Jump to content

muribundi

Members
  • Content Count

    769
  • Joined

  • Last visited

About muribundi

  • Rank
    Member
  • Birthday

Recent Profile Visitors

537 profile views
  1. muribundi

    Unofficial ruling Doc.

    It is not a question of knowing best. There is rule problem that we need ruling during tournament. And it will do 6 months ffg say nothing, so someone need to take the lead
  2. muribundi

    Unofficial ruling Doc.

    mmm still no Qi'Ra
  3. And you still fail to say how you fix the situation without the rule
  4. Yes that is the funny thing. He does not say what he is doing with cocked dice. Because they are no different then dice dropped on the floor. What you do, take the result you deem the most "probable" because again, the rules do not say to do that. And a cocked dice could have rolled for a bit more time, and most cocked dice are not that clear cut far from it. So what you do when this happen OP ?
  5. Yes it was, we were rerolling cocked dice before they made it official. And there is no official rule that you must reroll dice that fall off the table, so I suppose you don't reroll them and get the final result from the floor. By the way there is no rule about how to roll dice. So everyone should try to let them fall from a inch height and try them not turning so you get the result you want
  6. Or if they decide to give Bomber a system slot... or many other thing that could happen.
  7. muribundi

    Talon Roll Ruling required, FFG

    And Can Qi'ra shoot on a locked rock Can Rhymer shoot at range 0 Seriously, I'm baffled that there is still no new RR after what 6 months and a new wave?!? It is that long to just decide what to do with these ruling?!?
  8. muribundi

    Talon Roll Ruling required, FFG

    And Can Qi'ra shoot on a locked rock Can Rhymer shoot at range 0
  9. And here we finally have a device that can be launched according to its own rule. Closing the case, Deathfire was future proofed just in case. Sure Deathfire can't use them for now, but this is the perfect example that there will be device that are meant to be drop or launch: https://www.fantasyflightgames.com/en/news/2019/2/25/a-phantom-menace/?fbclid=IwAR2ylymp9rxo5KMmLw54tC3D6wx__JbaUB7Vp5z3jGGeUecMXcIrqAItAwE So Deathfire can't launch Proton Bomb because they can't normally be launch, end of story.
  10. muribundi

    Landing NEXT to an obstacle?

    In fact in a perfect 2d world you could clearly end up touching and not overlapping. In 2d games, you could clearly end up with each ship corner being exactly the pixel next to each other, with no "pixel" in between, you would then be seen as touching. And in the real world, then you will never be touching, because even when you place ship so they seems to be touching, their material molecules are probably still far from touching each other. And then we get back to the definition of the first edition that was causing confusion...
  11. muribundi

    Resistance vs. Rebel yt-1300

    And the point is, yes according to the letter of the rules, a judge could reject the "wrong" model being used for the falcon. But again by this same letter of the rules, there is absolutely nothing that say the square radar is for the resistance faction. Except if you know the lore... and use the card artistic representation that show the rectangular radar. I would not call that a clear cut reference for a judge to reject a model
  12. muribundi

    Resistance vs. Rebel yt-1300

    Still not a rules, there is no rules that say that the TIE Advance model must be used for TIE Advance x1 and that the TIE Advance Prototype model must be used for the TIE Advance v1. Only Common knowledge or looking at the small icon... Yes I know that these are seen as "granted" by everyone. But still there is no way to know which falcon go with which except if your a fan of start wars. The icon show the same ship...
  13. muribundi

    Resistance vs. Rebel yt-1300

    Still not a rules, still common knowledge and assumption Previously it was TIE Advance and TIE Advance Prototype Now it is TIE Advance x1 and TIE Advance v1. Which rules state which one are what
  14. muribundi

    Resistance vs. Rebel yt-1300

    It is not a rule, it is "common" knowledge and assumption. A new player would still have absolutely not way to know that. This is a clear omission in the rules, or contrary to what everyone imply here, they just don't care as long as it is clear what you run.
  15. muribundi

    Resistance vs. Rebel yt-1300

    No I'm not, I'm not saying they are interchangeable, but it is a legitimate concerne, there is no rule about which model go with which ship. How is a total new player supposed to know which falcon go with which ?
×