Jump to content

MacchuWA

Members
  • Content Count

    536
  • Joined

  • Last visited


Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from Bucknife in Obi-Wan Kenobi, Rebel Crew. It's Time, FFG.   
    I love the tractor mechanic, but he needs to do more, or he risks being useless if your opponent doesn't bring tractor tokens. Something like this would let him be built around:
     
    Obi Wan Kenobi
    3 force, non regenerating.
    Setup: Equip this side faceup.
    At the begining of the engagement phase, you may spend 1 force to remove one tractor token from a ship at range 0-2.
    If you have one or fewer force tokens, you may flip this card.
    Obi Wan Kenobi (Force Ghost)
    When friendly ships at Range 0-2 perform a special attack, they may treat the Attack (Target Lock) restriction as Attack (Focus)
     
    Maybe 10-12 points, a little cheaper than Chancellor Palpatine?
  2. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from Odanan in Obi-Wan Kenobi, Rebel Crew. It's Time, FFG.   
    I love the tractor mechanic, but he needs to do more, or he risks being useless if your opponent doesn't bring tractor tokens. Something like this would let him be built around:
     
    Obi Wan Kenobi
    3 force, non regenerating.
    Setup: Equip this side faceup.
    At the begining of the engagement phase, you may spend 1 force to remove one tractor token from a ship at range 0-2.
    If you have one or fewer force tokens, you may flip this card.
    Obi Wan Kenobi (Force Ghost)
    When friendly ships at Range 0-2 perform a special attack, they may treat the Attack (Target Lock) restriction as Attack (Focus)
     
    Maybe 10-12 points, a little cheaper than Chancellor Palpatine?
  3. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from nitrobenz in Obi-Wan Kenobi, Rebel Crew. It's Time, FFG.   
    I love the tractor mechanic, but he needs to do more, or he risks being useless if your opponent doesn't bring tractor tokens. Something like this would let him be built around:
     
    Obi Wan Kenobi
    3 force, non regenerating.
    Setup: Equip this side faceup.
    At the begining of the engagement phase, you may spend 1 force to remove one tractor token from a ship at range 0-2.
    If you have one or fewer force tokens, you may flip this card.
    Obi Wan Kenobi (Force Ghost)
    When friendly ships at Range 0-2 perform a special attack, they may treat the Attack (Target Lock) restriction as Attack (Focus)
     
    Maybe 10-12 points, a little cheaper than Chancellor Palpatine?
  4. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from CoffeeMinion in Obi-Wan Kenobi, Rebel Crew. It's Time, FFG.   
    I love the tractor mechanic, but he needs to do more, or he risks being useless if your opponent doesn't bring tractor tokens. Something like this would let him be built around:
     
    Obi Wan Kenobi
    3 force, non regenerating.
    Setup: Equip this side faceup.
    At the begining of the engagement phase, you may spend 1 force to remove one tractor token from a ship at range 0-2.
    If you have one or fewer force tokens, you may flip this card.
    Obi Wan Kenobi (Force Ghost)
    When friendly ships at Range 0-2 perform a special attack, they may treat the Attack (Target Lock) restriction as Attack (Focus)
     
    Maybe 10-12 points, a little cheaper than Chancellor Palpatine?
  5. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from dsul413 in I’m Pretty Sure those are Imperial Class Star Destroyers   
    The first trailer shows an Imperial 1, the second gave us a better look and showed that those same Imperial 1s were modified with big underslung guns. This is probably them.
  6. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from admat in Figuring out Ric   
    It is. I've found it very useful - you dial in that three speed manoeuvre which may or may not fit, wait for the lower initiative pilots to move, then decide: if you fit, great. If not, you can choose whether the extra dice are more useful than getting your action/evade (assuming your opponent moved slowly).
    Cost is the only major issue I have: my list is bang on 200 points, but that's largely because I insist on flying 4 N1s. 🙂
  7. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from Odanan in First Order ships (includes TROS spoilers)   
    I'm quite disappointed with the First Order designs that actually look to be making it into the movies vs the concept art. It feels like everything that they have actually put on screen has either been ugly (Dagger, Xi, Echelon) or incredibly derivative (TIE f/o,  s/f, both those interceptor designs etc.). The only really interesting, unique design they can claim is the Upsilon, and maybe the Silencer. Resistance is hardly any better, with only the bombers being anything close to unique.
     
