Jump to content

kkuja

Members
  • Content Count

    302
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by kkuja

  1. kkuja

    Verse and Rune Magic vs Arcana

    You are not blind, and did not miss anything/much. There is no career with verse skill as career skill. Only way to be a Bard and use verse magic is to buy Tier 2 talent bard, and then a rank in Verse skill. In our game, bards are (mostly) envoys with Bard talent. If you want a dedicated bard career, then it's pretty easy to make one from e.g. Envoy (see Runemaster for ideas). I may be incorrect, if so, please someone correct me.
  2. Write an email to the company owning the IP, and ask about their policies. Usually they give you quite a clear answers. I have done it few times. Different companies have different policies. Some allow you to publish free products freely, as long as you acknowledge the IP owners. Some don't allow you publish anything. Some allow you to even publish and sell. But in my experience, best way to find out is to ask from IP owners.
  3. kkuja

    experience points deflation

    IMO, it's not good or bad idea, it's a change, which may work for you. Personally, it wouldn't for for me, because I often give additional points of XP from good roleplaying. And base amount is based on time (following Jay Little's recommendation for SW, which was 5 points per hour or actual playtime), and currently our session usually are from 1.5 to 2 hours, which means 7 to 10 XP plus 0-3 points based on player actions. With your change, you would lose some granularity when giving XP, but only you can find out whether that is problem, because that fully depends on your gaming style.
  4. Ok, I understand. I have seen your dice roller, and and explored it, but somehow I didn't connect it to you. Also, it's nice to know other people have similar needs than we do. Anyway, thank you for everything you have done for the community.
  5. kkuja

    Lich Master, an unofficial companion application for Genesys

    One question. Will this be windows only application? I love the idea, and believe this will be a great asset. Thank you.
  6. Awesome work Skyjedi! Just one question. Is it possible to remove talents from character? As I was testing the site, I didn't find a way to remove talent I added to character. Also, feature request for version n+1 (after you have nothing else to do ). A dice roller shared with all characters of one GM. (Background, I mostly GM online games using Roll20, and I'm looking an alternative to that, and in addition to this character sheet, all I need is a dice roller where I could put a difficulty to a PC and that player could click a "roll dice" icon next to skill, and software would roll dice, and show results automatically calculate number of successes/failures etc.) I'm not expecting you to ever to do the dice roller as it's quite a much work, and it's not actually in the core focus of this project. But, because you are sharing your code, I may fork it to our own project, and maybe add a dice roller to it. But again, thank you for your awesome work.
  7. kkuja

    Any longer campaign experiences so far?

    Not in Genesys, but in Star Wars (which is almost same system but Genesys has some rule enhancements, which would have fixed few of my problems (like PCs hoarding Dedications)), I GM'd 81 session campaign. At the end it was a bit cumbersome for me as a GM because 1) I gave a bit too much XP (characters gained well over 1000 xp), but 2) more importantly, I locked myself to SW canon too heavily. That campaign will continue later now that I have solutions to problems. I don't see any reasons why Genesys wouldn't work in longer campaigns. Power level will rise over time, but happens in every system with character development. IMHO GM need focus on few things in longer campaign: 1) Don't give too much XP (recommendations in book are good), 2) Make sure PCs don't cheese and min-max too much, 3) don't plan too much ahead in detail. Have a rough guideline in your usage, but e.g. give opponents stats when it's appropriate, and don't mind changing them appropriately if PCs gain more XP than you anticipated (e.g. from additional side quests).
  8. kkuja

    "Prepare" an action?

