Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
richsabre

What you never play

19 posts in this topic

i know this has been done before but there are a lot of new people since i remember this thread being active, so....

 

what quests do you NEVER play? and why? are they too hard, too boring, or just have you not gotten round to trying it yet?

 

i never play shadow and flame, its just not ...hmm 'questy' enough for me :D i prefer longer quests, that feel like a journey

 

also i never play the riddle quest... i tried it with some friends, and we sort of got sick of it, since then i havent tried it again

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Riddle neither. Nightmare is worse...
Rhosgobel, heal or nothing.
Emyn Muil, Nightmare is better.
Blood of Gondor, insanly difficult in multiplayer.
Into Ihtilien, same.
Cair Andros, same.
I am mostly playing 2 or more, never solo.

legolas18 likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah. I never play this riddle quest. Too random, unless you build for it exclusively. Rhogsobel also, very specific quest. 

I tend to avoid battle and siege quests, while I love them - not every deck will fit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm not a big fan of quests which require you to either split the staging area or guess at random card traits.  I don't look forward to the riddles of gollum.

 

Pretty much this.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Riddles in the Dark- just too random and Bilbo dies too easily

Flies and Spiders- also just annoying, the poison gets out of control

Shadow and Flame- just got slammed so much I haven't played it in a long time

Battle of Lake-town- for some reason I still haven't played it even though I've had it forever. I guess I don't look forward to getting smashed by Smaug ;)

PsychoRocka likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Riddles in the Dark- just too random and Bilbo dies too easily

Flies and Spiders- also just annoying, the poison gets out of control

Shadow and Flame- just got slammed so much I haven't played it in a long time

Battle of Lake-town- for some reason I still haven't played it even though I've had it forever. I guess I don't look forward to getting smashed by Smaug ;)

Pretty much this!! Also don't like the troll hobbit quest as I hate sacks... I play somewhat slower less ally filled decks and focus on a handful of powerful characters moreso so struggle pretty hard against the sacks. Oh and Flight from Moria as well... really don't like the randomness of the quest stages, almost as bad as the riddles in the dark!

Shadow and Flame isn't so bad, as rarely as I do play it i'd honestly rather play it than Flight from Moria or Riddles. Also just wanted to add I don't NEVER play these just very rarely compared to others or only if I feel like playing through the saga in the case of flies and spiders, riddles and the trolls.

Catastrophic09 likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I very rarely or never play:

 

Passage through Mirkwood - Too easy

Journey Down the Anduin - Very good quest but bored to death of it

Conflict at the Carrok - This one is like putting the same puzzle together again every time you play it  

Flight from Moria - I really like this quest.....for some reason I just haven't played it for a while

Road to Rivendell - So boring, however the enemies in this quest are great I think.  

Watcher in the Water - You do not know how much I hate the tentacles.....

Shadow and Flame - ehhh

The siege of cair andros - I built a deck that beat this quest 15 times in a row and two times I had a mumak on the first turn. It was easier than passage through mirkwood.  Haven't played it since.

Blood of Gondor - ehhh I just didn't like it.  

I didn't really like any of the Voice of Isengard quests that much.  I do not play those very often at all.

All the Saga quests I rarely play also.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I didn't like the battle and siege idea from the beginning, i find it to be a really cheap trick to mess with the player decks, it also breaks the "balance" of the game, making some cards really useless and others so much stronger.

 

so the quests with those 2 keywords are the quest that i play less.

richsabre likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I never play the Black Riders quests.

Because my daughter destroyed one of the encounter cards (well actually it's not completely unusable but is terribly marked). 

However my heart sinks every time I think about using it.

She also got hold of Beravor but fortunately a marked hero isn't really a problem (Also I always intended to get a second core set when they finished all errata on it - so the fact that I have to replace her seems like a future plan).

Apart from that; I usually play my adventures thematically (so if I set out to play the against the shadow cycle I intend to play all 6 adventures). 

