[MAFIA] Game 6: Fate of the Jedi - Completed

[ovinomanc3r 4,436]

17 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Maybe you know them. The whole of this game for me is trying to figure out who they are.

If I knew them I wouldn't give you a list of 5 suspects.

[Onidsen 571]

1 hour ago, Madaghmire said:

Hey @Onidsen what happens if multiple people are tied for most votes at end of round?

That's a no lynch.  If you can't hammer on a no vote, this is the only other way to avoid a lynch.

[Madaghmire 7,274]

8 minutes ago, ovinomanc3r said:

If I knew them I wouldn't give you a list of 5 suspects.

Why not? You certainly wouldnt advertise that you knew.

[Ginkapo 9,320]

On 05/07/2017 at 6:08 PM, Onidsen said:

24 HOURS PEOPLE, WHERE ARE YOU! Is Brobafett even here? Caldias and SmurfWedge notably offering little.

21 hours ago, Truthiness said:

##vote Madaghmire 1.0

So Mad starts a war with Truth on the basis of namesake which Truth is more than happy to oblige with. Note how comfortable they both seem with this arrangement we shall return to this later.

19 hours ago, Truthiness said:

I did. Missing something does not equal not reading. I'll be happy to claim your first "moron" of the game.

Your words.

19 hours ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

BOOP-beep-boop.

Interpretation:

I believe that your question is a textbook example of "irony."

Which textbook? Natalie Imbruglia's?

18 hours ago, GhostofNobodyInParticular said:

::sigh:: Of course somebody would. . .

I still don't understand the benefit of rehashing all the old arguments again, and coming to a plan of action in front of the scum. But if you desire to do so, then by all means, go ahead, I haven't the power or right to stop you. I can only ask that you please not state your plans publicly, as has happened in most if not all of the previous games. 

. . . unless that is your plan, and you are the scum? I'm watching you ::doing the fingers to the eyes thing and pulling a suspicious face:: 

So you dont support Town having plans? I would like to work with my friends here to lynch the Imps in an open and honest way. What have you got to hide? Please spill.

19 hours ago, CaribbeanNinja said:

My name is Six-T9 and I'm in this for the long haul *****.

Soooooo, as he is going to keep this up I fully support a lynch on CNinja.

##Unvote ##Vote CNinja

9 hours ago, ovinomanc3r said:

There is one thing about I am sure: @BiggsIRL is third party.

He said he plays townie when he is townie. He also plays townie when he is mafia. When he plays townie he writes list. He didn't write a list ergo he is not townie or mafia... He is third party.

What is this? (Have I said this before? Maybe just before you were revealed as scum in previous games...)

2 hours ago, ovinomanc3r said:

I will say what I always say. At least one mafia is in the vote game so my list of suspects:

@Ginkapo, @Madaghmire, @BiggsIRL, @Visovics and @Truthiness

5/10 is a good thing I think.

What is this?

2 hours ago, Truthiness said:

Madaghmire truce while we hang up this guy?

Why are you chickening out? What has Mad done that makes you not want to keep up your challenge? What are you afraid of? Why were you so comfortable before but at the first sign of trouble, (Note Biggs vote against Truthi), you chicken out of your challenge.

2 hours ago, Visovics said:

Sorry for the inactivity, just managed to catch up. It's the last days of school, so yesterday I ended up staying the whole day there for a music festival up to 22:30 with my phone out of baterry and had to get up and early and get quickly today cause we went to a theme park, I'm actually on the bus back, but now I can dedicate time for it till the end of the game

I agree that taking Ovi down gives a good insight into his list and main suspects.

Whats worse than making unverifiable excuses for inactivity? Definite promises of activity that are unactioned. What happened to this dedicated time whilst on the bus?

2 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

Yes, it is. From my perspective, it remains possible that Truth is still mafia, and vice versa, but neither of us are dumb enough to do something like this if we were both mafia.

So already you are trying to present Truthi and yourself as Town? Why? Why is it so important to appear town, why is it so important for you to present Truthi as town too?

However, upon merit I really dont know what Ovi is doing.

##unvote ##Vote Ovin

Its perfectly normal for scum to present a list of suscepts to confuse later in the game. Why not. I could say that my scum mate is Biggs. But how does that help anyone? If I flipped scum you wouldnt know if that was a bluff, double bluff or even triple bluff!

[GhostofNobodyInParticular 2,493]

3 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

My side has punch and pie.

Just sayin'

What flavor pie?

2 hours ago, Visovics said:

Sorry for the inactivity, just managed to catch up. It's the last days of school, so yesterday I ended up staying the whole day there for a music festival up to 22:30 with my phone out of baterry and had to get up and early and get quickly today cause we went to a theme park, I'm actually on the bus back, but now I can dedicate time for it till the end of the game

I agree that taking Ovi down gives a good insight into his list and main suspects.