    This is a bit of thread necromancy, so sorry for that. I just had something to say about, which I fell may be useful to some people. I'd handle the situation with normal rules and bit of creativity. I'd say to player that, "You can attack the opponent with deception (or cool if that suits better) against its vigilance, and if you succeed, you lure the enemy to the gas pool and light it at optimal time". On success PC would attack the opponent with fire. Personally I like when PCs attack opponents with unconventional skills. This works for our group, but YMMV. As one eyed pirate said, events actually happen fairly simultaneously, and PCs and opponents don't neatly wait their turns to hit, while other hack and slash at their turns. We can use this fact to our advantage. And Genesys is narrative system, not combat simulation, so PC action can narratively be delayed, but rules wise handled normally. I.e. PC acts normally on his/her turn, and that action's effect comes to play in NPC initiative slot. This requires some leniency from GM, and PCs, but in my experience works well. In this case there IMHO is no need for delayed action. I understand that sometimes delayed actions are useful, but most of usually situations can be handled normally in Genesys, when we just remember to keep PCs acting proactively and use a bit of creativity.
  9. kkuja

    Adversary Attack Damage

    As Swordbreaker said, "every uncancelled success", including the first one. So, all damages are actually at least +1 when attack hits. So minimum damage in this case is 6.
  10. kkuja

    The Dice Pool Podcast - Night's Edge Setting

    Hi @GM Hooly. I have listened all your dicepool podcast episodes (mostly while doing something else, like housework, so I have missed many details), and I'm anxiously waiting for more. I love the content. I just dropped by to ask do you have a plan to release the Night's edge setting as written document? Thank you for the podcast. You are doing great work.
  11. kkuja

    Arkham Horror for Genesys

    Call of Cthulhu 7th edition has two gaming modes, normal (the deadly) and Pulp, which is so much more forgiving. Personally I'm not sure if Genesys is the best system for Cthulhu games. For pulp games it probably would work, but I personally probably wouldn't use it for purist games, where focus isn't in cinematic action, but more in "can I survive?" or "how will I perish?". I started doing a Genesys conversion for my favourite horror game, but quit because I came to a conclusion that changing the system to Genesys would change the spirit of the original game too much. Of course, very much of how suitable Genesys is, depends on personal preferences.
  12. kkuja

    Arkham Horror for Genesys

    AFAIK, AH is FFG product currently. IPs of Lovecraftian works are interesting. Chaosium of course owns its Ctlhulhu related stuff. Lovecraft's book are largely seen as public domain, even though there is (or at least was) some dispute whether someone still owns them. E.g. Derleth (Arkham house) claimed he owned all Lovecraft's copyrights. Wikipedia page about matter gives AFAIK fairly good and interesting summary about that mess. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._P._Lovecraft#Copyright)
  13. kkuja

    So.. what's the damage of a school desk?

    Or opposed to Discipline, or Athletics, or... what ever suits the situation. Otherwise I agree. But that's just how we roll.
  14. kkuja

    soak....really?

    I respectfully disagree here. I require more specifications to define the best RPG. For me, best urban horror RPG for me is SLA industries (I love the world but hate the system). Best scifi opera RPG is FFG SW. Best space fantasy horror is Dark Heresy. Best space horror RPG is Rogue Trader. Best rules light horror RPG is Cthulhu Dark. My favourite beer and bretzels RPG is Fiasco. Best general fantasy is Dungeon World. Best hard scifi RPG is Jovian Chronicles. Best general system (also for fast spaced pulp styled games) is Genesys (future will show whether it's the system I will default to in every game). Also, if I want a system which heavily simulates the game world I choose different system than if I want a system which heavily focuses on narrative. So what is the best RPG for me? If you can say easily what is the best RPG for you then great, more power to you! Unfortunately I cannot. I'm not saying other people cannot define best RPG more easily than I can, I'm only saying I cannot. Thank you and sorry.
  15. Sorry for necromancy. I was looking for tips how to not lose every game. IMO it's good that lone investigator gets 4 turn before midnight. Team size cannot be balanced so that it works well always. After all, currently player always get four actions between midnights, difference is just that does he/she get them with one or four investigators. In that point on view current system is balanced. Act once per investigator between midnights would just turn the situation to opposite. Full team would have larger benefit that solo investigator currently has (4 times the actions, and benefits for all investigators). Maybe only really balanced way would be single action for single investigator each day, but that would just be silly. There is also the beginner aspect. Game is currently really difficult for beginner players, in fact in my opinion too difficult (also, difficulty varies hugely between games). As solo investigator I win maybe every 10th game, against Yig. So, if player want's a bit easier game, solo games are good. Those who have mastered the game can increase difficulty by playing with full team, and by selecting non-optimal investigators. After all, it's FFG's benefit to make a game which can be played with satisfaction by larger group of people. What I'd like to have in this game is difficulty setting.
  16. kkuja

    soak....really?

