Jump to content

Torg

Members
  • Content Count

    150
  • Joined

  • Last visited


Reputation Activity

  1. Like
    Torg got a reaction from librerian samae in Carrie Fisher (Alt Art Leia Crew) Tributes   
    We got to go with the sly cunning smile 
     

  2. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Iceeagle85 in Rogue One Plot Hole - spoilers   
    Rogue One would not be a Star Wars film without the plot holes for fan's to talk about for years to come.
  3. Like
    Torg reacted to Drasnighta in Snipe range   
    Vehemently Disagree.

    For Visual Aid:



    Figure A:



    The Enemy Squadron is at Distance 1.  Measuring Closest Point to Closest Point, it is at Distance 1.  We may shoot this figure if we are a normal, every day squadron...
     
     
     
    Figure B:
     

     
    When we make our Range Measurement...  We find this Figure is at Distance 1....  We may shoot this squadron, if we are a normal, every day squadron...   If we have Snipe, we just determined that our distance is Distance 1...  "You may shoot at Distance 2" says nothing about shooting at Distance 1, so we cannot do it.
     
     
    Figure C:



    We have determined now, that our Target is at Distance 2...  We may snipe this Target...  We cannot shoot it normally, as we are not at Distance 1...  We are at Distance 2.
     
     
     
    Figure D:
     

     
    We have measured and determined that, the closest point of our Target is at Distance 2...  We may snipe this Target...  If we assume that Figure B is at Distance 2...  Then I WILL ASSUME that Figure D is at Distance 3, and screw you, you cannot shoot at all, because Snipe won't let you shoot at Distance 3 Target....

    ...
     
     
    Furthermore, your application of the Difference in Snipe Ratings counts for one of three Types of Squadrons with Snipe upon it.  Two Others beyond the Generic (Corran Horn and Sabre Squadron), have Snipes Equal to their Basics.
     
    That is a Minority.  Not a Majority.  You cannot apply a Majority Rules to a Minority.
    ...


    IF SNIPE WAS GIVEN AS DISTANCE 1-2, I would agree with you.

    It is not.

    Distance 2 does not include Distance 1, unless specifically stated to include Distance 1, by virtue of the Minimum-Maximum Range Band Ruling.
     
    If Distance 2 was to inherently include Distance 1, then the entire Min-Max Range Rule Section of the Rulebook is Irrelevant, Redundant, and EVERY UPGRADE THAT USES IT IS WRONG....
     
    I will not apply a rule that flies in the face of rules already presented.
     
     
    You may continue to disagree with me, if you wish, but you cannot rely on "Common Sense" and "Reading Comprehension", when I am applying the letter of said rule as part of said Reading Comprehension.
     
    If it is intended to be used at Distance 1, then there must be a rule that allows it to be used at Distance 1.
     
    I have shown that no such rule exists.
     
    You may attempt to prove me otherwise - but you must do that - prove -
     
     
    THE ONLY ARGUMENT that would modify the above, is an application of "AT" meaning if any portion of your Enemy is within Distnace 2, it is at Distance 2...
     
    THAT WOULD MEAN you could Snipe in Figures B, C and D>..
     
    BUT IT WOULD STILL NOT ALLOW YOU TO SNIPE DURING FIGURE A.
     
     
     
