth 229]

For my money it's quad turbolaser cannons, which are both pricier and less effective than H9s. There is no scenario where I don't take H9s instead.

[svelok 4,671]

[Hedgehogmech 578]

4 minutes ago, OlaphOfTheNorth said:

For my money it's quad turbolaser cannons, which are both pricier and less effective than H9s. There is no scenario where I don't take H9s instead.

I've used them to good effect on Vader Cymoon ISDs. They're great at killing smaller ships - you're able to shut down both tokens on a flotilla, or both evades on a CR90. You'really need vader to give you a good chance of an accuracy, but when you do they're better than H9s as you don't give up damage to generate an accuracy - very important on swingy red dice.

[OlaphOfTheNorth 229]

5 minutes ago, Hedgehogmech said:

I've used them to good effect on Vader Cymoon ISDs. They're great at killing smaller ships - you're able to shut down both tokens on a flotilla, or both evades on a CR90. You'really need vader to give you a good chance of an accuracy, but when you do they're better than H9s as you don't give up damage to generate an accuracy - very important on swingy red dice.

Fair enough; I play about 80% rebel.

[Drasnighta 26,204]

How many posts before I mention Cluster Bombs?

[duck_bird 843]

QTCs is fun on a cymoon with spinals, because it's the only way you can possibly roll 8 red dice at something.

[TheCallum 742]

I have never seen Point Defense Reroutes in a serious list.

 

 

[Vae 118]

27 minutes ago, duck_bird said:

QTCs is fun on a cymoon with spinals, because it's the only way you can possibly roll 8 red dice at something.

Ackbar Defiance MC80A can roll 9 total (4+ 2 (Ackbar) + 1 (Conc Fire) +1 (Defiance) +1 (Enhanced Armament or QTC)). You could then possibly add Home One for 10.

[Bertie Wooster 1,120]

NK-7 Ion Cannons are terrible for their cost. 

[Thraug 1,006]

1 hour ago, OlaphOfTheNorth said:

For my money it's quad turbolaser cannons, which are both pricier and less effective than H9s. There is no scenario where I don't take H9s instead.

This is a great upgrade! It allows an extra "modification" to get an extra red die. It's super flexible in the right build. Get an extra accuracy when needed, or add it and reroll it in hopes for more damage. It's a 10 point Spinal Armament with some flexibility for accuracy with the chance of wiffing.

Works wonders in Vader Commander lists with ISD 2, Cymoon, VSD2. You should try.

[homedrone 235]

I used QTC on a liberty with H9 back in the flotilla hey day. It was expensive but quite effective.

[Church14 2,256]

3 hours ago, duck_bird said:

QTCs is fun on a cymoon with spinals, because it's the only way you can possibly roll 8 red dice at something.

MC80A, Enhanced Armament. Defiance, Ackbar. 4+2+1+1. 8 red dice. Use QTC to in theory roll 9 then. 

[duck_bird 843]

7 minutes ago, Church14 said:

MC80A, Enhanced Armament. Defiance, Ackbar. 4+2+1+1. 8 red dice. Use QTC to in theory roll 9 then. 

Oh crap I have a new life goal.

[Stasy 2,487]

Independence is expensive for a lack of attack post move.

Redemption also pricey on a fragile chasis.

Cluster Bombs. Point Defense.

Just things off the top of my head. 

[Colindarklighter 8]

For me its redundant shields, 8 points for an effect that regenerates only a single shield and it really only works on turns 3-6 if you are lucky.

Edited August 22, 2018 by Colindarklighter

[Undeadguy 5,730]

Tantive IV

Fire Control Team

Sensor Team

Redemption

 

[>kkj 304]

50 minutes ago, Undeadguy said:

Tantive IV

Fire Control Team

Sensor Team

Redemption

 

Tantive IV is great if you want Coms Net but dont have place for a Flotilla in your fleet! (Assuming you already use a CR90 in that fleet)

[Undeadguy 5,730]

4 minutes ago, >kkj said:

Tantive IV is great if you want Coms Net but dont have place for a Flotilla in your fleet! (Assuming you already use a CR90 in that fleet)

Why don't you have room for a flotilla? And Jaina's Light is far superior. 

