Actually let me try to make my point better by asking you two questions: 1. Do YOU personally have rules clarification issues with Elder Sign? 2. Do you or do you not believe that FFG did a great job with the rules, design, and balance of Elder Sign?
Yeah, that's better!
I'm not here to debate my personal view of the rules, but to collect questions. When I said "rules are nifty", that's objective: if rules were so streamlined and cleared, nobody would have kept on asking the same questions over and over and over since the game had been released. So that, focusing on finding about what people get confused on, is one of the main aim of the FAQ project.
If there were no need for a new FAQ, then nobody would have answered the call, the thread would have gone deserted, and so on. But we got questions.
Additionally, an FAQ document shouldn't only address "obscure" points in the rulebook, but also help guiding players of all levels (from the rules lawyers to the occasional gamers) in understanding better what happens. For instance, lots of people over the BGG argued for ages about the "when I kill a monster locking a die, may I add that die to my dice pool befor the end of my Resolution Phase or not?". I think rules are clear, but people keep on arguing about this, so that having an FAQ entry with this question stated would help undoubtably these players.
And in any case, having an updated FAQ document won't hurt anyone.
EDIT: and please, do not flame this thread.
Edited by Julia, 28 June 2014 - 02:20 AM.