Jump to content



Photo

Usefulness of Medics?


  • Please log in to reply
31 replies to this topic

#1 Robomummy

Robomummy

    Member

  • Members
  • 255 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 05:38 AM

How useful is a medic and is really worth having one in your party. While I was GMing a game one of the players chose to be a medic. Then during game he found out medics can really only heal each player once per day with the value of their intelligence bonus (in his case 4). This seems fairly useless unless someone were dying.

Is there something I am missing or is that it for medic's healing ability?

If there is nothing I am missing and that is really all medics can do I have made some home rules for the medicae skill's first aid ability:

- Medicae: the medic player may heal any character at any point in the game, however, the medic may only heal up to 2d10+Intelligence bonus per day (reroll for a new value each day, excess healing does not carry over).

This way the medic gains a sort of health pool that they can designate which characters are in the most critical condition and heal them accordingly.


Check out my podcast Buckets Of Dice where myself and a friend review how to start various different kinds of tabletop, roleplaying, and CCG games. http://bucketsofdice.podomatic.com/ Each episode focuses on a new game, we discuss a little about the game's backround, rules, how to start/ what to buy, and a little about the company.  


#2 Musclewizard

Musclewizard

    Member

  • Members
  • 320 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 05:56 AM

I've changed how first aid works slightly (way back in DH) and I think it makes the medicae skill more useful.

Whenever you take damage you write it down seperately. For example if you take 3 damage in the first round and 2 more in the second round you write that down as 3, 2 as opposed to 5. Each wound can be treated once. The medicae test can only restore as much health as the wound has cased per wound.
Your "damage status" (lightly wounded, heavily wounded, critically wounded) applies to all wounds so getting treatment earlier is better than getting treatment later.

Overall I think the Medicae skill is useful but having a dedicated Medic isn't always neccesary.



#3 Ryath

Ryath

    Member

  • Members
  • 47 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 07:07 AM

Another thing to remember with the medicae skill is that any degree of success when making a first aid check also adds to the number of wounds healed, a med kit can also help giving you a bonus of +20 to skill checks.  You could also try and get a Cebebral Implant for your medic to give him some unnatural intelligence.

Also the game by its nature is trying to be a bit on the gritty side so can't have people healed to easy each fight as it takes away a lot of the threat of combat, but while a starting medic may only be able to heal 3 to 4 HP with every test before DoS to start with, eventualy with some bonus gear or more skill points it can be increased a bit.  



#4 AtoMaki

AtoMaki

    Member

  • Members
  • 582 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 07:09 AM

Robomummy said:

How useful is a medic and is really worth having one in your party. While I was GMing a game one of the players chose to be a medic. Then during game he found out medics can really only heal each player once per day with the value of their intelligence bonus (in his case 4). This seems fairly useless unless someone were dying.

Is there something I am missing or is that it for medic's healing ability?

If there is nothing I am missing and that is really all medics can do I have made some home rules for the medicae skill's first aid ability:

 

Okay, first, everyone with Medicae can heal. The medic's advantage is the +5 Int, starting aptitudes (he has both cheap Int and cheap Medicae) and the starting equipment. Especially the starting equipment. 

Second, with First-Aid you heal your TB+number of Degrees of Sucess on the First Aid Test. The Medic has an overall +25 bonus (+5 Int, +20 Medi-kit) to his Medicae Test, this is potentially +2 Damage removed. 

 

i think the Medic is kinda' like a compulsory member. Yeah, others can learn Medicae too, but the Medic starts with a huuuuge boost that is nigh-impossible to make up for other characters. And a party without someone with good Medicae is a dead party :)



#5 Braddoc

Braddoc

    Member

  • Members
  • 673 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 07:16 AM

I don't have my book with me, but isn't the medicae skill be used once per encounter rather than once per day?



#6 jdubb

jdubb

    Member

  • Members
  • 2 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 08:16 AM

Isn't it once every 24 hours for the person BEING treated for first aid?  ie an injured soldier can only be treated by someone with Medicae once per 24hours, whereas  a medic with Medicae can treat as many soldiers as long as he counts the full action taken



#7 Plasmafest

Plasmafest

    Member

  • Members
  • 153 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 08:22 AM

Braddoc said:

I don't have my book with me, but isn't the medicae skill be used once per encounter rather than once per day?

Braddoc said:

I don't have my book with me, but isn't the medicae skill be used once per encounter rather than once per day?