This keeps me from choosing the adventures I want to play and helps me to use all the cards I own.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I rarely play Escape from Dol Guldur. I have been playing since day one of LoTR LCG, and remember being repeatedly stomped on by that quest. I remember managing to beat it once with only core set cards, but barely, and with lots of lucky draws. 

 

Once my card pool had expanded significantly, I remember going back to beat it once or twice for good measure. But, I still stay away from it and won't play it unless someone in my playgroup really, really wants to. It is also the one nightmare deck that I have not tried...

 

With respect to Escape from Dol Guldur, trust me, "I've seen some ****, man."

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I rarely play Escape from Dol Guldur. I have been playing since day one of LoTR LCG, and remember being repeatedly stomped on by that quest. I remember managing to beat it once with only core set cards, but barely, and with lots of lucky draws. 

 

Once my card pool had expanded significantly, I remember going back to beat it once or twice for good measure. But, I still stay away from it and won't play it unless someone in my playgroup really, really wants to. It is also the one nightmare deck that I have not tried...

 

With respect to Escape from Dol Guldur, trust me, "I've seen some ****, man."

As punishing as it is I really like the nightmare version of this quest, great mechanics. I don't find Dol Guldur so hard with the expanded card pool anymore, that is as long as the captured hero isn't someone integral to your team or a hero who is the only on his team of a certain sphere thereby rendering that sphere unplayable.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I very rarely or never play:

 

Passage through Mirkwood - Too easy

Journey Down the Anduin - Very good quest but bored to death of it

Conflict at the Carrok - This one is like putting the same puzzle together again every time you play it  

Flight from Moria - I really like this quest.....for some reason I just haven't played it for a while

Road to Rivendell - So boring, however the enemies in this quest are great I think.  

Watcher in the Water - You do not know how much I hate the tentacles.....

Shadow and Flame - ehhh

The siege of cair andros - I built a deck that beat this quest 15 times in a row and two times I had a mumak on the first turn. It was easier than passage through mirkwood.  Haven't played it since.

Blood of Gondor - ehhh I just didn't like it.  

I didn't really like any of the Voice of Isengard quests that much.  I do not play those very often at all.

All the Saga quests I rarely play also.

Wow.... thats like 21 quests you've listed, almost half the quests to date =\

Dain Ironfoot likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

With around 40 quests available now, and limited playtime, almost all of the quests are on my "rarely played" list.  When I do sit down for a game, I almost always make it a point to go back and play one I haven't done for awhile.  But I do actively avoid Into Ithilien, too many bad memories...

Edited by GrandSpleen

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

With around 40 quests available now, and limited playtime, almost all of the quests are on my "rarely played" list.  When I do sit down for a game, I almost make it a point to go back and play one I haven't done for awhile.  But I do actively avoid Into Ithilien, too many bad memories...

I remember my first time ever playing that quest and getting to stage 3; The Hidden Way. Within a round on that stage I was like wait what.... like half this particular encounter deck is enemies and not only do they not engage me but I can't even engage one a turn like on JdtA? This is goddamn broken and insanely hard. I then did not beat the quest for a very very long time. Now I ALWAYS let Celador die and do stage 2 instead, infinitely easier.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

With limited playtime, almost all of the quests are on my "rarely played" list.  

There is your reason why I have 21 quests on my rarely play list.  I don't understand where people get so much time to play everyday......

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't have much time to play at the moment, but when I do play I find I rearly play the core quests, the Mirkwood cycle, Against the shadow cycle (except Stewards fear), the Voice of Isenguard quests, or many of the Hobbit quests.

I just don't find the recent quests as interesting as some of the ones from a couple of years ago.

 

I tend to find myself going back to old favourites, like Khazadum, Moria, Heirs, Riders...

 

But that could also be because i haven't found the time to explroe new deckbuilding for quite a while, so much of the player card pool from the last year or two i haven't used.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0