Hah we always liked the idea that you were sacrificing him to appease the elder gods yet it somehow restored your sanity. The choice of wording on the card is pretty poor in regards to sacrifice. And Brinton is impossible to explain hah maybe he slipped in a big soup bowl you were eating out of and you didn't realize it or something haha.
Oh, and another card we always got a good laugh at and also hated as investigators. I'm paraphrasing…
"The stars are aligned differently. Lose 1 sanity"
I don't know how many times that sent someone to the asylum haha.