OW style Medicae can only be used to Treat (that is attempt, not necessarily successfully) someone once per 24 hours - and that's First Aid or Extended Care, not both in the same period. The PCs are very much merely mortal and quite likely to die from wounds; for instance the -50 penalty that would apply to a First Aid attempt to heal a Crit 5 injury. I believe the quote goes "A sucking chest wound is Nature's way of telling you to slow down."



#8 Robomummy

Robomummy

    Member

  • Members
  • 255 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 08:31 AM

Were are you getting this?


Check out my podcast Buckets Of Dice where myself and a friend review how to start various different kinds of tabletop, roleplaying, and CCG games. http://bucketsofdice.podomatic.com/ Each episode focuses on a new game, we discuss a little about the game's backround, rules, how to start/ what to buy, and a little about the company.  


#9 Robomummy

Robomummy

    Member

  • Members
  • 255 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 08:32 AM

sorry Ignore above post, I meant to ask where you were getting the information that a medicae can heal at anyone multiple times.


Check out my podcast Buckets Of Dice where myself and a friend review how to start various different kinds of tabletop, roleplaying, and CCG games. http://bucketsofdice.podomatic.com/ Each episode focuses on a new game, we discuss a little about the game's backround, rules, how to start/ what to buy, and a little about the company.  


#10 KommissarK

KommissarK

    Member

  • Members
  • 1,499 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 08:38 AM

Robomummy said:

sorry Ignore above post, I meant to ask where you were getting the information that a medicae can heal at anyone multiple times.

The isse you're going to see with this thread is that Medicae as a skill has changed drastically in OW as opposed to the other 40K RPG games. Even more so, it has changed quite a bit during the OW beta. Not everyone has their rules on them at any given point in time (obviously those speaking with authority do have their book with them).

I don't have my book with me right now but I'm with jdubb in that I coulda sworn the wording was that the 24 hour wait was for the patient of First Aid, not for the healer. You're definitely going to want to read through the medicae black box in the skills section, paying close attention to the First Aid action.

 

All that said, I can definitely say a medic is better than your average guardsman at healing. If there is no medic/medicae trained character present, a GM will really need to make sure there is some way to remove damage from the squad, or encourage players to not be attached to their characters.

Part of the problem is that unless you're a medic, a tech preist, a psyker or an operator, training in medicae is going to be pretty costly.



#11 AtoMaki

AtoMaki

    Member

  • Members
  • 582 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 08:46 AM

KommissarK said:

Part of the problem is that unless you're a medic, a tech preist, a psyker or an operator, training in medicae is going to be pretty costly.

 

Actually, you need to be either a Medic or an Operator to get the cheap Medicae as a basic option. STs, Ratlings and Weapon Specialists can also get it if they acquire the Intelligence aptitude. tech Priests and Psykers only have a cheap Int Advance, what won't be enough on the long run.



#12 jdubb

jdubb

    Member

  • Members
  • 2 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 09:03 AM

Robomummy said:

sorry Ignore above post, I meant to ask where you were getting the information that a medicae can heal at anyone multiple times.

 

I don't have the book in front of me, but I believe based on the wording, it is implied that using the First-Aid-Medicae skill can heal mutliple people during a given day; however each person can only be affect by First Aid-Medicae skill ONCE per 24 hours.

It is different for whatever it's called, extended care?, where a Medicae skilled person can only treat a certain number of individuals at once over a 24hour period.

 



#13 Robomummy

Robomummy

    Member

  • Members
  • 255 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 03:10 PM

KommissarK said:

Robomummy said:

 

sorry Ignore above post, I meant to ask where you were getting the information that a medicae can heal at anyone multiple times.

 

 

The isse you're going to see with this thread is that Medicae as a skill has changed drastically in OW as opposed to the other 40K RPG games. Even more so, it has changed quite a bit during the OW beta. Not everyone has their rules on them at any given point in time (obviously those speaking with authority do have their book with them).

I don't have my book with me right now but I'm with jdubb in that I coulda sworn the wording was that the 24 hour wait was for the patient of First Aid, not for the healer. You're definitely going to want to read through the medicae black box in the skills section, paying close attention to the First Aid action.

thats what I meant, I thought someone said the medic can heal anyone at will multiple times. I know they can heal once per day per player.


Check out my podcast Buckets Of Dice where myself and a friend review how to start various different kinds of tabletop, roleplaying, and CCG games. http://bucketsofdice.podomatic.com/ Each episode focuses on a new game, we discuss a little about the game's backround, rules, how to start/ what to buy, and a little about the company.  


