Do turret weapons make us dumb ?
Posted 05 April 2014 - 09:38 PM
I did quite a bit of research on what ships to buy first, what is good for beginners etc.
One of the recurring suggestions that was put forth was "buy a yt-1300" they a re a good ship for beginning players due to their 360 arc of fire.
Also suggested were the Y-wing's with ion turret.
Now I can see the merit of this, and I agree that its mostly good advice. Some new people might have a hard time with the whole "line em up in your sights" approach that most of the other ships use.
However, this got me to thinking : is this really the best way to get people introduced to the game?
I ask this because in my opinion after you get used to having the freedom to shoot whomever the hell you want, it sometimes frustrates people when they switch to the more complex ships and have to really start relying on their actual ability to pilot their ship and thus. ... The training wheels are off.
So what do the rest of you all think?
Should we continue to suggest the 360 line of fire as a good beginning, or should we maybe examine our teaching credentials and perhaps go with another de-facto ship as the best beginner.
There is obviously pros and cons to this topic, I could list a metric crap ton of them, but I was trying to keep it from becoming a wall of BOOORRRING text ...zzzzzzz
Posted 05 April 2014 - 09:42 PM
I can definitely see the turret weapons as being a crutch, aye. Annoyingly, their sheer existence is a nerf on mobility, which is otherwise an incredible factor.
Heck, if we got rid of them, the Tie Advanced might actually be worth playing.
Posted 05 April 2014 - 09:44 PM
Well, Y-wings with ions have benefits unrelated to their turret-ness; they're control ships, and I don't actually regard them as particularly beginner-ey. The Falcon definitely is a bit easier to learn to fly, but it has a learning curve of its own: it's easier than many ships to fly competently, but it's just as difficult to fly it well.
So I guess… I think X-wings make a good on-ramp to the game for one reason, and a Falcon for other reasons.
- DraconPyrothayan and IvlerIin like this
Posted 05 April 2014 - 09:45 PM
X-Wings and TIE/Ln units are straight out of the box and perfect for learning how each faction works without getting into more nitty gritty details. If turrets are a crutch, then you simply have to learn to fly better than the ships with the turrets. With the exception of Horton Salm, Y-Wings suck at range 3 for fighting capability (before anyone mentions torpedoes, that's an exception that any other ship can take.)
- Hrathen and Stone37 like this
Alliance Fleet: 4 X-Wings, 3 Y-Wings, 3 A-Wings, 2 B-Wings, 2 HWK-290, 2 YT-1300, 1 GR-75
Imperial Navy: 5 TIE Fighters, 1 TIE Bomber, 2 TIE Interceptors, 1 TIE Advance x1, 1 Lambda Class Shuttle, 2 Firespray 31
Posted 05 April 2014 - 09:50 PM
I equate this to teaching kids to drive a car by making them start on a hill with a stick shift and making them do it until they don't roll backwards.
In unrelated news, I appear to be out of friends.
- Red Castle, Chris Maes, VanorDM and 19 others like this
Rebel Scum: 7x X-Wing 6x Y-Wing 5x A-Wing 3x YT-1300 4x B-Wing 6x HWK-290 3x GR-75 Transport 1x Corellian Corvette 8x Z-95 Headhunter 3x E-Wing
Imperial Heroes: 8x TIE Fighter 4x TIE Advanced 13x TIE Interceptor 3x Firespray-31 6x TIE Bomber 4x Lambda Shuttle 3x TIE Defender 4x TIE Phantom
Posted 05 April 2014 - 09:59 PM
Honestly x-wings are probably the best balanced ships in the game, plus every beginner knows what they are. I think it's better to wait and introduce the uber-yt1300 of doom and then it seems more impressive.
Posted 05 April 2014 - 10:25 PM
Honestly I'd say the B wing should be the de facto beginner ship. It hits hard, has a decent dial and is very forgiving as far as tankiness goes without having a turret.
Posted 05 April 2014 - 10:33 PM
I suggest beginners start with 4 shuttles without engines.
In unrelated news, I appear to be out of friends.
Thank you for this. I chuckled out loud quite a bit.
I think it depends on the kind of gamer;
Hardcore gamer with a knack for strategy and stacked odds? Hand him/her the core ships (or something more difficult if he/she's up to the challenge) and see what he/she does with them.
