Recon on Sylluria {MAFIA}

[Lord Preyer 556]

5 minutes ago, Gengis Jon said:

I’m sticking with LP as my no 1 suspect. (Which, contrary to someone analysis I never deviated from when the lynch mob waggon train hit overdrive)  LP seems entirely too helpful and likable. I don’t want it to be him, but I must go with my gut. My single (semi) tangible piece of evidence remains his usage of the word “neat.” It really does just seem like the kind of word someone would use who’s trying to put out innocent “ah-shucks, I’m just a friendly townie” kinda vibes. Just a smiggin over the top.

My second choice is LTD — I don’t trust anyone who doesn’t know the difference between quasi black and faux black.

##vote @Lord Preyer

Oh Gengis. I’m afraid it’s even worse than that - this is how I actually am and indeed speak in real life too!

[EbonHawk 1,243]

Just now, Lord Preyer said:

Oh Gengis. I’m afraid it’s even worse than that - this is how I actually am and indeed speak in real life too!

 

[Matt3412 486]

updated since i think i'm gonna die, 

bad

ovi

 

unknown

ebon

ltd

 

good

gengis

clon

lord peyer

 

[EbonHawk 1,243]

1 minute ago, Matt3412 said:

updated since i think i'm gonna die, 

bad

ovi

 

unknown

ebon

ltd

 

good

gengis

clon

lord peyer

 

updated with my response again 

3 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

I'm sorry but with all respect that is rubbish.

Saying someone is BAD is not a reason, that is a STATEMENT.

You need reasons reasons to make a statement, and so far all you're saying is, bad.

 

[EbonHawk 1,243]

Why do you think this? just saying bad is not helpful in your defence, and leads me only to see scum more

[EbonHawk 1,243]

@The Jabbawookie can we have a vote count please  

[EbonHawk 1,243]

4 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

updated since i think i'm gonna die

what reason can you provide to not lynch you?

If you can, then also provide us with who to lynch in your eyes and a reason to lynch them.

[Lord Preyer 556]

19 hours ago, Lord Preyer said:

Let’s consider the case of who killed Pod. 

Ebon starts the train and I provided the killing vote (see previous post for my justifications). 

We know that GNIP was in on the train (and his post actually helped persuade me to flip from Ebon to Pod). It’s a distinct possibility that another Scum was in on the vote. That means me, Ebon, Clon or Matt @Matt3412

When Pod died he was pointing the finger at me and Matt (along with his traditional ‘kill ebon’ call).

If there was a pre-game Night Phase and (and given Pod was Insane) then it’s possible he scanned me or Matt and one of us read as Scum to him thus proving whichever of us he scanned was Town. That means in terms of my own threat ranking I am currently ranking Matt as a lesser threat (for now!) and am now more concerned about (as JJ would say): ”CLON!” @clontroper5

Finally, I am just a little bit tempted to just vote for Ebon @ebon hawk because the vendetta thing gives him cover every game to explain his Day 1 anti-Pod vote and that makes reading the tea leaves on Day 2 even harder! Said vendetta would give him good cover if he was Scum too...

@ebon hawk - here’s my earlier post stating a pre-scan was an either/or on me and Matt. My theory falls down though on why he would state both of us were scum though. 

[EbonHawk 1,243]

1 minute ago, Lord Preyer said:

@ebon hawk - here’s my earlier post stating a pre-scan was an either/or on me and Matt. My theory falls down though on why he would state both of us were scum though. 

I believe bc he didn't get a scan.. if he did we would have a Sane Cop still, who would know he's sane, and also have a pre game scan, and would now know 2 confirmed town.

As this hasn't been revealed I don't believe we have a second cop, or that pod got a pre scan.

But... I could be wrong

[Matt3412 486]

@Lord Preyer i think he viewed how we acted on day one as similar, since you were the No1 i belive he checked you.

[Matt3412 486]

##vote @ovinomanc3r this is all i got right now,

your pressing will soon be rewarded with my innocence being revealed, and i don't think that will look very good on you. @EbonHawk

[Lord Preyer 556]

Ebon - we may still have a sane cop who is just trying to lie low and gather more scans so that they can reveal enough later to win the game (and they would know they have 2 nights of leeway). 

I’m trying to work out who to vote for. I would have voted Ebon because of the vendetta thing but that’s over for him now which is a good thing and so I don’t want to go down that road anymore. 

In terms of who was in on killing Pod, that leads me back to looking at you @clontroper5 

[EbonHawk 1,243]

Just now, Matt3412 said:

@Lord Preyer i think he viewed how we acted on day one as similar, since you were the No1 i belive he checked you.

which would make you wrong about Preyer being scum if the case.

