Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
Nemomon

Talisman The Woodland Expansion!

302 posts in this topic

I don't understand why The City is considered nonlinear. You can't even go backwards! Sure you can stop at any store, but compared to the Dungeon and Highland where you could go in either direction freely, The City is even more linear!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am very excited to see them finally use the light and dark sides of fate.  This will add a fun, and unique feel to the already amazing game.

 

Finally all of the OCD owners can rest easy now we will have the 4th corner. :lol:

 

Long Live Talisman!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Finally a reason for two sided fate tokens. LOL I think the "path" mechanic sounds fun, will that be just in the forest or will it apply for other effects in other regions once you leave forest?

 

I'm guessing the path mechanic will be for the Woodland expansion only. You step into it, choose a path, and once you get your destiny you "step off" the path so to speak.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

♫♫I'm so excited,

And I just can't hide it,
I'm about to lose control
And I think I like it.
I'm so excited,
And I just can't hide it,
And I know, I know, I know, I know
I know I want you, want you.♫♫

 

I don't know why but that popped in my head yesterday when I saw this on FFG's website.  

 

The idea of Light/Dark fate...oh yeah.  The concept of making my friends reroll that die when they needed a 6 and got it?!? hahaha , I love it!

 

Seriously though, I am one of those OCD people that looks at my board with that missing corner and dies a little inside.  

 

I love the idea of insta-toadings.  I see toads very rarely on the board, we need more! 

 

Encounters with creatures that kill you off?  Yes, please.  Especially when you roll and win...but I spend a Dark fate and say "reroll that, (insert sardonic comment here)"  haha.

 

So far it looks good and like others I am very surprised they are pushing this out so quickly.....NOW, if they would only follow through on an FAQ!  

DomaGB and 0beron like this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am so excited too, Jedi, and thanks for "Point"-ing the way!

 

My wife is only excited over Dark Fate and using it to make other players re-roll their die. (who knew she was really competitive this way, after all?)

 

No one likes being turned into a Toad, but I agree that we see few of them in our games.

 

The possibility of instant and irrevokable Death has always been one of the guilty and dirty secrets of Talisman. I think there are 'sudden death' situations in most of the expansions, so why not.

 

I kept thinking 3rd quarter is end of the year, but I realize that it is not... and the previous poster who thinks it might be out by Gen-Con is probably right. If I wasn't too busy with other conferences and things in August I would go ('bout a 4 hour drive from Detroit area).

 

But I bought the Firelands at an area Hobby store (previously only bought online) and I think I will support a local Ven-Dorr this time too!

JediKnightAmoeba likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am so excited too, Jedi, and thanks for "Point"-ing the way!

 

My wife is only excited over Dark Fate and using it to make other players re-roll their die. (who knew she was really competitive this way, after all?)

Will you play an Oberon-Titania game if those are in fact the two characters?

0beron likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yes,

 

Full disclosure: I'm a Wiccan of many years (since around 1970) and Oberon is my *Magickal* name. I actually took the name from a character in a comic book, the Assistant to Mr. Miracle in a DC comic book around that same time. Mr. Miracle was some sort of escape artist who was also related to other magical/super folks (I kinda forget him, but not his assistant, Oberon)

 

I also note that 'Oberon' was the name of an obscure character in Dark Shadow, the gothicy soap opera from that time as well.   But yeah, Shakespeare, Midsummer's Eve, Oberon, etc.  That suits me too

 

*** EDIT, hour later - - and of course you're asking if my wife will be Titania to my "Obie".

 

Truth to tell she prefers the luck of the draw; we usually deal 7 cards each and pick one from them. We've also started 'eliminating' the played ones. So we eventually work through the entire range of characters.

  At any rate, I do have half a mind to mandate that only I can be "Oberon" (and perhaps can just play it default?)

Edited by 0beron

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

Finally a reason for two sided fate tokens. LOL I think the "path" mechanic sounds fun, will that be just in the forest or will it apply for other effects in other regions once you leave forest?

 

I'm guessing the path mechanic will be for the Woodland expansion only. You step into it, choose a path, and once you get your destiny you "step off" the path so to speak.

 

I agree, I don't think the mechanic include the other boards. But it would be cool, to see a future expansion updating the "Adventure" cards from the main board and the previous expansions. Maybe some kind of expansion the link all the previous expansions together (like the one they made for Arkham Horror).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

Finally a reason for two sided fate tokens. LOL I think the "path" mechanic sounds fun, will that be just in the forest or will it apply for other effects in other regions once you leave forest?

 

I'm guessing the path mechanic will be for the Woodland expansion only. You step into it, choose a path, and once you get your destiny you "step off" the path so to speak.

 

I agree, I don't think the mechanic include the other boards. But it would be cool, to see a future expansion updating the "Adventure" cards from the main board and the previous expansions. Maybe some kind of expansion the link all the previous expansions together (like the one they made for Arkham Horror).

 

I personally don't see why the new Fate mechanic cannot apply beyond the Woodland board, though future news may reveal if that is true or false.

 

 However, these comments make me wonder if POD expansions will have some fixes, or ....

