Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by bradknowles

  1. On the one hand, I do think that auto-fire is not properly balanced for the rest of this game. On the other hand, I don’t think that it is the most OP thing in the game. Moreover, I believe that there are ways that the GM can moderate how bad auto-fire can be, especially when the players understand that anything the PCs can do could also be done by NPCs. So, if they don’t want to have the entire party wiped out by a Terminator firing a mini-gun from a building at them, then maybe they might want to hold back a bit on going down that road themselves.
  2. The adventures should be tailored to each PC, yes. But I believe that the F&D CRB and GM Kit have much more to say on this subject, and I don’t know that I can really add much of anything beyond telling you that I think they are vital to making this process a success.
  3. Do you have any idea how hard it is to spot even Star Destroyer size ships at any kind of distance? Do we need to dig up the old quote about how mind-bogglingly big space is?
  4. If I had to guess, I would say that they probably underestimated the number of people who would buy so many copies and then try to flip them. They may have also run into printing and/or distribution problems. But you’re definitely not the only one to have such problems. ;(
  5. If I do decide to take advantage of this service, it would only be with my spare copies of books. I wouldn’t want to risk my sole copy of anything, at least not until I see how the whole process works and I get my books back.
  6. Aren’t Jawas in the Unofficial Species Menagerie? If not, then I wouldn’t necessarily have a problem with someone proposing some reasonable rules for them. Either way, I think the key is they need to give me a good role-playing reason why their Jawa would be off adventuring instead of at home. Give me a good narrative, and a reasonable proposal based on that narrative, and I’m much more likely to be receptive. But maybe that’s just me?
  7. Hmm. That is quite tempting! I might decide to give them a try….
  8. Depends on your GM, and how he feels about the standard “Carbine Rule”. And whether or not you are playing a four-armed species.
  9. On the one hand, it seems cool to let the PCs resolve the situation this way. This time. But next time, the driver might be better equipped for Social Combat, and when you yell “Stop, Thief!” he’s just going to laugh his @$$ off at you as he scoots away into the crowd.
  10. Just keep in mind that most of these things are bloody obvious when your ship is parked, and would be considered outright illegal on most semi-civilized worlds. You don’t want to be docking your expensive Nightshadow-equipped ship anywhere remotely close to a place where the authorities could come around with a Star Destroyer or three and ask what you’re doing there.
  11. So, I wanted to point out a somewhat alternative concept — pick a race that isn’t necessarily well known for their Agility, but would thematically work well otherwise. My Besalisk Hired Gun:Heavy/Ace:Gunner is going to be going into Gunslinger soon, but I would have done a pure Gunslinger version if the group I was playing in didn’t do a lot of ship-to-ship combat. Four Weapon Combat? Okay, that’ll take some GM house rules. But the OK-98 Carbine, with appropriate mods? That’s the best blaster pistol I’ve seen, if you’re using it in pistol mode — does damage right up there with Blaster Rifles, but in a Carbine. Four of them? Yowch! Please understand, Heavy with autofire weapons would be able to do so much more damage, but would be so much less fun to roleplay.
  12. You’re not dodging a laser beam, you’re dodging their aim. Same principle works with arrows, guns, etc…. The difference with lasers in the real world is that you get much faster feedback on when you’re on target, and therefore you can correct your aim a lot faster. Same with projectile weapons with high rates of fire and tracer rounds.
  13. Roll enough Triumphs, and anything is possible.
  14. Yeah, but the armor has to be powered for that to happen. So, it’s power armor or Power Armor, one way or the other.
  15. Have you seen the size of this thing? Witness: Do you know of any lightsaber in existence that can take a softball-size gem and use that as a lightsaber crystal?
  16. You don’t get much in the way of environmental effects that give setback dice to a gunner onboard a ship. Most of the setback dice you get are either due to Shields on the target, doing called shots, or issues with your systems or your crew. IMO, none of that would qualify as “environmental”. Setbacks due to flying through an Asteroid field, or due to performing high-g maneuvers, those are something that I would consider to be environmental, and could be reduced or eliminated by the “Brace” talent. And called shots apparently no longer do any damage to the Hull Threshold or System Strain Threshold of the target — they only do Critical Hits, which can be quickly fixed by mechanics. So far as I can tell, the “Call ‘Em” talent appears only in the “Gunslinger” tree. But it should be equally applicable to all other types of weapons and specs.
  17. The problem is that the spec is supposed to be the “Ace” of “Gunners”, and therefore probably the second most important role on a ship. And it’s just not that useful in that position. Sure, it has two ranks of True Aim, but so do at least a couple of other specs — and Sharpshooter can get to those ranks of True Aim much easier/faster. And Sharpshooter also gets the Sharpshooter talent, which Ace:Gunner doesn’t get. “Overwhelm Defenses” and “Debilitating Shot” are the only other two Gunner-specific talents provided, and neither of them are all that great. There’s no talent to remove setback, and you don’t get “Lethal Blows” or “Deadly Accuracy”, either.
  18. Unfortunately, Operator is even more lame than Ace:Gunner. I looked at it closely, to see how well it might stack on top of Ace:Gunner, and I just didn’t see enough there to make it worthwhile.
  19. You can get those on eBay. That’s assuming you trust the sellers on eBay to be actually selling you real copies of real books, and not just half-empty broken boxes. For me, it’s not so much the cost. It’s more the thought of doing something like that to books. It just seems like it should be a serious crime, with automatic jail time and everything.
  20. If I had the money, I wouldn’t mind buying second copies of a number of books, then carefully slicing up the ones that aren’t in such good shape and scanning them in. But then you have to OCR the text, and even now OCR isn’t all that good. Of course, after scanning I would take all the loose pages and put them into page covers, so that I could put multiple books together into a single binder. Man, I wish they had e-book or PDF versions we could buy. I’d be more than happy to buy a second copy of each, just to have good clean copies that were made to be electronic (and searchable) from the beginning.
  21. He was connecting wirelessly to his own systems in Cloud City, the ones that he had helped build and maintain. And he did it with his own proprietary wireless algorithms that he had developed. I guess you could try to jam him if you knew what the frequencies were, or you could try to reverse-engineer the protocols, if you were smart enough. But I don’t recall him ever using any of those wireless capabilities to slice anyone else.
  22. Which totally negates the “Debilitating Shot” talent in Ace:Gunner. Ace:Gunner is weak enough as it is, it doesn’t need to be made more useless by house rules.
  23. I’m sure that works fine for Yoga materials, but if you’ve got two or three shelves worth of gaming books that you’re trying to lug around, that’s not going to work so well. You need something that is more book-friendly.
  24. So, as a player I have a number of characters that I’ve run that I have really enjoyed. But as GM, I can’t recall any that I especially liked. I mean, all the PCs that my players ran were fine and well-played, but I don’t recall any of them being especially favorites of mine. And there were a few NPCs that I had which I liked, but that game didn’t last that long, and I didn’t get to use those NPCs that much.
  • Create New...