#14 .113

.113

    Member

  • Members
  • 77 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 10:29 PM

The medic can heal the same person several times, BUT there are some restrictions…

Each "group" of wounds that you attempt to heal can only be healed once/24 hours.

 

So, if I am playing a Stormtrooper with 16 wounds, and get shot twice in the first round of combat for 4 and 5 wounds (after armor and such), and take cover behind a wall while the medic tries to heal me.. Lets say he heals me for 5 points of damage. Out of the first 2 attacks i had taken a total of 9 damage, then got healed for 5. This means I have 4 remaining wounds that are TREATED.

So if I in the few rounds of battle, or a bit later within those 24 hours, take another hit for 2 wounds (putting me at 6wounds of damage), the medic rolls and again would be able to heal 5, he would still only be able to heal those 2 later wounds, because the first 4 have already been treated.

 

So basically everytime you attempt a first aid, you treat ALL the wounds currently on that character. They are ALL treated, no matter how many of them you remove or not.

If I had taken 4 wounds, then gotten healed and then shot again for 5 wounds and healed, the medic would probably have been able to remove them all.

 

 

So yeah, a good medic of some kind is more or less essential in this game. Preferably one that will do it's best to heal wounds ASAP, to make sure there wont be too many treated, but unhealed, wounds.

 

A medic on the other hand could just as well be a Tech-priest, an operator or even a weapon specialist trained in the skill (or using an advanced kit). How ever, a group not starting with a medic should, in my personal opinion, not have as easy to get hold of first aid kits. Especially not advanced ones. But it depends on the group a bit as well. A droptrooper regiment might not be able to afford a properly trained medic, and might instead use advanced first aid kits on a designated medicae weaponspecialist. Biggest advantage of medics is they start with the kit.



#15 boooh

boooh

    Member

  • Members
  • 36 posts

Posted 01 February 2013 - 11:19 PM

Healing only 4 points of dammage sounds kinda low to me.

Im playing a medic myselve and he is able to do a lot more.

1) In 50 ( rolled maximum, +5 for medic, +5 cheap raise)

2) medic +10

3) medkit (+20)

so I roll normaly against an 80%

You heal In bonus ( 5 ) + any numer of degree of sucess

normaly he gets every player back to near Maximum after they got hit in battle.

Even heavy and critical wounded chars are at least back to fighting ability



#16 Kiton

Kiton

    Member

  • Members
  • 364 posts

Posted 02 February 2013 - 01:02 AM

A Medic's best friend is a Psyker with Endurance. The Psyker can't handle the squad's healing on his own unless people only ever get very minor damage. If the Psyker can turn Critical or Heavy wounds up a grade, the medic himself spikes rather nicely in effectiveness.

 

Characters in Only War are expected to have a couple of days to recuperate, or to try and find the time for it when they can, even if that's just lying down a few more hours in a foxhole. This may be a pacing we've not seen since DH Biomancers, DnD3.x casters and the such, but "we'll lick our wounds" is a perfectly acceptable use of your character's time.

 

Not literally though. Could result in acid, mutagens or shrapnel-cuts across your tongue. Then the medic will get angrier.



#17 .113

.113

    Member

  • Members
  • 77 posts

Posted 02 February 2013 - 01:15 AM

Well, my example was just for showing how it works.

Also an average roll would've been about 10 less, meaning 1 less point of base healing + most of the time one less DoS, so 2 points less healing than your medic does on average.

On another note, you know that you get -10 for each critical damage taken? A character with 5 critical damage would require a -50 medicae roll, quickly removing most of your bonuses :P

You might also get a -10 penalty on heavily injured characters, though I'm not entirely sure that's the case.



#18 KommissarK

KommissarK

    Member

  • Members
  • 1,499 posts

Posted 03 February 2013 - 07:28 PM

.113 said:

The medic can heal the same person several times, BUT there are some restrictions…

Each "group" of wounds that you attempt to heal can only be healed once/24 hours.

 

So, if I am playing a Stormtrooper with 16 wounds, and get shot twice in the first round of combat for 4 and 5 wounds (after armor and such), and take cover behind a wall while the medic tries to heal me.. Lets say he heals me for 5 points of damage. Out of the first 2 attacks i had taken a total of 9 damage, then got healed for 5. This means I have 4 remaining wounds that are TREATED.

