Re: Mandy Thompson's Personal Story in Arkham Horror Second Edition Posted April 7, 2015 Julia, I also thought this may be the case. But it was one of those situations where I wondered if the original card design was limited by a lack of foresight regarding added mechanics included in later expansions. Thanks for your two cents. I will probably lean toward that result should I encounter this again (looks like Tibs and another also back your thoughts so we will call it consensus.) One further question: Was it ever established whether or not Mandy receives the gate trophy from the closed/sealed gate? I can't remember, but I though there was some strange wording that suggests that trophies are always collected unless it is said specifically that they are NOT collected. And finally... the forum spam that is occuring right now is ridiculous. there are now 20-ish pages of spam threads. Did anyone contact a mod about them yet?