Jump to content



  • Please log in to reply
1 reply to this topic

#1 Peacekeeper_b



  • Members
  • 2,485 posts

Posted 23 June 2012 - 07:19 AM


So far my biggest dislike is the comrades rules. I am not against such rules or anything, but I find them to be a bit of a cop out. For example, the Commissar's Summary Execution ability allows him to kill a NPC (Comrade) when a PC is severely injured to let the PC continue and to ignore his injuries until the end of the encounter.



It makes no sense. "Ah hell, Jennings stepped on a land mine!" Says the Commissar turing to CPL NPC Bouregard as he draws his bolt pistol. BANG! "Get up Jennings!" So as a Commissar I kill a perfectly healthy guradsman because another guardsman gets serious injured? I rather it work to increase morale because the commissar is allowed to kill you if you run. Such as a +10 or +20 to Fear/Terror/Whaterver checks as long as the Commissar also makes his or her check and have the bonus extend to everyone in the immediate area of the commissar because HE IS ALLOWED TO KILL Y OU. I mean what happens if only 2 PCs are left? Does the commissar kill one of them? Kill himself?

Maybe base it more on the wargame, with Stubborn (no penalty to fear/morale checks when lead by a commissar) or even oldschool 3E 40K version (which included summary execution and gave a +1 LD bonus).

Summary Execution

As a Commissar serving the front lines in the wars against the enemies of the Imperium, you carry the authority to execute those found wanting. Whenever you are present when a NPC or PC in the Imperial Guard fails a Willpower test against or any other variaiton of morale in combat you can make an immediate reaction Intimidation test. If you succeed the target is permitted to retake the Willpower test with a bonus of +10 per degree of success you recieved on your intimidation test. If they PC or NPC fails the second time you immediately shoot him or her at point blank range with an automatic head shot.


#2 lostguardguy



  • Members
  • 24 posts

Posted 12 October 2012 - 06:45 PM

This actually makes alot of sense. Look at it this way. You and your squad are walking along and you step on a land mine or are in the middle of a fire fight and your leg gets a good chunk blown off. Now blood is flying every where and even with your adrian pumping that leg hurts something awful and your thinking of quiting. Then suddenly you hear PFC Redshirt yelling "THEY GOT HIM MAN! GAME OVER MAN! GAME OVER!" and turning to run. Instently without missing a beat the Commissar pivits on his heels and puts a round in the back of his head immediately followed by the bolt shell exploding and showering you with blood and brain mater. "THIS IS THE EMPEROR'S WORLD AND HE WILL HAVE IT! Such is the of any that halt the Emperor's will." the Commissar says gaze fixed on you. YOU ARE NOW MOTAVATED.

© 2013 Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc. Fantasy Flight Games and the FFG logo are ® of Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc.  All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact | User Support | Rules Questions | Help | RSS