Ok, that was a long read, though not as long as it perhaps should have been, and as to both I did it to myself. I did a first pass and flagged everything that caught my eye. I dont know the new cats yet, so if I misinterpret something, its not personal.
First red flag, why are you concerned with town roles at all? Town roles will be revealed as we go, by the players who have them, as their role provides relevant information. That you also mention scum roles could either be legitmate guesswork as to both or merely attempting to project that image.
And thats a lazy follow. The “analysis” in question was simply a prod. Two early red flags Rewen.
Merely casting a vote isnt really looking to lynch aithout cause. Especially early, voting is the most useful tool in the town toolbox to pressure and hopefully force a scumslip.
It was quiet, but there were some things.
Like this, here. This is a common fallacy among newer players. I also believed it, once upon a time. After all, better not to kill a fellow townie right? But then we sacrifice valuable information.
Based on the timing (very close to end d1, trying to push a lynch) I’ll give these passes. But wow, really insightful stuff with these.
Same as above.
Good, shades of town. Call to action, making a push, providing reasoning.
I read this and assumed LP gave them a lowdown on some of us regulars. The scumchat theory was interesting.
The Green rep gets discussed a bit, it just means I played a lot of Armada and was a vocal member of the community.
1. I mean, it was definetely insinuated that he was in a scum chat. Him addressing it is to be expected.
2. The rep thing is immaterial, you know that. What were you looking for him to say in response.
3. Is this it?
4. Spoiler: Its Ebon.
This is interesting, but impossible for me corroborate. I’d love for some of the crew who know more to comment about it.
I haven’t been playing my typical game. I haven’t been playing at all. Which is its own problem, but why would you say this was typical?
Flagged to remind me to re-read pods game.
This leads to a sequence of posts that very much concern me. Clon says he didn’t get any gift from Pod, which lead to this post, where Pod believes he was roleblocked.
Why would this matter it he was roleblocked? Fishing? (This clears up later)
I’d say I wasnt random, I deserve a push.
Have to verify. For the new crew, Ebon’s description of Pods typical play as town is accurate.
Why? This is the biggest red flag. Clon is now admitting to lying to us. That runs afoul of the lynch all liars protocol. That he wasnt caught in it, but simply admits to it, is the only mitigating circumstance on his side.
Why? Cuz they say so? The only thing I know for sure about Clon is that he’s lied.
No, see above.
Not doing a great job of it.
I mean, sure. I hadn’t participated at an svveptable level, fair.
It tells me someone in the new crew is scum, but so does basic probability.
At the moment, I’m most concerned with Clon, because Lynch all liars. Why lie in that situation?