HAPPY GAME OF THRONES DAY!

[heychadwick 11,357]

So is Arya the character who doesn't follow through on anything now?

"I'm going to kill loads of people. Nah I can't be bothered".

"I'm going to reunite with my family. Nah I can't be bothered".

"I'm going to become a master assassin. You get the idea..."

 

That's what I don't like about the tv show version.  In the book, she does kill a bunch of people and totally does what she is supposed to with the Faceless Men.  She doesn't "mess up".  In a preview chapter for the next book, they have the whole theatre troop, but she is told to join them to learn how to act.  While she is there, she sees some people on her list that are guarding an envoy from Westeros to the Iron Bank.  They take in a play.  She murders them and decides to leave the Faceless Men to go back home and kill everyone.  So...she totally follows through on everything.  

[Timathius 2,152]

Basically the guy she kills at the inn with the hound is the guy she kills above, a man who was on her list. 

 

Additionally, she kills someone else at the inn in the books who was also on her list. Though, the list is more like "guidelines" than an actual list. 

 

 

But her storyline in the books... man, i know it would be really hard to do in a TV show but she is so much more badass. 

Edited May 31, 2016 by Timathius

[heychadwick 11,357]

Yaar....they're more like "guidelines".

 

I don't see how Sam is going to avoid his father with that Valyrian steel sword.  I mean, he's going to the Citadel.  It's not like he can hide or something.  Though, how much you want to bet he's going to kill an Other with it?

Edited May 31, 2016 by heychadwick

[Timathius 2,152]

Yaar....they're more like "guidelines".

 

I don't see how Sam is going to avoid his father with that Valyrian steel sword.  I mean, he's going to the Citadel.  It's not like he can hide or something.  Though, how much you want to bet he's going to kill an Other with it?

Is he going to the Citadel though? The show is off the reservation on all the other plots so why not his. Its possible that he dips out back to the north

 

But he probably is, and I think that the sandsnakes alluded to one more sister in the show so maybe............. Mr. Tarly looks like he could do with an arrow to the eye.....

 

figured out how to use spoilers.

Edited May 31, 2016 by Timathius

[FTS Gecko 24,135]

Wasn't it Neryn Trant that Arya killed in the released chapter from the next book? Something that happened last season?

It seems to me as though - with Arya and the Lannister's current arcs - that the series took a brief detour abs and is now circling back to the books. Jamie is off to Riverrun; check. Arya killed Trant out of sequence; check.

This is down to the myopic manatee's snail's paced writing, for me. The series threw a couple of things out of sequence and pur some arcs on hold for a season to give him a chance to gethis act together, and since he didn't, they're now circling back to the books in a bid to give him ANOTHER chance.

See Jamie Lannistrr as exhibit a. Should have gone to the Riverlands with Ilyn Payne; went ti Dorne with Bronn instead. Now a year later, he goes back to the original pllan and heads off to the Riverlands.

And with some of the teases we've had in recent weeks - Blackfish, Brotherhood without Banners etc - ut looks like we're going to see previously skipped material turn up.

[Timathius 2,152]

Wasn't it Neryn Trant that Arya killed in the released chapter from the next book? Something that happened last season?

It seems to me as though - with Arya and the Lannister's current arcs - that the series took a brief detour abs and is now circling back to the books. Jamie is off to Riverrun; check. Arya killed Trant out of sequence; check.

This is down to the myopic manatee's snail's paced writing, for me. The series threw a couple of things out of sequence and pur some arcs on hold for a season to give him a chance to gethis act together, and since he didn't, they're now circling back to the books in a bid to give him ANOTHER chance.

See Jamie Lannistrr as exhibit a. Should have gone to the Riverlands with Ilyn Payne; went ti Dorne with Bronn instead. Now a year later, he goes back to the original pllan and heads off to the Riverlands.

And with some of the teases we've had in recent weeks - Blackfish, Brotherhood without Banners etc - ut looks like we're going to see previously skipped material turn up.

