order in which to get the expansions
Posted 31 May 2013 - 03:42 AM
Posted 31 May 2013 - 10:07 AM
Getting them in the order they were released is certainly a good thing. You'll experience in this way something similar to what happened to many Arkham die-harders, and in some way maybe this is the best way to enjoy the ride.
Anyway, as you could imagine, this question was already asked countless times, so, if you want detailed answers, it's better if you use the search function of the forum with keywords "order expansions", I'm pretty sure you'll find a lot of answers.
Finally, my suggestion is:
a) Dunwich: most of the components are the perfect complement for the base game, and a larger board forces you to understand properly how to deal with the Mythos; plus, Injuries and Madnesses, really necessary to completely enjoy the Arkham experience
b) Kingsport: the definitive second expansion boards. No unstable locations, but a great new mechanics (rift), and tons of items, monster, Ancient Ones, Heralds and so on; all aspects of the game are enhanced (but having no unstable location this is not a good "first board expansion")
c) Innsmouth: the most difficult, brutal, nasty, evil board ever. But for tons of technical reasons, it's not a good "first board expansion" (not to mention that noobs will be butchered by the difficulty of the game if they start from here)
and finally, add the small ones.
Custom Arkham Horror material / Arkham Horror Advanced Players League
Posted 31 May 2013 - 02:56 PM
Big fan of Dunwich Horror for the 1st Big Box Expansion and the King in Yellow for the 1st Small Box Expansion. Once you've enjoyed these for awhile, bring-in Curse of the Dark Pharoah, Kingsport, Innsmouth, and Miskatonic. Black Goat of the Woods is cool and very thematic, but painful to try to introduce as it's quite affected by dilution.
Posted 12 June 2013 - 04:08 PM
I have a list at home (at work at present) of the order I worked out I wanted them based on rules implemented. I can't find the exact site article I found it in (someone rated each aspect out of 5, very good article if I could find it >.>).
Anyway, at present I own just Dunwich, Lurker, and Black Goat but plan on more when finances allow.
The article I did find though is here.
That article isn't too long but goes into the big box expansions and the features of each as well as doing a numbered list of a suggested order and the reasons of what they each bring to the table in each.
I agree with the list but I can easily get the small expansions over bigs, so generally I get the big ones first if I can afford it. My next I believe was going to be Miskatonic to enhance what I have and prepare me for the rest I buy, otherwise I agree with that list
Edited by Jayven, 03 July 2013 - 03:24 AM.
Ooo, Shiny! Blog
Tabletop Gaming Collection @ Board Game Geek / Roleplaying Game Collection @ RPG Geek