johnwatersfan said: I'm sorry Nghtflame, you've been playing the game wrong. Under the rules for sealing a gate it starts with the statement, "If an investigator successfully closes a gate, he may immediately spend five clue tokens to seal it." With certain exceptions (Elder sign being one of them) you must roll to close the gate first, then you spend the clues to seal it. It's going to make your Arkham games much harder from here on out.... Also, for Yog-Sothoth, it requires two successes to close a gate. It's one of the special abilities of the Ancient One. Nightflame was aware of that. His question was "Why did the initial poster not close the gate allthough he's been having rolled one success?" He said they were spending clue tokens for something ... pretty confusing posting in the first place