I have played in PLENTY of tournament games (in other game systems granted), and believe me...I've been graded down on "sportsman ship" more than once because I committed the gravest sin in my opponents eyes
I beat them
completely fair, no rules lawyering, no iffy game play.......I simply WON, when obviously (to them) that it shouldnt have happened, so since they cant nix my game score....they lower my sportsman ship score in order to "get even"
we have a name for those players....I just cant type it here without getting in trouble
all that aside, Im not a poor sport for not letting you fix a mistake automatically. a LOT of whether or not I allowed it? is based on your sportsmanship
be a jerk to me? I'll find a way to repay you...trust me I have a long memory....but play fair and be a good sport? I can return that just as easily
I worked for a law office in real life....rules lawyers annoy me, and the ones that somehow think they are special and deserve to get everything their way? annoy me worse
so...since its likely I will be called a poor sport either way? Im going to PURPOSELY pick the one that messes up your day as well
Im a vindictive old man that way...you, me and the TO will spend the next hour + arguing the rules until you get sick and tired and leave/give in or they throw me out...along with the rest of my game club, cause they will walk to
ask any TO about loosing 12 ppl from your tourney
so...be a poor sport to me and try to ram your "short cuts" down my throat, and we will blow the entire tourney up...OR act like someone with a bit of maturity and we will "fly casual" all day and enjoy the game...win or lose
your choice, not mine
as for the skill level of the other player determining whther or not I allow a redo/fix?
go to YouTube and watch the national championship round where the x-wing flies into an asteroid losing him the game
even skilled players make mistakes, at least he had the class to accept that he messed up instead of whining about it