    True. Sometimes the line between Strain and wound is unclear. That's not de facto bad thing, as is allows more flexibility guided by narrative. On the other hand, it may sometimes be a bit frustrating or strenuous as there are no hard and absolute guidelines. This is also a good point. This can be used as guideline what type of damage character should get. I.e. how long should recovery take.
  17. kkuja

    soak....really?

    In narrative I see Soak more as armor or clothes (or simply just body) partially absorbing the energy of attack so that target takes less actual damage. If defense dice give the failures and cause the attack to miss, then it's dodge. Of course this is all open to interpretation. "The enemy hits you with the sword, but the hit isn't perfect and your clothes and armor absord the most of the damage, and you only have a minor hit, taking 2 wounds." No. But it's my favourite. Being best would require there to be a universal criteria what kind of games are globally best. Different people and groups enjoy different games. Sometimes I like to play highly realistic and simulationistic games, in those times I choose different system than when I want to play pulpy fast paced narrative systems. Also, different system work with different styles. I probably wouldn't choose Genesys for highly lethal and gritty game. For that my choice would probably be the SilCORE. I love Genesys because it transfers narrative power, usually associated with GM, to players, empowering them. It also gives new kind of success experiences to players. SW and Genesys changed our games to more cooperative and less adversarial (e.g. GM vs. PCs). And it's fast. We played an 82 session SW campaign at the time it took to play last sixth of our Pathfinder campaign. But, we tend to dislike combats, and for us they are the more boring part of game. We find it more enjoyable to invent optional ways to bypass combats.
  18. kkuja

    Condition of Taris

    I'd like to change the view point a bit. At what condition it needs to be to optimally fit your campaign?
  19. kkuja

    "I'm out!" - Dealing with Ammo in Genesys

    AFAIK Requirement to reload is that you have extra ammunition. I.e. every encounter one uses a gun costs one extra reload. And point was that in survival setting any weapon only has ammo to a single encounter. Your need to extra reloads (or what ever they are called in that setting) rises dramatically from normal despair causes out of ammo effect. But I may have understood incorrectly.
  20. kkuja

    How to handle Languages?

    AFAIK reading was much less common in medieval times than speaking multiple languages was. What ever you end up with, I'd advice you to keep it simple. Genesys isn't supposed to be realistic simulation, and IMO it doesn't work very well in simulationistic games, because its focus is in fast spaced narrative gaming. AFAIK: Languages have been always affected by other languages. English has been hugely affected by French, German and latin, and less by greek and other languages. Especially in medieval times, languages were less defined by borders and were more regional thing. My native language, finnish, was affected by russian, swedish, norwegian, german, english and latin, and others. A thing to remember also is that more primitive the culture, smaller vocabulary is needed to survive. In modern world, if you learn a 1000 most common words in any language, you survive in most common tasks. Even 100 or less gives you good base to express your needs. You may not communicate eloquently, but you usually get your basic needs communicated. ("me hungry, need food" goes a long way. ) But, only you can know what works with your group. IMO don't hesitate to try something and change it if it doesn't work. There have been some good suggestions in this thread. If you want to simulate languages then have a language skill. But remember, Every language after first is harder to learn than those before it. And IMO that is realistic. In my experience, languages become easier to learn in basic level, more you learn them. I'd probably keep it somewhat abstract. I.e. have a language skill, and then when PCs encounter a person with no common language (if language is not in their already known list) they'd roll a language check, to see if know it. Currently I'm using languages as narrative device, and languages become issue only when I want it. So, PCs know needed languages unless it's a plot point. They are supposed to be the heroes after all.
  21. Rather than redesigning whole initiative system, I would probably allow that kind of exception to some very special occasions. E.g. if NPC, in their slot, is doing something which would be very bad for PCs, I might allow competitive check to disrupt the normal initiative order for a moment, i.e. allow PC to intercept the NPCs action using their next slot before it would normally happen.
  22. kkuja

