Jump to content


[Standard Game] A couple rules questions after first playthrough

  • Please log in to reply
1 reply to this topic

#1 arariel



  • Members
  • 6 posts

Posted 07 January 2013 - 06:51 AM


My group spent yesterday afternoon playing Merchant of Venus, and had a blast, but we did run in to a few rules questions that we disagreed on or weren't sure, and the rule book didn't seem to address.
The one in biggest contention revolved around one of the Level 3 abilities of the Whynom pilot, which states:
"When another player enters a space with a telegate, they must pay you c10"
It very clearly states on the card that entering a telegate space, they have to pay c10. The way we read that, if you're passing along a path, and your path takes you past a telegate (even if you don't use it) you've 'entered' that space, and owe c10.
The question arises when someone passes THROUGH the telegate. They enter the first telegate space, owing c10. Then they use the telegate to travel elsewhere on the board, entering a SECOND telegate space. Do they owe another c10, essentially making the cost of passing a telegate c10, and using a telegate c20?
Some of us said the card expressly states "enters a space" which they are doing twice. Others feel that the fact that moving from one telegate to another costs zero movement points means they aren't entering the second telegate space. How does the pilot ability actually work?
The second question, was about a mission that required the player "active 2 different ship upgrades on a single turn" which we read as "assigning a die" because everywhere in the rulebook, it says "assigns a die" and does not use the phrase "activate"
If you roll your move, and have, say… Steath AND Variable Lasers. Do you actually have to make USE of the upgrades in order to have them count as activated, or if you simply opt to assign the dice to them, do they count as "activated" for that turn, even if they don't get used, thus completing the mission?

#2 willsmonkey



  • Members
  • 1 posts

Posted 20 January 2013 - 06:39 AM

When passing through Telegate space you always have to 'come out the other side' somewhere.  Whether this is through assigning a die to navigation, rolling the effects die or not getting a result and just passing through the same Telegate.  So my group thought it makes sense that you only pay once ie.  You only pay once to pass through the gate, regardless of where you end up.

With regard your second question we absolutely thought activating a ship upgrade means it must be used.  Eg. Variable Lasers used in a Laser check, using market flux to cycle through a market.  I actually thought it came up in one of the rules, but having looked again I couldn't see anything.

I couldn't see anything concrete on either of these, but that's what we did.

© 2013 Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc. Fantasy Flight Games and the FFG logo are ® of Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc.  All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact | User Support | Rules Questions | Help | RSS