 

   those of us who want to see even more connectiveness between boards, and expansions, want PODs which can do that.

 

Or PODs that can enhance or be an expansion to an existing expansion.

 

So maybe a POD that ties in with Blood Moon, but is more Vampire oriented? The Vampire's Tower.

 

Or a POD that "unites" some of the bosses for a smackdown of epicness.  Ice Queen, Reaper and Lord of Darkness do a tag team on the regular players.

 

Things like that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I wonder if i will not use some of the minis to make some homemade heroes for descent

a druid class morphing into a treant thing with the treant, and the man with the bear on the shoulders as a druid.

 

mmhh ... hope it will comes soon !

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Yeah, I think the Light, Dark fate is a rule that can be implemented straight away. A first look it sounds unbalanced (with evil characters and characters that replenish fate quickly) but then you realise that by choosing Dark fate you are choosing to lose a Light fate to use for protection. I think maybe limit a player to one Dark fate use a round. But then again maybe not.

 

The only thing is timing issues and can a player use a Light fate to re-roll the effect of a Dark fate. I think not... But these are issues. All in all I think it will make a Talisman game more involved. Put other players in the game during other players turns more. Thus improving gameplay :).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
But as long as you've mentioned these things, what would you really have liked with a Forest or Woodland expansion. Would you have done anything, or wanted anything in the way of light/dark Fate? This seems to be one of the most asked-for things by fans who post here, so what would you have done different with that.

 

I'm not trying to argue, btw, I am interested in what you think could still be better.

 

The addition to light and fark fate I am fine with. They seem to be general rules, though, and not specifically applying towards the Forest corner, though they have an impact on the Forest enouncter cards. It would've been nicer to introduce these rules for fate a few expansions ago, so these effects could have been included in later expansions as well.

 

It's not so much about the City being linear or not, which can be argued, due to the shops. It's layout is completely different from the Dungeon and the Highlands, which are both basically a single long trek. We already have 2 boards of "travel along this single path towards the endboss". Do we really need a 3rd?

 

Some things they could have done:

- Allow a fork in the path somewhere, so you'd have to choose between two different routes. Perhaps one appealing to Craft and the other to Strength, or one appealing to Lightbound and the other to Darkbound, or maybe something as simple as one side being a lot of draw cards and the other being mostly encounters written on the squares.

- Add a river to the board, between the first and second row or between the second and third row, so that people with options to cross the storm river could take a shortcut on this board instead.

- Devote a small section of the board to expand the Village, which would be separate from the rest of the board.

 

And there are plenty of other ways to make it not like a 3rd Dungeon/Highlands. Missed opportunities.

 

As for complete gib cards, I never liked them much. They make the luck factor way too big. Too much gib cards in the forest expansion would simply cause me to never visit that corner during a boardgame.

Edited by Thels
0beron likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Games Workshop are pulling the strings behind the scenes as they hold the Talisman copyright and license it to FFG. This means that Games Workshop have a lot of say in how things pan out in expansions.

DomaGB likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you Thels,

 

 

You did a good job of articulating what you want, and as I see it, those are very good ideas, and questions, some of which I have thought of two, the River, and you also explained the fork in the road/non linear.

 

To Talismanamsilat, I would say I had no idea this was still the case and of course makes sense.

 

Without seeing the board in better detail I don't want to say how boring/same/linear it is, until I know more. If there are some interesting spaces where things happen, that are not exactly like the other boards, I would be pleased.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's not so much about the City being linear or not, which can be argued, due to the shops. It's layout is completely different from the Dungeon and the Highlands, which are both basically a single long trek. We already have 2 boards of "travel along this single path towards the endboss". Do we really need a 3rd?

 

Some things they could have done:

- Allow a fork in the path somewhere, so you'd have to choose between two different routes. Perhaps one appealing to Craft and the other to Strength, or one appealing to Lightbound and the other to Darkbound, or maybe something as simple as one side being a lot of draw cards and the other being mostly encounters written on the squares.

- Add a river to the board, between the first and second row or between the second and third row, so that people with options to cross the storm river could take a shortcut on this board instead.

- Devote a small section of the board to expand the Village, which would be separate from the rest of the board.

 

And there are plenty of other ways to make it not like a 3rd Dungeon/Highlands. Missed opportunities.

 

These are all ideas that could have been developed, but I don't think that the Woodland would necessarily feel so similar to the Dungeon or Highland. The preview hints at a mechanic which will guide your journeys through the Woodland by the drawing of Path cards. They've presented only a single card, the Runebound Path, but I suppose there will be many more, with different effects.

 

Then there's the space layout, which could mirror exactly the Dungeon or Highland, or be completely different. Of course there's much that could be done to make the spaces less standard than the Dungeon's or the Highland's.

 

I would also like a non-linear board, but not necessarily on a corner board. I still hope we will see a non-linear Sea expansion sooner or later, that replaces the Timescape with a similar travel system, but without multiverse or WH 40k contamination.

 

As for complete gib cards, I never liked them much. They make the luck factor way too big. Too much gib cards in the forest expansion would simply cause me to never visit that corner during a boardgame.