Casual gamer who's strategy consists of "Do I, or do I not buy Park Place?"? Maybe give him something easier to fly to see how much he/she enjoys it.
That being said, I think there is a reason they didn't release the Falcon or Turrets in the base set.
The Tie fighter and the X-Wing seem the perfect ways to learn to fly (at least for me, my wife, and all my friends who have learned to play with me)
They also leave plenty of room to appreciate bonuses and drawbacks of the other ships XWM has to offer.
Galactic Empire: 8x Tie Fighters, 1x Tie Advance, 1x Tie Bomber, 2x Firespray 31,
Rebel Alliance: 4x X-Wings, 1x A-Wing, 1x B-Wing, 1x YT1300,
--Proud Member of the Imperial Navy--
Posted 05 April 2014 - 10:33 PM
I think the key word here is "crutch". Some folks like to look for an "I win" button, or they use turrets to take one less
Equation out of the game thus kind of creating a peusdo auto pilot for thier lists.
Now don't get me wrong, I love me some Falcon action it was one of the first ships I got and flew well.
But I kind of had a harder time of things when my A wings arrived and I wanted to go into different lists.
This is what got me to wondering what this kind of info does for other beginners.
Posted 05 April 2014 - 10:50 PM
- AdmiralThrawn likes this
Rebels: (5) X-Wings, (4) Y-Wings, (2) A-Wings, (2) B-Wings, (2) YT-1300s, (2) HWK-290s
Imperials: (9) TIE Fighters, (2) TIE Advanced, (2) TIE Interceptors, (2) TIE Bombers, (2) Lambda Shuttles, (2) Firespray-31s, (2) Imperial Aces
Posted 05 April 2014 - 11:05 PM
On the flip side I definitely wouldn't lead new players to Y-Wings w/ ions. They are fine but there are much better ships imo.
Posted 05 April 2014 - 11:43 PM
Teaching players by using the Falcon and you start by teaching them about turrets, crew, actions, firing arcs, titles and the stuff the Empire can do (who don't have turrets anyway), instead of the ease of teaching in an X-Wing.
Edited by Dagonet, 05 April 2014 - 11:47 PM.
- jasonkw likes this
Posted 06 April 2014 - 06:14 AM
Use of turrets is as tactical as any other aspect of the game. You've got to maximize your capabilities and minimize your deficiencies. Do they require as precise flying? Not necessarily, but you still have to be able to gauge your opponent's moves, and make the right choice to put your ships in the right place.
I personally love turrets, they're a great way to deal with flankers and low-agi enemy ships. But to each his/her own.
5 X, 3 B, 2 A, 2 Y, 1 Hwk.
6 TIE, 2 TIE B. 2 Ints, 1 Adv
Ordered: 1 Defender, 2 Phantoms
Posted 06 April 2014 - 06:56 AM
Posted 06 April 2014 - 06:58 AM
For me, the advantage to starting someone out on the Falcon is that it is so forgiving for them. When my wife first expressed interest in playing, she asked if she could use the Falcon and to me, it made perfect sense. It's cool, it's big, it's durable, and it's beginner friendly. This was all particularly good for me since my wife is not exactly a gamer.
When we started playing then, she made a couple of "sketchy" moves. Moves that didn't really make sense and which would have put her in a horrible position had she not been running the Falcon (i.e. she would not have had anyone in her arc). If she had not been running the Falcon, it would have been a thrashing. Instead, she was able to continue to complete and recover from the mistakes and she had a lot of fun.
Now, that being said, now that she is enjoying the game, she has specifically been avoiding the Falcon because she wants to get good at maneuvering, etc. Plus, she seems to like the Darkside. lol I am noticing; however, that she is struggling with some of the more subtle aspects of the game still. She's been struggling with the interceptors for instance because she hasn't quite figured out how to combine boosts and/or barrel rolls so as to get my ship in her arc while placing herself outside of mine.
In the end, I think it really comes down to each particular person, but I sort of equate it to would you teach a new driver on a Camry or on a Lamborghini? (a bit of an exaggeration I realize).
