Maybe if they shut down the forums and push the game release back, everybody will forget how much they hate it. Or at least it's failure won't look like a big black mark when Asmodee tries to sell them.

Who cares?

Who cares?

Who cares?

Actually, scratch the above. I believe the best fix is to simply add one blank to the cup for 4-5 players or 2 blanks for 6 players. 

Ow I have embraced it already, by not going for this version* of descent en spend my money elsewhere ;). I’m glad this is something for you, i hope this will gives your money right.
a small note om your point of cost tho. With most big kickstarter projects you get a complete game to play for that amount of money. What could make it more expensive is de FOMO of the addons, which is great marketing. But most titels will give a sh*tload of campaignplay with just the base game and not just the first act...
and the fuzz.. well I guess you aim on all the individuel opinions of the game so far. Well I respect them, the pro and con people, including yours that will get the game. I personally would wait with preordering before I have seen some more gameplay. But thats me.
again, I hope this game will bring you the joy you experiencing now!
Ow and thanks for calling me a nag😘
 

actually its far more similar to descent 2e ed than mom 2 ed was to the first. legend of the dark function basically with the same mechanics. mansions of madness first ed used completely different game mechanics than the second edition. As for a descent 3rd edition, i seriously doubt there will be any

Most similarly priced Kickstarter boardgames offer far more content as a rule. As a veteran of both previous editions of descent , though i played the second edition far more than the first, i can tell you that the proposed iteration and its asking price comes as a serious disappointment. Even when they took mansions of madness in the second edition and turned it into a full coop app driven experience, they at least had the good sense to make as much of the first edition material as they could usable in the second. we dont even that that little smidgen here  

That probably explains your opinion more than the rest of your post. The vast majority of people talking about this game come from a background having played Descent 1st and/or 2nd editions.  You don't have any basis for comparison because you haven't played the previous Descent(s), and thus the 'fuzz' over Legends of the Dark doesnt make sense to you. Honestly, you are probably their target audience now.
 

Progress just for the sake of progress is never good. They had an amazing story, theme and game engine at their disposal and decided to literally threw it all away to make something bloated and over priced with what unfortunately can only be seen as distorted horrible game art compared to the standard.
There was a natural progression here, from Descent 1 to 2 then Imperial Assault. The next step building on all of that would have been fantastic. Instead we got this mess.

I may still be deluding myself that another campaign for the app will show up at some point.

Hey all, innsmouth is one of my favourite settings in Lovecraft, but I’m a bit concerned about possible bloat with the latest expansion. 
when FFG put out the sub-par at best Masks of Nyarly expansion for Eldritch Horror, the cards and bits of the game reached the tipping point for me. 
Now with the bless/curse mechanic, I’m concerned the same thing is happening with the LCG and hoping you can allay my fears. 
Having more bits is one thing, but having investigators whose abilities require you to use those bits (eg Sister Mary) is another. Means if you don’t want to use bless/curse, no sister Mary. Or other player cards that play with bless/curse, so the expansion becomes less appealing even though I like getting new investigators and like the setting.
how has bless/curse been to play with? I’m assuming it’s here to stay from now on, so future expansions will also have it. Wondering if this is my exit...

$150 CAD for this is still too expensive in my opinion. 

175 $ is what you pay for KS games with 2-3 times the content shown here and with far more replayability than a measly 16 quest one and done campaign.

I literally bought jaws of the lion 2 days after the descent announcement and i LOVE it and am so glad I got into it and I have this descent preview that I'm not interested in to thank lol.

I'm a huge fan of Descent (I own all 1st and 2nd edition expansions)... The 3D scenario tiles are intriguing, the minis look cool, I don't mind the app support (if done well, it can add a lot of value to the game), but the 175$ starting price feels too high... I hope you get a lot of content with that.
It would be nice to know their full plans for the game. If the 175$ box includes a lot of stuff and scenarios and no need to buy expansions to get a varied and rich experience, then it may be worth it... This is one I'll add to my watchlist, but I'm a bit disappointed by such a high price.

And "normal" Gloomhaven more than 90 scenarios for 120$

16 quests. $175. Sorry, this is a hard pass. Gloomhaven Jaws of the Lion is 25 scenarios for $50. Miniatures are cool and all but... yikes that’s a big ask for what is basically a third attempt to make Descent relevant. 

To build up to crushing our hopes, again?  You really need to have emotional fortitude to be a fan of Imperial Assault.
 

https://imgur.com/a/wXEkI2T?fbclid=IwAR3mvGviZe8Tkr9Z5Vmi-jcBRVkJjd3X-qamwwBhioydOWmWjLeQLb4iaig

I like it! The cards' wording needs a little tweaking IMO, but if you want I could help you out with that.

https://imgur.com/a/E3z1oo8

There are two things that come to mind for me which FFG hasn't done with this game yet but which could really spice things up and give new life to old cards.
Create a saga-like mechanic tying together all 9 quests for each expansion, with boons, burdens, treasures, and so on to add an RPG-like element to the game. This has been discussed many times in the past, and would have a lot of player appeal. It's also highly modular, allowing players to dip in however much or for whichever cycle they want. This would also be an opportunity to "fix" older quests (like many in the Shadows of Mirkwood and Khazad-dum expansions), as some of the Nightmare scenarios have done. This would be easily doable with a standalone expansion pack for each cycle. Standalone or in combination with #1, it would be very interesting if FFG created unique challenges that combined novel quests with interesting deck-building or even gameplay restrictions or rules changes. There are many, many examples of custom fan-made challenges, and it would be cool if FFG were to bring all if its design and develop resources to bear on this idea. A while back they issued a Designer's Challenge, "Three is Company", which could be a model. That challenge received pretty favorable reviews, if I recall correctly, but FFG never did another one.

I mean, you are technically correct, but I wouldn't mind an actual campain in app, for HotE

After shutting down the awesome mode in TTS, this is both insulting and pathetic. 
Well done ffg!