     
    That is all.
  4. Like
    Torg got a reaction from DurosSpacer in Dice Art   
    So dice porn or what  or did FFG censored the pictures
  5. Like
    Torg got a reaction from BlodVargarna in Best 'stand alone' Star Wars movie?   
    Star Wars (original movie) is the best of the movies so far, we were introduced to Han Solo, Luke, Leia, Old Ben, R2, the Falcon, Darth Vader, the force and Lightsabers and of course the Death Star for the first time.
  6. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Crabbok in Got a lightsaber   
    Awesome Crabbok, now don't break it 
  7. Like
    Torg got a reaction from RuusMarev in Tie Striker 'fix'   
    Nope, not needed for the game, don't try to turn the TIE Striker in to a imperial Heavy Scyk
  8. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Punning Pundit in Tie Striker 'fix'   
    Nope, not needed for the game, don't try to turn the TIE Striker in to a imperial Heavy Scyk
  9. Like
    Torg reacted to Spector1331 in AT-ST errata needed?   
    So let's take a look at what has to happen for cunning to kill the AT-ST (2 scenarios):
    1. A yellow character must be in the deck.
    2. Cunning must be in hand.
    That is the things that must happen.
    3A. Yellow character must be alive.
    4A. Cunning has to be paid for and played.
    5A. The special has to be rolled.
    6A. You have to not have the special controlled while your opponent takes his action.
    OR
    3B. Poe is in the deck and rolls a special. He resolves the cunning special side.
    So in the more common A scenario, there were steps you could have taken to not allow cunning to kill your AT-ST. In the less common B scenario Poe did his thing.
    So you're upset that your extremely strong card has a counter? That seems to be what I'm hearing unless I'm mistaken. Counters are part of the game.
    Also the AT-ST die is quite strong. 5 damage for 1 is the highest in the game, only tied by launch bay where my opponent doesn't discard. So I would not say that the die has no extraordinary sides.
    Also 6 resources is quite doable turn 2. I've seen crime lords go off on 2 and that takes 9.
  10. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Slugrage in Tie Striker 'fix'   
    Nope, not needed for the game, don't try to turn the TIE Striker in to a imperial Heavy Scyk
  11. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Flyingbrick in Tie Striker 'fix'   
    Nope, not needed for the game, don't try to turn the TIE Striker in to a imperial Heavy Scyk
  12. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Ccwebb in Tie Striker 'fix'   
    Nope, not needed for the game, don't try to turn the TIE Striker in to a imperial Heavy Scyk
  13. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Archangelspiv in Tie Striker 'fix'   
    Nope, not needed for the game, don't try to turn the TIE Striker in to a imperial Heavy Scyk
  14. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Oberron in Tie Striker 'fix'   
    Nope, not needed for the game, don't try to turn the TIE Striker in to a imperial Heavy Scyk
  15. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Scabiosus in Rogue One Plot Hole - spoilers   
    Rogue One would not be a Star Wars film without the plot holes for fan's to talk about for years to come.
  16. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Slugrage in Imperial Assualt Tabletop Game   
    IA is a tabletop game, FFG tabletop games are different from the likes of GW tabletop games
  17. Like
    Torg got a reaction from subtrendy in Imperial Assualt Tabletop Game   
    IA is a tabletop game, FFG tabletop games are different from the likes of GW tabletop games
  18. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Spidey NZ in Imperial Assualt Tabletop Game   
    IA is a tabletop game, FFG tabletop games are different from the likes of GW tabletop games
  19. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Bojanglez in Rogue One Plot Hole - spoilers   
    Rogue One would not be a Star Wars film without the plot holes for fan's to talk about for years to come.
  20. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Gadge in Best 'stand alone' Star Wars movie?   
    Star Wars (original movie) is the best of the movies so far, we were introduced to Han Solo, Luke, Leia, Old Ben, R2, the Falcon, Darth Vader, the force and Lightsabers and of course the Death Star for the first time.
  21. Like
    Torg got a reaction from derroehre in Rewards other than xp   
    If you do "force" the Recruit spec on everyone then I would suggest making Recruit not count towards there Spec count when buying a new Spec, then everyone would get a "free" spec that doesn't effect the character's and the way xp is spent.
  22. Like
    Torg got a reaction from IceQube MkII in Is there a #10-11 Ship ID Token?   
    well looking at the ships released, 11 is from the The Home One pack, and 10 is from the ISD pack, check your large base ships
  23. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Zorprime in Hrm. So what ships can they bring to the table with waves 11 and 12?   
    People are still looking for that Huge Scum Ship, also I agree they need to start slowing the pace of releases of ships.
     
    With a new Star Wars movie out each year there will plenty of new idea's for ship's from them.
  24. Like
    Torg got a reaction from Giledhil in Hrm. So what ships can they bring to the table with waves 11 and 12?   
    People are still looking for that Huge Scum Ship, also I agree they need to start slowing the pace of releases of ships.
     
    With a new Star Wars movie out each year there will plenty of new idea's for ship's from them.
  25. Like
    Torg got a reaction from SFC Snuffy in Rewards other than xp   
    Giving each player a free spec like the recruit could be a bit heavy handed, if its a one off that could lead in to a campaign then you could give the group a duty rank upgrade instead, so they could get equipment upgrade's.
     
    If the player's earn the exp required to to buy a 2nd spec then you could point them to the recruit if that's how you want the player's go down that path, or even you could make them start as recruits, so they could pick the skills they think would be useful and fun to have. 
×
×
  • Create New...