ARMADA love over xwing?

[KILODEN 914]

I have to say, with every preview I get more excited about this game.

 

my only fear, is this game going to take away from my xwing gaming time?

 

will FFG release game play campaigns to incorporate both systems?

 

will Armada lead to similar ground based game on larger scale?

 

 

[Extropia 1,475]

Well....i can safely say that it WILL take away from my X-Wing time, simply because working full time etc I only have X hours for gaming as it is, and I have to split that among all my games!

 

That said, i am actually more excited for this anyway. I have always preferred the capital ship aspect of sci-fi, especially Star Wars, and so far the rules look superb!

We can dream about a ground game....

[Corellian Corvette 1,733]

HYPEHYPEHYPEHYPE

[Brian_Black 105]

Given the time to only play one, my current impression would be that I'd pick Armada 80% of the time.  I still enjoy X-wing, but the taste of larger battles that Epic gives that game is broadened even further here.

[Jedhead 855]

I agree that Armada will have to replace X-Wing much of the time for me.  I just don't have time to play both consistently, so Armada will probably win out a majority of the time. 

[KILODEN 914]

that's the boat im in as well, been bouncing between xwing and battletech lately, my buddies wife will kill me if I show him another game.....

 

so I showed him armada.......

 

im in witness protection as I speak.

[L0STHER0 82]

Its just a case of because its new and different people are excited. I am personally going to play both. I'm team star wars not team armada or x-wing

[Xcerus 12]

To be fair - I am looking forward to running skirmish games of Imperial Assault alongside games of Armada and X-Wing in big campaigns.

Attack a planet, if you win attack key ground positions before the defender can move a new fleet to break the blockade. Rebels break blockade by getting a tantive across a 6 X 3 from short end to short end alive in x-wing to resupply the ground forces etc etc

Edited December 8, 2014 by Xcerus

[Mikael Hasselstein 6,898]

I think that this game has the potential to become my favorite game over X-Wing.

 

Whether it does or not is not dependent upon the game itself but my gaming environment. If people in my gaming environment don't adopt it the way that they've adopted X-Wing, then it won't become my favorite game, because I won't get to play it.

[Imperial Advisor Arem Heshvaun 9,503]

im in witness protection as I speak.

 

Totally worth it.

[Imperial Advisor Arem Heshvaun 9,503]

Its just a case of because its new and different people are excited. I am personally going to play both. I'm team star wars not team armada or x-wing

 

Agreed.  Categorically.  It's not Armada vs X-Wing.

 

Its Rightful New Order of The Empire vs this insignificant and pitiful Rebellion.

[Cannis0013 42]

I have always loved the capital ships of Star Wars... the fighters are fun, but incomplete without the caps. I without a doubt am way more excited by Armada than I was about X-Wing and judging by the rules that have been released so, far I think I will enjoy the game more too.

[ldodt 358]

We can dream about a ground game....

 

I would love to see a ground based tactical miniatures war game with vehicles and tanks and squads of troopers and air speeders and at-at's. We have the pilot experience, the commando experience and admiral experience now we just need the general.

[Extropia 1,475]

Yep. And then full campaigns are ready to go!

[Hobojebus 11,341]

Well it depends on how fast a game of armada is, it could be a case of got an hour play some x-wing, got an evening play some armada.

[Norsehound 2,740]

Two significant roadblocks to defecting X-Wingers are going to be Cost and Play-time.

 

Some of our locals are not excited about dropping that much money for three ships, and the heftiness of the expansions don't help matters. Now, these prices may be "standard" for most other miniatures games out there, but X-Wing fans are quite used to the 15-30-45 price point for their most common ships, and starters being only $40. X-Wing's built up a reputation of being a cheap-to-enter game and Armada is not as "accessible" that way.

 

Also, a lot of X-Wing players enjoy how quick these games go. I've never seen an epic match in my local store, and I get the feeling a lot of X-Wing players haven't embraced the epic scene because of the play-time. Not outside of a convention at any rate. Armada might be engaging across those two hours but it's still two hours.

 

So my view is that we're going to have some overlap, but X-Wing and Armada are almost two different worlds. Most Armada potential fans I see come from larger wargaming backgrounds, like Saga or Warhammer or Flames of War. A lot of X-Wingers come from modest board game backgrounds where they haven't spent a lot of time and effort to get in.

[DarthSidious 847]

We don't know how long Armada games are supposed to last, so making decisions based on it seems premature.  As for the price point, it may be that the difference will be a wash.  After all, lots of people have eight TIE Fighters (~$120 retail, give or take, @ $15 each), but we probably won't be able to fit in more than 2-3 of the larger ships (~$120 retail, give or take, @ $40 each).

