I'm playing a game tonight and was hoping someone could offer their opinion in time.
We like the surprise factor of the Cylon Attack cards, but like the more agreesive Cylon Fleet option. Would it not work to include both using the following rules:
1) Cylon Attack Cards take precedence, so whatever ships are on the Fleet board fill up requirements on the attack cards.
2) If Cylon Attack cards do not appear in a while the fleet acts as normal
3) Once a Cylon reveals himself Cylon Attack cards are ignored and the Cylon(s) may play the fleet behind a screen to keep the element of surprise (this would obvously require player trust)