Taking ovi down only helps if he flips scum, as if he's town we still know nothing, and even if he flips scum, we now only know 5 names that he said are driving the voting. We can't just assume that the other 5 names are scum, nor can we automatically clear these 5. It really doesn't tell us much.

2 minutes ago, Ginkapo said:

So you dont support Town having plans? I would like to work with my friends here to lynch the Imps in an open and honest way. What have you got to hide? Please spill.

I redirect you to the Day 0 thread, where we have discussed this at length. I don't feel like repeating myself.

[Madaghmire 7,274]

Actually @Ginkapo, i didnt present us both as town. I simply pointed out that it would be a bad play if we were both mafia.

[Ginkapo 9,320]

2 minutes ago, Madaghmire said:

Actually @Ginkapo, i didnt present us both as town. I simply pointed out that it would be a bad play if we were both mafia.

So if he might be mafia why are you backing out? He chickened which is a sign of weakness. Why is he feeling weak?

[Madaghmire 7,274]

2 minutes ago, Ginkapo said:

So if he might be mafia why are you backing out? He chickened which is a sign of weakness. Why is he feeling weak?

Because there are ten players who "might be mafia" to me. Ovi's post rang more bells then Truth jumping off an early joke vote.

[Madaghmire 7,274]

By the same token, if you disagree with that assessment, why did you follow on Ovi? Also, I dont think truth has actually unvoted me.

[Madaghmire 7,274]

Nvm yes he did

[Visovics 1,675]

25 minutes ago, Ginkapo said:

Whats worse than making unverifiable excuses for inactivity? Definite promises of activity that are unactioned. What happened to this dedicated time whilst on the bus?

Battery died again, basically almost broken iPhone 5s can't take much time out even in battery saving mode and by not using them, I'm now home and will be on for most of the night. And I wasn't very clear, sorry, I'll be able to dedicate time by tomorrow around 14:00, because it's when I finish the scholar year, after that is 2 months of absolute freedom.

I maintain my vote on Cninja for now. He seems to be taking this game differently from the others and hiding behind his character to not give much benefitial input to town

[SmurfWedge 192]

@Ginkapo

Am I notably offering little to gain insight....... or notably offering little to watch prey......or even notably offering little to escape the attention of the Agent......who knows? ......maybe even I don't know.

 

No one expects the Inquisition 

 

[Visovics 1,675]

3 minutes ago, SmurfWedge said:

No one expects the Inquisition 

[SmurfWedge 192]

I was just trying to attach one of those. Haha

[Madaghmire 7,274]

Its main weapon is surprise! Surprise and fear!

..Its two, its two main weapons are surprise, fear, and a ruthless efficiency!

Ok, its three, three main weapons are surprise! Fear! A ruthless efficiency! And an almost fanatical devotion to the pope!

Amongst its diverse weaponry...

[Ginkapo 9,320]

Much chat, so discuss, such insite, wow

[ovinomanc3r 4,436]

I will try to read all later.

All I can say now is that I never said there is no scum between the other 5. I only said that one of them IS between the 5 I mentioned, cause I don't think that every scum keep far from the action. They want to put a finger on every cake. And joke vote is one of them.

I would prefer that you don't lynch me cause is the only I am 100% will fail. But feel free for do what you think is better.

All I ask for is to give me until tomorrow. We have no idea but we have time. 

[Madaghmire 7,274]

I am getting pretty close to feeling like we may as well policy vote someone who has been sitting on the sidelines. Sure it will be a shot in the dark but at least we'll be keeping the people on record alive. When I was mafia I was very much interested in killing people I thought were going to be active, because the more discussion the more chances for something to come to light.

[Truthiness 5,696]

Mad and I have a long history of not taking things seriously. A Highlander war is a nice icebreaker. I don't need a good reason to move off of that. Now voting for some else is worthy of explanation. Ovi's comments asserting that one of the voters to this point must be scum is entirely too much of a definitive statement for day one. That at some of his other odd or definitive statements (What the hell was that timeline and ninja crap about? Are you trying to broadcast a power role again?) were the first truly suspicious actions I saw. Hence moving my vote.

Grasping at straws a little more than usual there Gink. Something to hide?

[GhostofNobodyInParticular 2,493]

6 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

Yes, it is. From my perspective, it remains possible that Truth is still mafia, and vice versa, but neither of us are dumb enough to do something like this if we were both mafia.

