Jump to content

Nicola Zealey

Members
  • Content Count

    16
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Nicola Zealey


  1. The annoying thing is next time you play if the text is about a dead husband the killer will be the same and so you will immediately know who the killer is!

    The killer is randomly selected from one of five but even so this becomes annoying if your group plays the scenario multiple times or plays a few times and is unlucky with who the killer is.

    What would be better would be to have the scenario so that the suspect who has a dead husband can vary.

    That would have made the scenario a lot more re-playable because you would, then, need to check the other clues even when the same clue appears.

     


  2. The key to solving the mystery is de-coding a key item.

    You should be able to guess what this key item is.

    As long as you've talked to the suspects (and done some searching) you should be able to deduce who the killer from the text.

    The following examples are made up in order not to spoil the mystery but should set you along the right path:

    •    If the text mentions say taking cows to be milked, the critical question is who might do such a thing.
    •    If the text mentions say a brother is involved, the critical question is who has mentioned a brother.
    •    If the text mentions say a dog owner, the critical question is who owns a dog.
    •    If the text mentions say a cook's apron, the critical question is who might own such an item.

    You may guess (from my made-up examples) Vengeful Impulses is not my favourite murder mystery scenario.

     


  3. Players who don't 'get' Mansions tend to regard every scenario as a simple random dice fest.

    They search every token in every room and either get overwhelmed or win by sheer luck.

    The way to consistently win is to regard the game as a race to find the critical clues.

    Don't skim read the text.  We all tend to do this... including myself.

    FFG's scenario writing style is unfortunately very verbose and key information is often obscured by tons and tons and tons and tons of flavour text.

    Use every action carefully.   Often you don't have a lot of actions to spare before really bad things happen.

    Follow the breadcrumb trail of clues as quickly as possible.

    Support other investigators - you only need to lose one to lose the game.

    Don't forget about the special actions an investigator can use - especially to help other investigators.

    Use the little known 'Push' action to move an investigator with a key item an extra space.

    Use the 'Trade' action to pass on a key item like a baton in a relay race.

    All players can help to solve a puzzle.  Solving a puzzle using teamwork helps to keep everyone involved and makes solving them less of a chore.

     

     

     

     


  4. 7 hours ago, Vortid said:

    This is really fantastic, thanks for all the work.

    One problem for me is that I have all these nice minis that I have painted, but then only used once, or even none with some of the bigger ones because the scenario never went that way when I played it...so ways to offer more replayability with existing parts of the game is just what is needed. Knowing that there will be ways to use the game when I run out of official content makes me much more inclined to buy expansions and overall makes it feel better to own all of the game.

    The company should promote this in some way. Surely it is good business to have a fan base that gives the game longevitiy. Hold a design contest, perhaps?

    If you want something done then maybe do it yourself?  :)

    Rather than wait for FFG to promote Valkyrie why not promote it yourself on the forums?

    A little bit of promotion on forums such as this one and BGG may encourage others to give Valkyrie a go.


  5. 1 hour ago, Cthulhu80 said:

    Hi everyone,

    I have a similar question: I was playing  the "Dearly Departed" map and the app spawned an angry mob; in every Mythos Phase the app kept saying "the mob moves towards the closest detective", but didn't specified if the detective had to be inside or outside. What should I do in that case? If the closest detective is inside a building, does the mob move towards him/her?

    Thanks for the help!

    There is nothing in the rules specifying that the mob cannot move into an indoor space.

    So the answer to your question is Yes - the mob would move into the building.


  6. 14 hours ago, Sodiumbrella said:

    It is good to see that there are a lot of new scenarios been made. I love the idea of this app, and it has not been updated for a long time so I was a bit worried if the development was dying out, but I also have to admit that I am not using it, primarily because the interface is still just black and white boxes (at least, it was last time I checked). I know that is a really superficial reason, but I am a very visual person and the interface detracts from the experience, unfortunately.

    Everyone is entitled to their own personal opinion but not to their own personal facts.

    Quote

    I love the idea of this app, and it has not been updated for a long time so I was a bit worried if the development was dying out

    There has been numerous new versions of the app released.  I've lost count there's been so many.   There is currently a major new version in beta-test which will be released soon.

    Quote

    I also have to admit that I am not using it, primarily because the interface is still just black and white boxes (at least, it was last time I checked)

    You've not downloaded it for a long while and you've not noticed it's been updated several times.  Maybe you should check again!

