Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Asmodi

Anything better than Vassal Xwing in the pipeline?

48 posts in this topic

I just think FFG are missing a boat here.

Imagine all the players in the world being able to link up and play and i dont believe it will affect the status quo. If anything it might make it more popular.

 

I know Vassal is out there but its just too cumbersome.

 

Is there anything in the pipeline reguarding an online version?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please, no. An online version would hurt the offline community. If I want to play a game like this on my tablet I'll play Sid Meiers Ace Patrol or Pacific Skies.

Shocker likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not sure it would hurt the community, in fact a faithful representation may well grow the player base. As an analogy I'd never considered any of the card games until I got Magic as a free download for Xbox; played it, enjoyed it, week after I had to have the physical product and have been buying since!

Would be great to test squads against a range of AI builds.

Disgruntled likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Magic: Online has enhanced the community. I would expect X-Wing: Online - If it learned from what MTGO has gotten right and has gotten wrong - to do the same thing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

While I think it could be a great thing, I'm not sure it makes sense from a business perspective. However, FFG does seem to worry less about pure profit than other game companies, so they might actually consider an online version of X-wing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

FFG probably isn't licensed to produce an electronic version of x-wing.

While I think it could be a great thing, I'm not sure it makes sense from a business perspective. However, FFG does seem to worry less about pure profit than other game companies, so they might actually consider an online version of X-wing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It might hurt things a little bit, but I kind of doubt it.

 

I really think it would get more players into the game.  The ones that come from really small communities that either lack an LGS or a sufficient player base will suddenly be able to play.  Pro Players will be able to practice more, and a love of the Online game might get some people in to the tabletop version.  Anyone who has played some couch co-op videogames will know that it's a lot more fun to sit down with a couple of friends, crack some beers, and play from the comfort of your own living room.  Playing with a bunch of random guys online isn't nearly as cool.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I also think an accessible, fun to play online version increases the retention factor in this game. I've had many people tell me that vassal "kept" them in the game between their real bouts in LFGS, since they were unable to go out and find games, for all sorts of reasons: lack of a group, newborn baby, to cite 2 examples.

When any board or tactical game doesn't hit the table even once during long months, it tends to be sold away.

 

I fully admit vassal isn't the best possible implementation of online X-Wing but it *has* improved in the last year in terms of player aides, reduction of fidliness through auto-movements and there's a jumpstart guide http://s93768914.onlinehome.us/xwing/ that you can consult. If you have any suggestion for additional entries for it, feel free.

 

So far, I'm aware of 2 different projects for a online X-Wing replacement. One started in January, one started in August, both of this year. I haven't seen any news or progress shots on them so far. If a good platform crops up, I'll be the first to jump ship and finally return to just playing and enjoying the game.

Edited by Mu0n
Osoroshii, Rinehart and Veldrin like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just think FFG are missing a boat here.

Imagine all the players in the world being able to link up and play and i dont believe it will affect the status quo. If anything it might make it more popular.

 

I know Vassal is out there but its just too cumbersome.

 

Is there anything in the pipeline reguarding an online version?

 The best part for FFG is they could make you register your ships with your proof of purchases. If there's a "purchase code" on them (haven't looked close enough) it's a veritable gold mine for them just waiting to happen.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please, no. An online version would hurt the offline community. If I want to play a game like this on my tablet I'll play Sid Meiers Ace Patrol or Pacific Skies.

 

Making something more accessible across several platforms has never decreased sales of that something in history, It also lets you get comfortable with the rules and how ships move before you actually go out and find someone to play against, which (again, just anecdotal evidence) appears to be the largest barrier to entry for -every- game.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

X-wing on Vassal works just fine. Thanks to Mu0n for all of his hard work!

 

I dare say it does but there never seems to be anyone online, well; maybe 1 or 2 games.

Maybe i just need to find someone with the patience of a saint to show me what to do :D

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I think a user friendly on line version would be a great idea. Since I've been on this site I've heard far too many players say they have been reluctant to jump in due to lack of local players. An on line global game format would help many of those players.

I haven't played on Vassel, but I hear good things about it. The benefit to FFG might be on line tourneys that they could get a global participation for. Maybe even a true World championship. The possibilities are endless.. regional tourneys that actually include a larger sampling of the region.

Edited by oneway

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

X-wing on Vassal works just fine. Thanks to Mu0n for all of his hard work!

 

I dare say it does but there never seems to be anyone online, well; maybe 1 or 2 games.

Maybe i just need to find someone with the patience of a saint to show me what to do :D

I'm new to vassal. I would download and install all of the pieces you need. Spend 30-45 minutes building a squad. That takes the longest in the beginning. Make sure you save it. Then play around with the interface and the Mormons. There is a handy quick reference in game. Play one game and you'll be set. There learning curve isn't all that steep. By about the 4th game you'll have hot keys down and be moving much faster. But if you read up and play one game with someone teaching you, you'll be set for the next one. Then you'll spend the downtime building squads. And watching games. I would highly recommend it to everyone. The quality of play is higher than my locals. I'll be a better player because of it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

FFG probably isn't licensed to produce an electronic version of x-wing.

 

While I think it could be a great thing, I'm not sure it makes sense from a business perspective. However, FFG does seem to worry less about pure profit than other game companies, so they might actually consider an online version of X-wing.

 

 

Oh yeah, were you in the negotiations they had with Disney? If I recall, everyone kept screaming they didn't have an EU license or prequel license. Turns out they did. Everyone also said that they didn't have the rights to make SW board games either. Turns out they had that too.

 

So do you know anything else they've done behind closed doors?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

X-wing on Vassal works just fine. Thanks to Mu0n for all of his hard work!

 

I dare say it does but there never seems to be anyone online, well; maybe 1 or 2 games.

Maybe i just need to find someone with the patience of a saint to show me what to do :D

 

 

If you ever see me online, I'll gladly show you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

X-wing on Vassal works just fine. Thanks to Mu0n for all of his hard work!

 

I dare say it does but there never seems to be anyone online, well; maybe 1 or 2 games.

Maybe i just need to find someone with the patience of a saint to show me what to do :D

 

If you ever see me online, I'll gladly show you.

s1n is a great teacher.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Vassal is a great alternative to real games, but a fully automated online game would definitely be fun.

 

Some things can really slow vassal games down, most notably ship crashes and having to manually reposition the ships.  Having something like that automated would be awesome.

Osoroshii likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I also think an accessible, fun to play online version increases the retention factor in this game. I've had many people tell me that vassal "kept" them in the game between their real bouts in LFGS, since they were unable to go out and find games, for all sorts of reasons: lack of a group, newborn baby, to cite 2 examples.

When any board or tactical game doesn't hit the table even once during long months, it tends to be sold away.

 

I fully admit vassal isn't the best possible implementation of online X-Wing but it *has* improved in the last year in terms of player aides, reduction of fidliness through auto-movements and there's a jumpstart guide http://s93768914.onlinehome.us/xwing/ that you can consult. If you have any suggestion for additional entries for it, feel free.

 

So far, I'm aware of 2 different projects for a online X-Wing replacement. One started in January, one started in August, both of this year. I haven't seen any news or progress shots on them so far. If a good platform crops up, I'll be the first to jump ship and finally return to just playing and enjoying the game.

One feature I would love to see is auto bump. The only thing left to fiddle with is when you bump and try to obtain the correct position.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have heard a lot about vassal. I downloaded it, played it. But it is just too daunting and cumbersome. Even a watered down version (similar to warhammer quest - an online version of the 1990s hero quest) would be great.

Asmodi and zathras23 like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0