 

Nah she kills Raff in Bravos, but all in all yes I see your point. Honestly, I think it comes down to Dorne being a complete screw up that people are so annoyed a Jaime's pacing. 

 

He better find out about Lancel (and Moonboy for all i know) before he leaves. 

[TasteTheRainbow 8,726]

Well! That was pretty fun. Loved seeing CH be the exact person grrm said he wasn't, but in sure that won't be how the books handle it.

 

Yeah....I'm expecting it different in the book.  Still, I wouldn't be too surprised if it was in the book.  I mean, everyone was thinking it.

 

So given the new KL political situation... If Cersei loses her trial by combat(CLEGANEBOWL!) then the gods will have proven Tommen to be no relation to Robert Baratheon, yes? And I think if that happens, then the faith will take over the crown.

The future political situation of Cersei and Dany shifted enormously this weekend in the books and movie, IMO. That new Euron chapter changes Dany's future just as much.

 

What were her crimes that she admitted to?  It wasn't that she slept with her brother.  It was that she slept with Lancel and a few others.  Maybe murdered someone.  It wasn't about King Robert.  As for the High Sparrow...he's not going to knock down his pawn on the throne.

I think the trial is about the things she didn't admit to. Murder and incest are the main things HS accused her of.

[TasteTheRainbow 8,726]

Yaar....they're more like "guidelines".

 

I don't see how Sam is going to avoid his father with that Valyrian steel sword.  I mean, he's going to the Citadel.  It's not like he can hide or something.  Though, how much you want to bet he's going to kill an Other with it?

He's going to give it to Tormund to make the ultimate WW-slaying power couple.

[DariusAPB 6,925]

 

Yaar....they're more like "guidelines".

 

I don't see how Sam is going to avoid his father with that Valyrian steel sword.  I mean, he's going to the Citadel.  It's not like he can hide or something.  Though, how much you want to bet he's going to kill an Other with it?

He's going to give it to Tormund to make the ultimate WW-slaying power couple.

 

That's perfect, how better to piss his dad off?

[heychadwick 11,357]

See Jamie Lannistrr as exhibit a. Should have gone to the Riverlands with Ilyn Payne; went ti Dorne with Bronn instead. Now a year later, he goes back to the original pllan and heads off to the Riverlands.

 

 

You think it's not too late to introduce Stoneheart?  Probably yes as they seem to be ending characters than adding them.  Also, Brienne is far to the North...unless she goes south with Sansa to entice the Blackfish north?

[Timathius 2,152]

 

See Jamie Lannistrr as exhibit a. Should have gone to the Riverlands with Ilyn Payne; went ti Dorne with Bronn instead. Now a year later, he goes back to the original pllan and heads off to the Riverlands.

 

 

You think it's not too late to introduce Stoneheart?  Probably yes as they seem to be ending characters than adding them.  Also, Brienne is far to the North...unless she goes south with Sansa to entice the Blackfish north?

 

Sansa is staying north she is sending Brienne to riverrun so I would not be surprised by a LSH appearance 

[FTS Gecko 24,135]

I thought Sansa sent Brienne to Riverrun on her behalf last week?

I think if we're skipping back to the conflict in the Riverlands, with the Freys and the Tullys, then with Thoros potentially still around we have a CHAMCE for Stoneheart.

Not that I'm all that bothered either way - all Stoneheart has done so far is stand around silently and menacingly and half Freys.

[TasteTheRainbow 8,726]

I think Sansa might fulfill the role. She has already mentioned hanging Freys.

[heychadwick 11,357]

Not that I'm all that bothered either way - all Stoneheart has done so far is stand around silently and menacingly and half Freys.

 

 

Errr....Stoneheart has gotten all the Brotherhood Without Banners to plague the Freys.  They killed a bunch of them, too.  She's done more against the Freys than just silently menace.  Well, she's leading the Brotherhood without Banners.  It's not actually her doing it, but she is directing them.   

 

There's also the whole bit about Brienne and Jamie having to duel or be hung.  