[Extropia 1,475]

Actually, as a big player of Saga, Infinity and Warmachine....you might have a point there

[Caliber42 229]

I'll probably do X-Wing for local tourney's and Armada for home games. Maybe. Possibly.

 

-Cal

[IraShaine1972 4]

Two significant roadblocks to defecting X-Wingers are going to be Cost and Play-time.

 

Some of our locals are not excited about dropping that much money for three ships, and the heftiness of the expansions don't help matters. Now, these prices may be "standard" for most other miniatures games out there, but X-Wing fans are quite used to the 15-30-45 price point for their most common ships, and starters being only $40. X-Wing's built up a reputation of being a cheap-to-enter game and Armada is not as "accessible" that way.

 

Also, a lot of X-Wing players enjoy how quick these games go. I've never seen an epic match in my local store, and I get the feeling a lot of X-Wing players haven't embraced the epic scene because of the play-time. Not outside of a convention at any rate. Armada might be engaging across those two hours but it's still two hours.

 

So my view is that we're going to have some overlap, but X-Wing and Armada are almost two different worlds. Most Armada potential fans I see come from larger wargaming backgrounds, like Saga or Warhammer or Flames of War. A lot of X-Wingers come from modest board game backgrounds where they haven't spent a lot of time and effort to get in.

2 Hours is an EPIC mini wargame?  My how times have changed.  2 days was once regarded as truly epic.  2 hours.....I have had games that took longer than that to even set up. LOL.

[IraShaine1972 4]

I have $800 in x-wing so far and still don't feel like I have enough variation to truly enjoy the game fully and there is another wave coming.  Its approaching the cost of some of the larger 40k armies I have shelled out for.

[Extropia 1,475]

 

Two significant roadblocks to defecting X-Wingers are going to be Cost and Play-time.

 

Some of our locals are not excited about dropping that much money for three ships, and the heftiness of the expansions don't help matters. Now, these prices may be "standard" for most other miniatures games out there, but X-Wing fans are quite used to the 15-30-45 price point for their most common ships, and starters being only $40. X-Wing's built up a reputation of being a cheap-to-enter game and Armada is not as "accessible" that way.

 

Also, a lot of X-Wing players enjoy how quick these games go. I've never seen an epic match in my local store, and I get the feeling a lot of X-Wing players haven't embraced the epic scene because of the play-time. Not outside of a convention at any rate. Armada might be engaging across those two hours but it's still two hours.

 

So my view is that we're going to have some overlap, but X-Wing and Armada are almost two different worlds. Most Armada potential fans I see come from larger wargaming backgrounds, like Saga or Warhammer or Flames of War. A lot of X-Wingers come from modest board game backgrounds where they haven't spent a lot of time and effort to get in.

2 Hours is an EPIC mini wargame?  My how times have changed.  2 days was once regarded as truly epic.  2 hours.....I have had games that took longer than that to even set up. LOL.

 

 

Haha, quite. I've played plenty of multi-day games....2 hours is a short to average game time for most of my games!

[Ken at Sunrise 2,065]

We don't know how long Armada games are supposed to last, so making decisions based on it seems premature.  As for the price point, it may be that the difference will be a wash.  After all, lots of people have eight TIE Fighters (~$120 retail, give or take, @ $15 each), but we probably won't be able to fit in more than 2-3 of the larger ships (~$120 retail, give or take, @ $40 each).

 

I have a fair amount in X-Wing but that isn't the same as $300 for the Core and 1st Wave.  That is a big difference.  Maybe I won't need as many ships in Armada but this will the game be limited in the number of pieces FFG comes out with or????

 

I've considered of buying the core and a couple of the expansions and stopping there.  Get a good game with enough expansions for variety and stop there.  If I end up doing that I'll probably wait for the reviews.  At this point I'm not terribly excited about the two additional (new) ships in wave 1 anyway.  I could stick with what was in the movies (if balanced) and stop.  Did I just say that?

[mazz0 2,910]

Well, it'll have to take time away from X-Wing, unless you have some free time where you were just not playing X-Wing cos you're bored of it (I don't).

 

I hope I'll end up playing both quite often, but I fear I may find I prefer one over the other and will tend to play that when I get a chance to play something.

[Cannis0013 42]

I like the capital ships better (visually) and strongly suspect that I will enjoy Armada much more. I see so much potential in this game for both quick (2 hour) skirmishes and 12+ hour multiple mission scenarios.

 

At this point X-Wing is beginning to look like the secondary (go to the fighter level after the fleets have engaged) game. And Imperial Assault is starting to look like boarding action/ground combat aspect of the experience...  A trifecta of Star Wars awesomeness!