    Just generally feels like a massive missed opportunity.
  8. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from wildcrdj in Is X-Wing headed for a +25% price increase?   
    As a resident of neither of those countries, I'm happy enough having them manufactured wherever the price/quality equation is optimised. If that's China, so be it.
  9. Like
    MacchuWA reacted to JJ48 in Are You Team Nerf ? or Team Puzzle?   
    When faced with opposing viewpoints, do you correctly try to understand the other side and have a real discussion, or do you ask biased questions to paint your side as superior?
  10. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from Tlfj200 in XXX XXX XXX XXX O   
    It's a semantic point. People can, and frequently do, feel upset on the basis of incorrect understanding or unreasonable expectations; I'm sure we can all point to examples from the political discourses of our various countries.
    In this case, the people complaining about the cost of the upgrade are labouring under false assumptions or misguided comparisons. X Wing had reached a point competitively where it needed major surgery, which required the devs to build and test a whole new game system, as well as the upgrades and pilots for dozens of existing ships. That time and effort cost money which has to be recouped. The only other options were do nothing (i.e. incur no new costs, requiring no new revenue), and watch the game spiral further and further out of control, or keep releasing new fix packs, which players would have bought at an eventually comparable cost to the conversion kits.
    You can be upset. But that doesnt mean you're not demonstrably wrong.
  11. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from Tlfj200 in XXX XXX XXX XXX O   
    But what if they actually are stupid and/or wrong?
  12. Thanks
    MacchuWA got a reaction from Turcopolier in Other "Sci-fi" shows, you;d love to see get the X-wing treatment?   
    Not a TV series, but the Freespace series of games. It nearly happened via Kickstarter, but they didn't have the money in the end, which suggest a it probably wouldn't be popular enough to be viable as an actual game. But it'd be great - three species, plenty of fighters for each one, different missiles and primary weapons for upgrade cards, plenty of ways to differentiate ships (stats and dials like X Wing, but also weapons compatibility, arc width and secondary capacity). 
    I'd do it on a sliding scale, so you could put fighters on small bases, bombers on a medium bases, cruisers and corvettes on large bases and bigger capships on epic bases. Add in mechanisms for ETS, countermeasures, afterburners, better secondary integration, and capships with a full weapons suite, and you'd have a potentially complicated, but awesome, game.
    One downside would be a lack of characters for put cards, but if it were built with that in mind, it would be fine. You could use squadrons instead - on the right kind of ship, you assign a squadron card that gives it special abilities. So, you could have your first ship, and as long as it's a Hercules, Hercules Mk 2 or Ares class, you could assign it the 107th Ravens squadron. And the more Ravens you have in your squad, the better their abilities.
    One thing that would be better even than Star Wars would be the potential for time (and tech) to meaningfully move forward, rather than be essentially stagnant as it is in the SW universe. Power creep would happen, but that would be thematic as tech got better, and if it was designed properly from day 1, you could release ships in order and make the creep systematic.
     
    Maybe this was a bad idea. I'm finding myself pining for a game that'll never get made.
  13. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from mazz0 in What factions are you most excited to play in 2.0?   
    Galactic Republic!
     

  14. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from nitrobenz in Whisper/Kylo “Updated Version”   
    You reckon? Nym is shooting before Whisper cloaks - rolling three hits (which isn't exactly uncommon with a TLT) is a guaranteed damage in an uncloaked Whisper. You could keep her cloaked and hope Kylo kills Nym, or rely on an evade token and hope you never roll a blank evade die, but it's not something I'd be comfortable with in this meta, personally.
  15. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from Odanan in Solo movie talk (No spoilers)   
    I mean, not to drag this thread too deep into the political mud, but the droid was played by a very white, very British woman.

    I think you might have been seeing things that weren't neccesarily there from the creators' side.
     
  16. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from tsondaboy in Solo movie talk (No spoilers)   
    It's 3:30 AM, so this will be quick. But:
     It doesn't suck! As someone who truly disliked TLJ and really liked Rogue One, Solo is solid. 7/10 for me. Good Star Wars feel, bit of a weak first act, Donald Glover is great, Alden Erenreich grows on you. Chewie is cool. There are some very nice nods to the old movies, the old EU (though one of these in particular felt a little shoehorned in) and the Filoni TV series' (first one it's a little bit of fun, and I'll say nothing beyond that). 
    If you're on the fence, go see it. It's un, and you'll leave happy.
    For X Wing though, there's basically nothing more than what we see in the trailers. The AT Hauler can deifnitely go into space. Neither the Falcon's pod nor the new TIE plays a substantial role, and if there were any other new ships they weren't prominent.
    Now, bedtime.
  17. Haha
    MacchuWA reacted to FTS Gecko in Solo: A Star Wars Story [SPOILER THREAD]   
    I think that was an autocorrect error.  It should have said "whining".
  18. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from CoffeeMinion in Solo movie talk (No spoilers)   
    No idea about smoking before or after. If you mean runtime, we were in the cinema until about 2:40 AM, but that included ads and trailers for about 20 minutes.
     