    You are the only person I've come across who believes the Valkyrie interface is just black and white boxes. 

    I'm trying not to be unkind but did you download the following app?

    https://github.com/NPBruce/valkyrie/releases/tag/release/2.0/v2.0.1

    Did you check you're running it correctly?

    If you've got a very old version maybe try deleting it to ensure you are running the very latest version.

    Then give 'A Strain on Reality' a go and come back and post whether Valkyrie is just black and white boxes!


  7. 8 hours ago, TwiceBornh said:

    If I read correctly, Valkyrie isn't compatible with Apple/Mac?

    I don't own a Mac or Apple but I believe you are correct about Apple devices.

    The main issue with Apple devices is Apple have a payment licence system and I doubt if anyone will pay for a licence for Valkyrie as it's free.

    [Added]

    I believe Valkyrie does run on Mac PC's  - the issue is that iphones needs a paid licence for the apps.

    https://github.com/NPBruce/valkyrie/wiki

    In the downloads there is a download for the Mac OS.

     


  8. 15 hours ago, Duciris said:

    I'm going to complain.  Slightly.

    I wish there were a way to select not to use all of the tiles, but still use all of the other components.  I have everything MoM2, and have been keeping the game in three boxes.  I'd rather not use all of the tiles every game, because I do not have a good sorting method.

    Actually, anybody have a good tile sorting method?

    Yes.  I have tile trays.

    One tray for base and another tray for each expansion,

    https://boardgamegeek.com/image/3912648/nicola-zee

    I have all the expansions and all the trays fit nicely into the core box.

    The base of the trays I cut out of foam board.

    A friend of mine printed out the internal dividers using his 3-d printer

    https://3d.firedrake.org/#MansionsofMadness

    https://3d.firedrake.org/

     

     

     


  9. [...]

    Start with -1 Gate

    +2 Mythos Cards (randomly drawn from 2 green and 2 yellow cards), 1 put at the bottom of the pile, the other put on top (giving players 2 extra turns)

     

    Any additional (better) suggestions? :)

    When playing one investigator, I use Chris's idea of taking two turns before each Mythos Card phase.

    For odd numbers I just add 1 to the Doom track.

    If the group is experienced it's still tougher than normal but there's still a reasonable chance of winning.


  10. I would not go anywhere near any FFG game for newbies as they all take huge amounts of time on first play - EH at least a couple of hours on first play.

     

    There are some games that could (at a stretch) be useful as a teaching aid.  If you're teaching history, the board game 1775 could be a way of kids learning something of the war of independence.  Fast, fun, simple and above all quick.


  11. Agree 100% with this.  It's just plain bad game design to include a card which negates game play.  It's not as bad as adding an effect of you lose the game but it's not far off.  You can have severe game-over nasty effects but if you do you either give the players some kind of forewarning or give some way of balancing or cancelling out the effect.  The rumour cards are a good example of how to do this well.


  12. The Cthulhu Hydra mystery is not as bad as the Yig Serpent Crown mystery but its still fairly nasty compared to the other Cthulhu mysteries.  What I've done to make it less nasty is to add the following to the mystery card.

    If this mystery is the first or second mystery drawn, swap it with the third mystery card.

     

    At least it gives the group time to power up before having to attempt it.

    It also gives defeating the epic monster (as the last mystery) something of the feel of defeating a boss monster at the end of a video game.


  13. The same thing happened to me yesterday.  I decided to try out Yig for the first time by playing a 2 investigator solo game. 

    The first mystery was the Serpent of Crowns.

    Successfully completed the first expedition and retreated doom by 1.

    Successfully completed the second and gained 2 spells (way hey! - just what I didn't need).

    The next expedition ended up on the same space as the Colour out of Space monster which needs a 5 or 6 on a die roll to be defeated.

    Both investigators in the space failed the roll for 2 turns.

    Mythos deck almost exhausted, I gave up.

    To be honest it left such a sour taste, it left me with a low opinion of the FL expansion.  It seems to me to have made the game harder by adding a lot more randomness.  Before FL, EH was more skill then luck.  With FA its seems to be more luck than anything else. In addition, I wasn't a great fan of the delayed mechanism - so I wasn't that pleased with the new Lost in Time and Space miss a turn condition.

×
×
  • Create New...