Posted 06 April 2014 - 07:26 AM
True, a turret does let your flying get sloppy and you still get to shoot. But, the finesse in using a turret is choosing the maneuver that gets you out of your opponent's firing arc, and then using the turret to keep your shot.
I love it when I can fly my Y-wing parallel to my opponent. It is such a sweet feeling when the drive-by works....
Edited by TnT, 07 April 2014 - 08:56 AM.
- polmoneys, LeoHowler and Bohrdumb like this
Posted 06 April 2014 - 10:01 AM
The only people I know who cry about turret weapons are the ones who do not understand them, how they work, and how to play with/against them.
There is no 'shame' to use a turret weapon, it is not a 'crutch', it's just another srategy that has it's own strengths and weaknesses. Anyone who puts you down for your choice of ship/weapon is not worth playing with.
- LeoHowler and IvlerIin like this
Posted 06 April 2014 - 11:30 AM
I don't think playing the first games with a YT is bad but a character does need to branch out so it doesn't become old habbit.
While the YT-1300 may have that turret primary you still CAN make sure it is aware of its fire-arc and how important it can be. One way is to put a missile on the the ship although I'll need to admit that one missile doesn't always compare well to a 360 degree primary backed up by Gunner. The other thing to throw in to at least may the YT owner aware of the firing arc is Backstabber; yes, he may get shot down right away but player should learn that if he's within that wedge he's only attacking with 2 dice instead of 3 if he is attacking from somewhere else. I'm not sure how many apply to the Falcon but some upcome abilities also seem to care about the firing arc for things other than attacking.
1. Turret = Good for first taste but should move one to avoid it becoming a crutch.
2. Make sure firing arc is important in other ways besides just shooting the primary weapon.
Posted 06 April 2014 - 03:08 PM
Turrets are always attached to low agility ships. Focused fire brings them down quickly. Yes, the YT has a ton of hull and shields, but only one defense die. Three interceptors with focus and/or TL shooting at it every round is going to make short work of it if only the YT can fire back. The key, for rebel players, is to protect your turrets with harder to hit fighters. There is a reason why HSF has two X-wings in the build.
Posted 06 April 2014 - 07:39 PM
I maintain that the YT isn't just not the best beginner ship. It is hands down the worst beginner ship by several miles. You're better off starting with a Lambda (a support ship requiring you to understand the mechanics well enough to understand how it affects them) than a Falcon.
The Falcon's a good beginner ship if you're out to win those early games. It's tough, it's forgiving and it's easy to use. However, if you're out to learn how to play the game, it's awful. The Falcon is so easy to fly because it completely disregards a major game mechanic: the firing arc. With this mechanic stripped out, you won't learn to fly the rest of the game's ships, and neither will the person flying against your Falcon. At a beginner level and/or with very few ships on the field, introducing the Falcon can easily turn your game into little more than a "who rolls the best dice results" match.
Avoiding and lining up arcs is near meaningless to the Falcon. It can't be outmaneuvered or flanked because anything that can hit it it can hit back. It's a beast against TIEs, which is pretty likely to make up the entirety of your opponent's beginner squad, and your opponent won't be learning how to stay of of arcs (because with the Falcon they can't) any more than you'll be learning how to get ships in them. Even the choice of maneuver on the dial, which makes up a whole phase of the turn, is pretty much moot to the Falcon unless it hits something, at least at beginner level.
Don't get me wrong, the Falcon isn't a bad ship and using turrets doesn't make you a bad player, but if you're a beginner or teaching a beginner, don't touch the YT with a 5,000 ft pole. You will not learn the game flying with or against the YT at all. Don't go anywhere near it until you're confident with X-wing. To give a car analogy, the Falcon's an automatic and all the other ships are manuals. You can drive an automatic after learning on manuals but not the other way around.
The best beginner ships are the ones in the starter: the X-wing and the TIE fighter. For the price of the Falcon, you can get the X-wing and TIE fighter expansions to go with the starter, which gives you a good range of options in squadbuilding, a fun set of ships to fly and you'll learn the game while doing it. Most of the stuff I know about playing X-wing came from those early, smaller scale X-wings versus TIE fighters matches.
Edited by Lagomorphia, 06 April 2014 - 07:56 PM.
- LeoHowler, Dagonet and AdmiralThrawn like this