I've been lurking on these forums since I started playing WFRP this spring. I enjoyed the game a lot though we have only had maybe 15 sessions. Most of the group is new to table top roleplaying games, myself included. Our GM has done a good job trying to manage our inexperienced group but hasn't had a chance to be a player in 7 years, and doesn't have as much time to prep. I've offered to take over as GM, which I'm equally excited and terrified of. The first big decision I have to make is what to run (Andy, if you're reading this, stop now).
I could go with a pregenerated scenario, I'm going to take over after we finish The Gathering Storm (careful, I don't know how it ends, we've killing goblins near some cattle ranches right now) and Eye for an Eye has already been run for the group. As a player, I haven't read all the scenarios, and I wouldn't want to in case I take a turn as player again sometime. What is a good scenario to run for a Noob GM to run after Gathering Storm?
I have a few ideas to put together a custom scenario which would specifically target the Hero's deeds and backgrounds in an attempt to discredit them. My character would be the catalyst as he is caught and hanged for desertion, which would be the opening move in a power struggle between a Noble of Stromdorf and the Burghermiester. The characters as agents of the Burghermiester would be specifically targeted, and would have to prove thier innocence and improve conditions in the town to reinforce the Burghermiesters standing. One of the chief benefits I see to this is really forcing the players to engage because it's thier honour and reputation on the line. To tie them closely to allies in the town who are taking a beating and put the Noble in front of them the entire time taunting them and trying to drive them mad. Currently we're all fairly new role players, and so it's a bit stiff and dry when we interact, my theory is that this would give them more emotional stake in the game.
My questions for everyone here would be:
How much harder is it to do your own adventure rather than a pre-created one?
Is it a good idea to "go after" the players agressively? Accusing them of everything I can, Slandering them, or will that frustrate and discourge them? What is the balance between "Grim, Gritty" and "The GM is a **** who makes everything turn on us all the time, why bother when we'll get no credit?
Do you have tips for a new gm?