Trish's story in Arkham Horror Second Edition Posted June 22, 2009 Yeah, i've wondered that myself. I can see it both ways, i suppose in the most technical sense, location abilities replace one's encounter. But I guess I always thought of them more as 'alternate encounters'.. I dunno, I think leaving the science building open to her might be okay. It's just so tough to complete her story without it. I've lost her story at least 3 times by the second mythos card, and 2 of those 3 times were with Dagon, before Trish even got a turn. Bitchiness aside, why should getting Anna Kaslow via encounter at Independence win Trish's mission, but picking Anna up at the boarding house doesn't give you the same benifit? and aside from that, where is the best location to pick up multiple clues at once? I'm thinking possibly Hibbs Roadhouse?