    Much less jokey than TLJ, they don't do the thing where they undercut dramatic moments with a joke. Phoebe Waller Bridge's L3 gets a few comedic lines, but they kind of work in context. Han and Chewie have a couple of funny moments too. Never over the top though.
  19. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from Norym in Solo movie talk (No spoilers)   
    It's 3:30 AM, so this will be quick. But:
     It doesn't suck! As someone who truly disliked TLJ and really liked Rogue One, Solo is solid. 7/10 for me. Good Star Wars feel, bit of a weak first act, Donald Glover is great, Alden Erenreich grows on you. Chewie is cool. There are some very nice nods to the old movies, the old EU (though one of these in particular felt a little shoehorned in) and the Filoni TV series' (first one it's a little bit of fun, and I'll say nothing beyond that). 
    If you're on the fence, go see it. It's un, and you'll leave happy.
    For X Wing though, there's basically nothing more than what we see in the trailers. The AT Hauler can deifnitely go into space. Neither the Falcon's pod nor the new TIE plays a substantial role, and if there were any other new ships they weren't prominent.
    Now, bedtime.
  20. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from TheHumanHydra in Solo movie talk (No spoilers)   
    It's 3:30 AM, so this will be quick. But:
     It doesn't suck! As someone who truly disliked TLJ and really liked Rogue One, Solo is solid. 7/10 for me. Good Star Wars feel, bit of a weak first act, Donald Glover is great, Alden Erenreich grows on you. Chewie is cool. There are some very nice nods to the old movies, the old EU (though one of these in particular felt a little shoehorned in) and the Filoni TV series' (first one it's a little bit of fun, and I'll say nothing beyond that). 
    If you're on the fence, go see it. It's un, and you'll leave happy.
    For X Wing though, there's basically nothing more than what we see in the trailers. The AT Hauler can deifnitely go into space. Neither the Falcon's pod nor the new TIE plays a substantial role, and if there were any other new ships they weren't prominent.
    Now, bedtime.
  21. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from D.Erasmus in Solo movie talk (No spoilers)   
    It's 3:30 AM, so this will be quick. But:
     It doesn't suck! As someone who truly disliked TLJ and really liked Rogue One, Solo is solid. 7/10 for me. Good Star Wars feel, bit of a weak first act, Donald Glover is great, Alden Erenreich grows on you. Chewie is cool. There are some very nice nods to the old movies, the old EU (though one of these in particular felt a little shoehorned in) and the Filoni TV series' (first one it's a little bit of fun, and I'll say nothing beyond that). 
    If you're on the fence, go see it. It's un, and you'll leave happy.
    For X Wing though, there's basically nothing more than what we see in the trailers. The AT Hauler can deifnitely go into space. Neither the Falcon's pod nor the new TIE plays a substantial role, and if there were any other new ships they weren't prominent.
    Now, bedtime.
  22. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from Green Doo in Solo movie talk (No spoilers)   
    It's 3:30 AM, so this will be quick. But:
     It doesn't suck! As someone who truly disliked TLJ and really liked Rogue One, Solo is solid. 7/10 for me. Good Star Wars feel, bit of a weak first act, Donald Glover is great, Alden Erenreich grows on you. Chewie is cool. There are some very nice nods to the old movies, the old EU (though one of these in particular felt a little shoehorned in) and the Filoni TV series' (first one it's a little bit of fun, and I'll say nothing beyond that). 
    If you're on the fence, go see it. It's un, and you'll leave happy.
    For X Wing though, there's basically nothing more than what we see in the trailers. The AT Hauler can deifnitely go into space. Neither the Falcon's pod nor the new TIE plays a substantial role, and if there were any other new ships they weren't prominent.
    Now, bedtime.
  23. Thanks
    MacchuWA got a reaction from Commander Kaine in Solo movie talk (No spoilers)   
    No idea about smoking before or after. If you mean runtime, we were in the cinema until about 2:40 AM, but that included ads and trailers for about 20 minutes.
     
    Much less jokey than TLJ, they don't do the thing where they undercut dramatic moments with a joke. Phoebe Waller Bridge's L3 gets a few comedic lines, but they kind of work in context. Han and Chewie have a couple of funny moments too. Never over the top though.
  24. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from Xendrick in Solo movie talk (No spoilers)   
    It's 3:30 AM, so this will be quick. But:
     It doesn't suck! As someone who truly disliked TLJ and really liked Rogue One, Solo is solid. 7/10 for me. Good Star Wars feel, bit of a weak first act, Donald Glover is great, Alden Erenreich grows on you. Chewie is cool. There are some very nice nods to the old movies, the old EU (though one of these in particular felt a little shoehorned in) and the Filoni TV series' (first one it's a little bit of fun, and I'll say nothing beyond that). 
    If you're on the fence, go see it. It's un, and you'll leave happy.
    For X Wing though, there's basically nothing more than what we see in the trailers. The AT Hauler can deifnitely go into space. Neither the Falcon's pod nor the new TIE plays a substantial role, and if there were any other new ships they weren't prominent.
    Now, bedtime.
  25. Like
    MacchuWA got a reaction from FTS Gecko in Solo movie talk (No spoilers)   
    It's 3:30 AM, so this will be quick. But:
     It doesn't suck! As someone who truly disliked TLJ and really liked Rogue One, Solo is solid. 7/10 for me. Good Star Wars feel, bit of a weak first act, Donald Glover is great, Alden Erenreich grows on you. Chewie is cool. There are some very nice nods to the old movies, the old EU (though one of these in particular felt a little shoehorned in) and the Filoni TV series' (first one it's a little bit of fun, and I'll say nothing beyond that). 
    If you're on the fence, go see it. It's un, and you'll leave happy.
    For X Wing though, there's basically nothing more than what we see in the trailers. The AT Hauler can deifnitely go into space. Neither the Falcon's pod nor the new TIE plays a substantial role, and if there were any other new ships they weren't prominent.
    Now, bedtime.
×
×
  • Create New...