So if I in the few rounds of battle, or a bit later within those 24 hours, take another hit for 2 wounds (putting me at 6wounds of damage), the medic rolls and again would be able to heal 5, he would still only be able to heal those 2 later wounds, because the first 4 have already been treated.

 

So basically everytime you attempt a first aid, you treat ALL the wounds currently on that character. They are ALL treated, no matter how many of them you remove or not.

If I had taken 4 wounds, then gotten healed and then shot again for 5 wounds and healed, the medic would probably have been able to remove them all.

Just to clarify, and I've pulled out my OW rules now: its meaningful to note that the idea of "treated" wounds is no longer present. No matter what, you can only have one First Aid action performed on your character per day. But it can be confirmed that the Medic can perform First Aid on multiple characters.

Instead of "these wounds have been treated by the First Aid action," its just an idea that "this PC has had First Aid performed on them in the last 24 hours." Its actually possible to solely use First Aid as a means of healing a character, given enough days (i.e. you don't actually need to use extended care after the first use of the First Aid action).

This is significantly different from how it works in the previous 40k line (at leas up through DW, I haven't run a game of BC).

As far as the usefulness of medics: as others have said, they get +5 int, and cheap access to pretty much all healing related talents/skills. Ultimately it comes down to how useful you find their comrade abilities to be (because after enough XP is earned, that +5 int isn't going to be that meaningful). They can improve their ability to make use of Extended Care (and thus makes them excellent healers out of combat), and most interestingly, the ablity to have comrades perform medicae checks at range (remember, First Aid is a Full Action). This is probably the key thing, as it frees up their economy of actions and allows them to aid allies without needlessly exposing themselves to enemy fire.

Overall I'd say they're useful, but by no means "mandatory" (given the removal of the idea of treated/untreated wounds for the First Aid action, the net healing they can perform daily is limited). Fortunately the increase to make degrees of success add to the final result does by all means make medic useful, and First Aid at range has plenty of uses. What would probably determine their usefulness as well is what the GM would provide the party in their absence. Does the GM opt to provide an Advanced Medkit as a part of mission gear? How well staffed are allied medical facilities? If the GM is too lenient in the absence of a Medic, then much of the Medic's usefullness is decreased. Of course, if the GM is too harsh on the matter, then the party will needlessly suffer for the sake of the players actually picking the specialties they want.



#19 .113

.113

    Member

  • Members
  • 77 posts

Posted 04 February 2013 - 04:56 AM

KommissarK said:

Just to clarify, and I've pulled out my OW rules now: its meaningful to note that the idea of "treated" wounds is no longer present. No matter what, you can only have one First Aid action performed on your character per day. But it can be confirmed that the Medic can perform First Aid on multiple characters.

Instead of "these wounds have been treated by the First Aid action," its just an idea that "this PC has had First Aid performed on them in the last 24 hours." Its actually possible to solely use First Aid as a means of healing a character, given enough days (i.e. you don't actually need to use extended care after the first use of the First Aid action).

This is significantly different from how it works in the previous 40k line (at leas up through DW, I haven't run a game of BC).

Doh, my bad :P

That's how it works then. Now I know as well :)

Though I have to admit it seems a bit odd. Imagine putting some stitches on some guy who got shot, then an hour later when the guy unfortunatly gets shot again you're like "nah I did you already".



#20 KommissarK

KommissarK

    Member

  • Members
  • 1,499 posts

Posted 04 February 2013 - 05:09 AM

.113 said:

Doh, my bad :P

That's how it works then. Now I know as well :)

Though I have to admit it seems a bit odd. Imagine putting some stitches on some guy who got shot, then an hour later when the guy unfortunatly gets shot again you're like "nah I did you already".

I think it was an attempt to simplify it because you have to admit, the previous method was a bit odd the first time you read it. If I recall, @.113, you set up a thread about it as well. Its legimitately difficult to understand on the first read, yet it is a critical piece of the game, as being injured is a problem that most certainly will come up.

Personally I'm not sure what to think, but I'm just trying to clarify whats in the book.

I think the big difference is that First Aid can indeed be used on a day to day basis as a means of healing, which definitely speeds it up. So in the end, I'm not sure which is "better." It might be justifiable in the sense that during your average day to day of war you might only see one or two big battles that result in single big encounters, whereas with DH investigations that finally result in "raiding the compound" or DW kill team missions, you might have a bit more of a running battle/series of encounters.






© 2013 Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc. Fantasy Flight Games and the FFG logo are ® of Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc.  All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact | User Support | Rules Questions | Help | RSS