    Magic Scrolls

    I would probably make scrolls spells with predefined effects. The effect more defined than in Genesys alternate magic rules. For example, Scroll named Fireball might contain arcane Attack, with blast, fire, and range effects. Or scrolls would be mechanically be more similar to weapons, and user might buy additional effects with advantages. And scrolls would be used with knowledge check, and difficulty would be predefined, and probably easier than actually casting of similar magic effect. And there would probably be no strain cost. So, I think scrolls might be more like conventional spells, and the actual magic system more open ended. But these are just fast thoughts about this matter, which may be totally worthless. But, there are no hard limits to what can be done. Every group can, and should, make a customizations which best suite them. Also, Palomarus' idea about scrolls not being one shot spells is interesting. And lead to another idea, where spells are one shot boosts to spells (e.g. boost die to attack spell, or even upgrade). Or scroll could for example give a free blast effect to arcane attacks spell. That is one good option. Another is to use those to customize scrolls (not saying a good option, just an option).
  23. kkuja

    Magic Scrolls

    I don't see this as huge problem. After all, you can take a photocopy of a iPad, but that copy is not iPad. Very much depends on how magic and scrolls are explained in setting. If magic scroll is just words in paper, then copy would be easy and scrolls common anyway. If magic is separated from the words in scroll, and the scroll is kind of avatar of the magic, then copying is not that simple. Maybe actually copying scroll requires the magic of the original scroll to triggered, so original is destroyed. If PC wants to copy (or create) a scroll, I'd allow that if they have the ability to create a scroll in first place. Having a scroll to copy would give a boost die to creating a new scroll. Other totally different, and setting dependent, thing is how hard scroll creation would in first place.
  24. kkuja

    Magic Scrolls

    I like this. I think the knowledge to use a scroll is thematically and otherwise good solution. That also allow non magical characters to use scrolls, as long as they have enough knowledge. Personally I wouldn't put any strain cost to using scrolls, because of those are used in scroll creation. As long as rarity and price make sure they are not too readily available. One option is also to have different kind of scrolls. Some scrolls might require e.g. full strain cost payment when cast, or some ingredient usage, or other such things, because they were not made properly, or are partially incomplete. Some scroll might work only with blood sacrifice, etc. The narrative options are limitless.
  25. kkuja

    Magic Scrolls

    Personally I think that scrolls have a spell stored into them. When scroll is used, magic is used. After that scroll is no more spell scroll. This is inline with normal convention that scroll is one time magic item. Probably in Genesys I'd make casting spells from scrolls easier than casting them normally. This also solves the problem with copying scroll. You can copy a scroll, but that doesn't copy the magic stored to scroll. I might do it so that casting spell from scroll allows user to cast a spell defined in scroll without the strain cost. After casting the scroll is destroyed. I might even make it so that spell is cast with knowledge skill instead of magic skill. Making scrolls would require a talent, and when making scroll character must cast the spell to scroll, which is kind of spell container. In that vein casting a spell from scroll should be easier than casting the actual spell. Maybe anyone who reads, can cast a spell from scroll. This is setting dependant thing. How powerful and common are scrolls in setting used? Maybe scrolls are meant for common people, and real magic users can cast much more powerful spells. Maybe scrolls are relics from more powerful past, and are better than what magic users can do themself. P.S. I love the idea about scrolls containing stuff which cannot be done with normal magic. Maybe magic scrolls are really powerful.
×