[FTS Gecko 24,135]

All mostly off page. That's fine if you're happy with headcanoning her exploits, but in terms of actual on-page appearances and content, she's probably had about as much to do as Nymeria.

[TasteTheRainbow 8,726]

Yaar....they're more like "guidelines".

 

I don't see how Sam is going to avoid his father with that Valyrian steel sword.  I mean, he's going to the Citadel.  It's not like he can hide or something.  Though, how much you want to bet he's going to kill an Other with it?

He's going to give it to Tormund to make the ultimate WW-slaying power couple.

That's perfect, how better to piss his dad off?

This gem from Reddit:

[heychadwick 11,357]

All mostly off page. That's fine if you're happy with headcanoning her exploits, but in terms of actual on-page appearances and content, she's probably had about as much to do as Nymeria.

 

Does it matter that it's on page actions?  I mean, there was on page action of killing all those Freys.  She wasn't there, but you know it was her directing it.  I don't really need to see her directly do things to feel she's having an effect on things.  

[TasteTheRainbow 8,726]

Does killing Freys really matter in the grand scheme? They are just about the biggest bunch of incompetent buffoons in the entire series. They only pulled off the red wedding with the help of two great houses. They've just been squatting on the twins for centuries.

[Timathius 2,152]

So, just a thought, maybe we should make a book reader and non post? doesn't seem like there are too many people checking this that havent read but still. 

[FTS Gecko 24,135]

Although Hardhome was awesome and happened off page in the books, I'd say in Stoneheart's case it does matter. Quite a lot, in fact.

If you're going to five a big return to an actress like Michelle Fairley then you're going to want her to, you know, actually be seen and heard doing something.

Not just standing around with her mouth (and throat) open, looking angry.

[heychadwick 11,357]

Does killing Freys really matter in the grand scheme? They are just about the biggest bunch of incompetent buffoons in the entire series. They only pulled off the red wedding with the help of two great houses. They've just been squatting on the twins for centuries.

 

There are a lot of things that aren't necessarily crucial to the big picture that are also really cool, though.  The Freys were always more strategic allies due to their control of the Twins.  You can't move an army around without them. 

 

So, just a thought, maybe we should make a book reader and non post? doesn't seem like there are too many people checking this that havent read but still. 

 

I think all the book people that are worried about spoilers are not touching this thread since the entire season is a spoiler (maybe).  There is the other thread that was started to talk about the book only, but since there is no new info....it's been slow.

 

Although Hardhome was awesome and happened off page in the books, I'd say in Stoneheart's case it does matter. Quite a lot, in fact.

If you're going to five a big return to an actress like Michelle Fairley then you're going to want her to, you know, actually be seen and heard doing something.

Not just standing around with her mouth (and throat) open, looking angry.

 

OK...you are talking tv show now, so it does make a difference.  Sure, if it's tv show, then she can get screen time.  Maybe she will be showing up now and playing a bigger part in the story?  She won't spoil the Jon Snow rebirth that everyone who read the books saw coming a mile away.  

 

It is kind of ripe to bring her in and do something massive with the Freys.  

[Timathius 2,152]

Well, it hasn't happened yet so obviously not canon. But, the brotherhood is being hinted at having a red wedding 2.0 in the books where she would probably fit in fairley (HA) prominently. 

Edited May 31, 2016 by Timathius

[TasteTheRainbow 8,726]

I hope Red Wedding 2.0 is just Nymeria's pack consuming the last of the Freys and Boltons. I think the return of Nymeria is likely in the books and more likely than SH in the show.

[DariusAPB 6,925]

I hope the mountain and the high sparrow meet.

 

I hope the bloodshed in that scene pleases Khorne.

[heychadwick 11,357]

I hope the mountain and the high sparrow meet.

 

I hope the bloodshed in that scene pleases Khorne.

 

They won't kill the High Sparrow anytime soon.  I do wonder who the champion for the Seven will be, though.  Lancel?  I doubt it.  Or, if that, he won't live afterwards.  Wait!....I know!  It will be The Hound!   Remember that he's in that monastery.  He will get his revenge on his brother!!!!