For example Wilson’s Richards shotgun removed from the deck in scenario nine or Sister Mary’s cross is unavailable due to both of them being used.
I could still see giving Mary here Cross sense it’s not a scenario i.e. make a proxy of one.
but Wilson’s shotgun? These are possible outcomes I’ve thought of…
I’m leaning towards number one due to the fact all investigators get around 25 dollars worth of staring equipment (read this somewhere in old forums).
That way it would stay true to the Scenario and to the character’s monetary value for staring equipment.