Anything to add about the previous questions?

[EbonHawk 1,243]

3 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

##vote @ovinomanc3r this is all i got right now,

your pressing will soon be rewarded with my innocence being revealed, and i don't think that will look very good on you. @EbonHawk

If you're town, I move on to the next read and regret nothing..

Why, because you've done nothing to defend yourself, or lead us to not suspect you..

[EbonHawk 1,243]

3 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:

Ebon - we may still have a sane cop who is just trying to lie low and gather more scans so that they can reveal enough later to win the game (and they would know they have 2 nights of leeway). 

I’m trying to work out who to vote for. I would have voted Ebon because of the vendetta thing but that’s over for him now which is a good thing and so I don’t want to go down that road anymore. 

In terms of who was in on killing Pod, that leads me back to looking at you @clontroper5 

clon seems sly, but i'm willing to let him slide until tomorrow.

The fact matty's only reasons for voting people are bc they're bad... are just bad reasons, and he is only diverting attention away not answering questions a common scum ploy 

[Gengis Jon 222]

My vote was, in part, a test to see if Matt would jump ship back over to LP. Matt was the first to join my vote for LP. Very quickly, too, I might add. I was suspicious of Matt, and to some degree still am, but less so now. Regardless, I’m sticking with ##vote LP.  

[Matt3412 486]

Thanks for seeing some of the light @Gengis Jon

6 minutes ago, EbonHawk said:

If you're town, I move on to the next read and regret nothing..

Does this not worry anyone. so far both of ebon's votes have been on people he could care less are either scum or town 

[EbonHawk 1,243]

1 minute ago, Matt3412 said:

Thanks for seeing some of the light @Gengis Jon

Does this not worry anyone. so far both of ebon's votes have been on people he could care less are either scum or town 

If you wern't new you would understand mine and pods interactions day 1.

You're now purposely trying to stretch any point you can to divert away from you, again a scum tactic.

I'VE LITERALLY ASKING YOU FOR REASONS NOT TO HANG YOU 5 TIMES DUDE

and instead of answering it, you just keep trying to divert onto other people, and ignore anyone questioning you as scum

[ovinomanc3r 4,436]

33 minutes ago, Lord Preyer said:

@ebon hawk - here’s my earlier post stating a pre-scan was an either/or on me and Matt. My theory falls down though on why he would state both of us were scum though. 

man, that's like the twentieth time you missmentioned Ebon?

[Matt3412 486]

I have only ever voted for people I truly thought were scum at the time and have even been willing to admit when I feel I am wrong so to get a town person lynched. 1 time even on you ebon. 

[EbonHawk 1,243]

1 minute ago, Matt3412 said:

I have only ever voted for people I truly thought were scum at the time and have even been willing to admit when I feel I am wrong so to get a town person lynched. 1 time even on you ebon. 

I'm confused am I suspect or not, I've been both?

After LP you said LTD day 1, not LTD is fine as well, and because Ovis pressing you he's bad..

45 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

updated since i think i'm gonna die, 

bad

ovi

 

unknown

ebon

ltd

 

good

gengis

clon

lord peyer

 

also LP is now good, after you were insistent on him?

You seem to be twoing and throwing between people, at random. 

My vote stays, if you're town I'm sorry but I just don't see it

[ovinomanc3r 4,436]

27 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

##vote @ovinomanc3r this is all i got right now,

your pressing will soon be rewarded with my innocence being revealed, and i don't think that will look very good on you. @EbonHawk

Why me? Just to know. The reasons I mean, I don't have a problem with someone voting me if he has a reason.

15 minutes ago, Matt3412 said:

Does this not worry anyone. so far both of ebon's votes have been on people he could care less are either scum or town 

This is throwing mud onto Ebon. He explained what he meant and it wasn't that.

[ovinomanc3r 4,436]

If a jester he is really good.

[EbonHawk 1,243]

1 minute ago, ovinomanc3r said:

Why me? Just to know. The reasons I mean, I don't have a problem with someone voting me if he has a reason.

This is throwing mud onto Ebon. He explained what he meant and it wasn't that.

could not second this enough!

[Gengis Jon 222]

As I hope all of you know, I’m brand new to this. First time here or anywhere.

That also leaves me at a huge disadvantage as I don’t know who are the veterans and who are also new. I’ve been making some assumptions, but assumptions often go, they may have been off base.

If I may ask, who else are among the newest of recruits to this unit?