 

That Toad King looks like a guaranteed Toading, but the other cards highly depend on that lightbound/darkbound mechanic which is explained in the preview, so you should probably start to manage your fate in a different way.

 

Of course if the Woodland deck is full of dangers with no considerable reward, I would also skip the Region entirely. However, if those risks are balanced by great rewards, then why not? I think the Highland and City deck are rather boring and don't have so many dangers, even though I enjoy the variety of cards. The Highland is well balanced by the low risk/low reward ratio, and the City might also be considered balanced, if a couple of items were not outrageously powerful. It's a Region where you can spend your gold well, but where you shouldn't venture if you don't have any (you will lose your time). If the Woodland has a good risk/reward ratio, even if it is a high/high balance, then it will be something new and a good addition to Talisman.

 

The Destiny cards seem like a good addition to a character's set of abilities. The Runebound Path allows you to gain a Destiny if you fulfill a condition at a certain point (the "Meeting with Destiny" space, which I cannot spot on the board); cards that give you abilities such as the Dreaded will be something I would gladly display to someone who travels around the board, armed with a Flail, and is convinced that nobody can ever hurt him.

 

Games Workshop are pulling the strings behind the scenes as they hold the Talisman copyright and license it to FFG. This means that Games Workshop have a lot of say in how things pan out in expansions.

 

This is quite a big assumption. GW own the copyright and license for Talisman and they could probably influence some choices, like the re-issue of expansions that were part of 2nd and 3rd edition. That's probably why we have the 4 corners exactly like in the 2nd and 3rd editions. But I don't think they would interfere into the design process of such expansions, if this is what you're arguing.

Edited by The_Warlock
Invictus5000 likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree that it is quite possible that the horned thingie and the woman in dress is Oberon and Titania.

I was more hoping for a generic Satyr and an Dryad or Fae since I much prefer the formula of a Elf, Warrior, Monk, Knight, Ranger etc. get after the Crown, than specific persons like Titania, King Arthur, Conan or Red riding hood.

 

But since the horns on the "satyr" is more of a spirit of the forest a la "Herne the hunter" or the "Forest spirit" from Mononoke Hime I guess Oberon is more plausible.

 

If they indeed are the King and Queen of the fairies I hope there is a good story behind why they set out to possible fight each other to get the Crown on Command.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Maybe now after the release of all GW expansions (except Timescape) FFG has a free choice and will be able to benefit even more from their ideas. I just hope that does not kill our beloved game now. :) It would be nice to see the Timescape mechanics in a big box Sea expansion and another small box which expand all the other expansions. I hope they will release at least 2 more expansions...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The Woodland contains:

  • A new corner board, depicting the wilds of the Woodland
  • Five new characters to join your adventures
  • Three new alternative endings
  • ----------->Over twenty brand new tokens<------------
  • Nearly 150 new cards to bring the Woodland alive

 

I wonder what these are for.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Destiny and Path Cards + Woodlands deck for sure.

 

Though fifty some odd cards does seem like a lot to cover what we know of the Destiny and Paths, that seems more like 10-15 cards a deck max.

 

Paths seem like they would be about the size of the bountys deck and Destiny seems like it would be about the size of the relic or treasures.

 

All speculation though :)

 

Dying to know what the spider token is for :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Finally! Finally we have fourth corner board :D

It's nice that designers kept true to the legacy of older Talisman editions but I can't help but wonder what they have in store for us next. With the classic corner boards out of the way the posibilities are vast - providing they'll keep developing new expansions. I would love to see some sea related board (maybe Talisman Island ;) ).

I know I'm getting ahead  of myself, they just announces Woodland, but  my apetite for Talisman expansions is insatiable :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

my first thought as i saw it on ffg main page :

 

 

 

 

Jaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa   !!!!!!!

 

 

 

 

i hope they release it before wwIII starts

DomaGB likes this

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am glad that with every expansion we get more complete and less random game. For those who do not like Scribe from the City there is a Runebound Path which may deprive a Character using Scribe from annoying spells. Nasty! I hope other paths will be just as useful and they prepere something to stop the Alchemist character. 

Edited by Croonos

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, the Scribe only helps you keep those annoying spells, but I get your point. Some spells are annoying when they happen once, but the potential to keep recasting them...

 

Which means, since I believe you 'choose' a path (unless there is only 1 left to choose from?).  So a character who really likes his annoying spells may not choose that?

 

I guess we need to know more about mechanics, but maybe you're right and that's the point. 

 

"every expansion we get more complete and less random game"  (all things come to those who wait)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Must be toooo anxious as I'm posting rather often here.

 

But I just noticed something. In the News description it implies, more or less that there are a number or different type of 'Destiny' cards. We're given the examples of The Dreaded and The Wise, but

in the picture showing the board, figures and some cards there is a partially obscured card The Vaga__ or The Vaca__ ? It appears to be a Destiny card, a dark one.

 

Not sure if anyone else mentioned this. Wonder how many and how far reaching or types of effects they utilize.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0