Who'd call it dumb? You vote for each other day 1, nobody would expect you to put your necks on the line that quickly, so if one flipped, the other's safe, as your logic above implies. Furthermore, you don't even have to carry the vote to completion. All you need is a convenient townie seeming suspicious, you vote for him, and Boom! You've disassociated yourselves from each other and taken the pressure of each other. It'd be a good play. 

26 minutes ago, Truthiness said:

Mad and I have a long history of not taking things seriously. A Highlander war is a nice icebreaker. I don't need a good reason to move off of that. Now voting for some else is worthy of explanation. Ovi's comments asserting that one of the voters to this point must be scum is entirely too much of a definitive statement for day one. That at some of his other odd or definitive statements (What the hell was that timeline and ninja crap about? Are you trying to broadcast a power role again?) were the first truly suspicious actions I saw. Hence moving my vote.

Grasping at straws a little more than usual there Gink. Something to hide?

I think ovi may just be doing his usual. I don't agree with the third-party bit, I think it a stretch, but otherwise I think he's normal. Only the definiteness is different, and that could just be experience talking. I mean, Gink seems to usually be able to determine people's alignment based on how easily they unvote, so why not seem certain based on 5 games of experience (not much, but when it's the same group of people, enough to get an idea).

I do agree with you though that Gink seems less aggressive and certain than usual. He did say he would lighten up for this one as we no longer need the schooling, so to speak, but his analyses are a bit light today too.

[GhostofNobodyInParticular 2,493]

P.S. I think the timeline stuff was a joke. This Game is set a few years before Games 3 and 4 technically occurred.

[CaribbeanNinja 6,207]

3 hours ago, Visovics said:

Battery died again, basically almost broken iPhone 5s can't take much time out even in battery saving mode and by not using them, I'm now home and will be on for most of the night. And I wasn't very clear, sorry, I'll be able to dedicate time by tomorrow around 14:00, because it's when I finish the scholar year, after that is 2 months of absolute freedom.

I maintain my vote on Cninja for now. He seems to be taking this game differently from the others and hiding behind his character to not give much benefitial input to town

inquisitive blip-boop-whir.

Interpretation:

This is really interesting.  Your reason to press me is that I am playing along with my flavor? (Which involves making a few Blips and beeps btw.)  If you go to all the past 5 games you'll see I'm doing the same exact **** I always do (which, granted is just observing all of the **** going on)...and eventually when Biggs gets back from his Wave Sax outing he'll come up with a huge list, and I'll seem scummy to him for some reason.

I will ask you this though...You seem to be coming up with "RL" excuses a lot this game.  Hiding something?

[CaribbeanNinja 6,207]

BEEP-WHISTLE-boop-blip.

Interpretation:

This is my current analysis of the interactions for Day One:

@Truthiness and @Madaghmire's interaction and quick vote/unvote by Truth were notable.   I totally agree with the fact that these guys are hella-jokers, but that could totally be a great cover for them too.

@ovinomanc3r's really strange reasoning for calling out all of the folks that had voted.  I'm not sure what to make of this.  I had to do a double take to make sure that there wasn't a fool class in the mix.  He seems to want to be lynched.

@Ginkapo just being Gink?  He's driving this so far along with Truth and Madaghmire.  That may or may not be a scum tell.

@BrobaFettand @Caldias are basically MIA.  @SmurfWedge might as well be.

[Truthiness 5,696]

2 hours ago, Madaghmire said:

I am getting pretty close to feeling like we may as well policy vote someone who has been sitting on the sidelines. Sure it will be a shot in the dark but at least we'll be keeping the people on record alive. When I was mafia I was very much interested in killing people I thought were going to be active, because the more discussion the more chances for something to come to light.

Yeah, I'm getting kinda close to this myself. As Ninja pointed out, we have a fair few to choose from.

[Onidsen 571]

Sorry for not keeping up with the Vote Counts so far - I had an interview early this morning and a dentist appointment after that, plus several reasonably long commutes. But I'm back now, and so here's an updated vote count. Let me know if I missed yours (or if it was hiding in a conveniently stealthy paragraph).

Vote Tally: 11 players, 6 to Hammer

Time Remaining: I left a clock on the D1 post, and quicklinked it in the OP. You can find it yourself.

1. @Visovics
2. @Madaghmire - (1) ovinomanc3r
3. @GhostofNobodyInParticular - (1) Caldias
4. @Truthiness - (2) BiggsIRL
5. @BiggsIRL
6. @ovinomanc3r - (2) Madaghmire, Truthiness, Ginkapo
7. @BrobaFett
8. @CaribbeanNinja - (1) Visovics
9. @Caldias
10. @SmurfWedge
11. @Ginkapo - (1) SmurfWedge