[>kkj 304]

1 minute ago, Undeadguy said:

Why don't you have room for a flotilla? And Jaina's Light is far superior. 

Maybe because i want to use those 20 points for other stuff? You dont have to use a flottilla all the time, especially in the current meta. My tournament list for this saturdays store championship has Tantive IV in it because i want to have slicer tools on my GR75

[Snipafist 7,306]

There are some real stinkers in there (Heavy Turbolaser Turrets, Point Defense Reroute, Redundant Shields, Dominator title, etc.), but NK-7 Ion Cannons is the King Turd upgrade.

• Uses the ion cannon slot you probably should've been using for HIEs, Leading Shots, or SW-7s
• TEN points
• Requires a blue crit
• Exhausts to use
• Opponent gets to choose the token
• Token removed after the spend defense tokens step

It's really really bad.

Edited August 22, 2018 by Snipafist

[ExplosiveTooka 226]

9 minutes ago, Snipafist said:

There are some real stinkers in there (Heavy Turbolaser Turrets, Point Defense Reroute, Redundant Shields, Dominator title, etc.), but NK-7 Ion Cannons is the King Turd upgrade.

• Uses the ion cannon slot you probably should've been using for HIEs, Leading Shots, or SW-7s
• TEN points
• Requires a blue crit
• Exhausts to use
• Opponent gets to choose the token
• Token removed after the spend defense tokens step

It's really really bad.

I would theoretically take it in a liberty, gladiator, and AFmk2 heavy meta. Anything with non redundant tokens really.

[Undeadguy 5,730]

19 minutes ago, >kkj said:

Maybe because i want to use those 20 points for other stuff? You dont have to use a flottilla all the time, especially in the current meta. My tournament list for this saturdays store championship has Tantive IV in it because i want to have slicer tools on my GR75

Yea so drop Tantive IV for comms net and you have 30ish points to use. 

Just because you want to run something doesn't mean it's good. I use to run Tantilles and it was fun because it was comms net with dice but over twice the cost. People stopped playing it because comms net is cheaper and you can take 2 in place for a CR90. Double activations and token flexibility was a nice buff for large ships. 

[>kkj 304]

1 hour ago, Undeadguy said:

Yea so drop Tantive IV for comms net and you have 30ish points to use. 

Just because you want to run something doesn't mean it's good. I use to run Tantilles and it was fun because it was comms net with dice but over twice the cost. People stopped playing it because comms net is cheaper and you can take 2 in place for a CR90. Double activations and token flexibility was a nice buff for large ships. 

I dont play the CR90 for the Tantive IV title... i play it because it has a place in my fleet as a MS-1 boat. But since i already have a CR90 in my fleet i can use slicer teams on my GR75 which is great and thats what i mean. You dont play a CR90 for Tantive IV but using Tantive IV when playing a CR90 can be worth it, thats my point

[Ling27 851]

In my opinion, any card that is one use only. While yes, they can be really good and get you some great results (looking at external racks), they can have dramatic downsides.

1: If the ship equiped with the one use only, dies before it is used, then you wasted it.

2: if the one use wiffs, then its wasted. Sure, things like external racks still get ordinance experts... but if OEs didnt exist then Racks would suffer.

3: they still count toward points after the ship is destroyed. So even if it goes off well, then you get blown up... your opponant still gets the points.

4: You used the one use only thing, on your first shot! Now you have a second shot, or the ship survives for longer than that turn. Are you wasting a combat effective ship just because you blew the glass cannon's shot?

 

There are multiple reasons, but those are the main ones why i dont personally like using 1 use only upgrades, or upgrades that limit you.